83 réponses à ce sujet

[Remmirath]

From one to ten here, with ten being perfect (and therefore, nothing is ever likely to get a ten) and one being 'it was horrible, I could've even finish it'. Also, this is a lot more of how much I enjoyed it as opposed to some ultimate value.

Baldur's Gate: 9.5
Baldur's Gate II: 9.75
Neverwinter Nights: 3 for the original campaign, 8 for the multiplayer/toolset aspect.
Knights of the Old Republic: 7.5
Dragon Age: Origins: 7.75
Mass Effect: I haven't actually finished yet, but it's looking like 5.
Dragon Age II: 6.5

[Archdemon Cthulhu]

Neverwinter Nights: 6/10
Baldur's Gate 2: 7/10 (Don't hurt me?)
Knights of the Old Republic: 9.5/10
Jade Empire: 9/10
Mass Effect: 9/10
Mass Effect 2: 10/10
Dragon Age: Origins: 9/10
Dragon Age 2: 8.5/10
MDK2: 8/10

Never Played: Shattered Steel, Baldur's Gate, Sonic Chronicles

[Johnsen1972]

*slaps Archdemon Cthulhu*
You cant give BG2 a 7 out of 10!

Modifié par Johnsen1972, 25 mars 2011 - 08:20 .

[Archdemon Cthulhu]

Johnsen1972 wrote...

*slaps Archdemon Cthulhu*
You cant give BG2 a 7 out of 10!

Look, I respect the game, but I'm just not an "old school" RPG guy I guess( though I do wuite liek Planescape: Torment, so who knows).  I found the combat tedious, and even though I plowed through it, it wasn't nearly as satisfying as other Bioware games I've played.  That said, I also played it AFTER I played KoToR, Mass Effect, Jade Empire, and DA;O.  So it might've taken a hit for being such an old game played in comparison to newer ones

[MrDizazta]

*slaps Halae Dral*
You gave Mass Effect a 5?

[Johnsen1972]

Archdemon Cthulhu wrote...

Look, I respect the game, but I'm just not an "old school" RPG guy I guess( though I do wuite liek Planescape: Torment, so who knows).  I found the combat tedious, and even though I plowed through it, it wasn't nearly as satisfying as other Bioware games I've played.  That said, I also played it AFTER I played KoToR, Mass Effect, Jade Empire, and DA;O.  So it might've taken a hit for being such an old game played in comparison to newer ones

ok I forgive you, I played it like 12 years ago. I dont think I would like to play it today, but 12 years ago it was an awesome game.

[bussinrounds]

I'm playing it right now and it's great.

But i am an old school rpg guy. It also helps if you come from a d&d backround.

[Johnsen1972]

I have been playing the first rules set of D&D from gary gygax, I was 13 years old or something like that. I have been a table top roleplaying nerd. D&D wasnt that popular when it started...

Modifié par Johnsen1972, 26 mars 2011 - 12:36 .

[bussinrounds]

Nice. Gary was THE MAN. RIP.

But Baldurs IS still an awesome game. Unless your a big graphics guy, i guess.

[MajorStranger]

DAO: 9/10
DA Awakening: 7/10
DA2: 6/10
ME1: 9/10
ME2: 9/10
KOTOR: 9/10
Jade Empire:  7.5/10

[ChrisBGoose341]

DAO: 94/100
DA Awakening: 81/100
DA2: 86/100
ME1: 89/100
ME2: 96/100
BG1: N/A
BG2: N/A
KOTOR: 97/100 2: 80/100
NWN: N/A
Jade Empire: 80/100
MDK2: N/A
Sonic Cronicles: N/A
Shattered Steel: N/A

[MaaZeus]

Johnsen1972 wrote...

Archdemon Cthulhu wrote...

Look, I respect the game, but I'm just not an "old school" RPG guy I guess( though I do wuite liek Planescape: Torment, so who knows).  I found the combat tedious, and even though I plowed through it, it wasn't nearly as satisfying as other Bioware games I've played.  That said, I also played it AFTER I played KoToR, Mass Effect, Jade Empire, and DA;O.  So it might've taken a hit for being such an old game played in comparison to newer ones

ok I forgive you, I played it like 12 years ago. I dont think I would like to play it today, but 12 years ago it was an awesome game.

Oh, it hasnt lost its charm a one bit. I just played it a year or so ago, with some mod added it was a blast to wander in the world of Forgotten Realms again.

[Johnsen1972]

nice, maybe if Im bored and Witcher 2 doesnt come out soon, I will play it again.

[conan.cimmerian99]

Baldur's Gate 1 9.3/10
Baldur's Gate 2 9.8/10
Jade Empire 9.2/10
Star Wars: Knight of the old Republic 9.4/10
Neverwinter Nights 8.8./10
Mass Effect 8.5/10
Mass Effect 2 9.5/10
Draogn Age: Origins 9/10
Dragon Age 2: 8.7/10

[Leinadi]

If 5 is about an average (just rating the main campaigns here and how I enjoyed them subjectively speaking):

Baldurs Gate: 6/10
Baldurs Gate 2: 8/10
Neverwinter Nights: 2/10
Knights of the Old Republic: 3/10
Jade Empire: 5/10
Mass Effect 3/10
Dragon Age Origins: 9/10
Mass Effect 2: 5/10
Dragon Age 2: 4/10

[A Killing Sound]

Knights of the Old Republic: 10/10
Mass Effect: 10/10
Mass Effect 2: 8/10
Dragon Age Origins: 7/10
Jade Empire: 5/10

[xCirdanx]

Shattered Steel - 6/10 (as far as i remember it, that was long ago)
Baldurs Gate - 9/10
Baldurs Gate 2 - 10/10 (best game ever )
Neverwinter Nights 9/10
MDK2 - 7/10
Star Wars KotoR - 9/10
Jade Empire - 8/10
Sonic Chronicles 6/10
Mass Effect - 9/10
Mass Effect 2 - 7/10
DA:O - 8/10 (ignoring Awakening...)
Dragon Age 2 - 5/10

[KenKenpachi]

DAO: 7.5 /10 not a bad game, but parts of it its like....sigh lets get out of here so I can finish. It just drags along too much for my liking in parts. Still a solid game.

DA Awakening:7/10 some parts of the game were fantastic but others bummed me out.

DA2: 8/10 I have to give it an 8, I know others won't but will I like what I like you like what you like.

ME1: 8/10 too slow paced in parts. But still pretty good game from its story.

ME2: 8.5-9/10 suffers same faults at parts as the former, but minus a few things is a better game.

BG1: 4/10 see below.

BG2: 5/10 Not my cup of tea I'm a legend of Dragoon, FF7 man. Its not looks or how long it is for me As the two I mentioned were multi disc and long games, I just liked playing those, same with the "tales of" games. And I have never finished a Pen and Paper game, or actully been asked to one, so I don't share the same "love" for the game. If I want a tactical game, I'll hit up Rainbow 6, or play an RTS.

Warhammer, want to play haven't seen it.

KOTOR: 9/10 KOTOR 2 though not by the same gets a 7/10

NWN: 6/10 Bit slow for me. Have not played he 2nd one.

Jade Empire: 9/10 really loved the setting, but controls were iffy and keeps it from a ten.

MDK2: N/A

Sonic Cronicles: IT should be burned 3/10

Shattered Steel: N/A

Modifié par KenKenpachi, 26 mars 2011 - 10:43 .

[Alexine]

Knights of the Old Republic: 6.5/10 Only done one playthrough. I wasn't a huge fan of Star Wars, but I felt the story was a bit dull for my tastes. However, KOTOR 2 sold me more to Star Wars universe than KOTOR did.

Jade Empire: 9.5/10 The game that introduced me to Bioware games. Very ambitious, and pulled off quite well. I think the combat was alright (didn't find the controls chunky like all the others)

Mass Effect 1: 8/10 Pretty decent game. The story was amazing, but the gameplay was lacking.

Mass Effect 2: 8/10 A good improvement in gameplay and game mechanics, but sorely lacking in story content. Not really an improvement if you ask me

Dragon Age: Origins: 7/10 As much as I like High Fantasy, I felt the story to be a bit hollow and filled out. Gameplay wise I liked, but got a bit too repetitive.

Dragon Age 2: Haven't played yet, but will soon.

[Tobebech1307]

KOTOR: 9/10
ME 9/10
ME2 9/10
DA 9.5/10
DA2 7/10
JE 7/10

[Ramirez Wolfen]

KOTOR: 8/10
ME: 9/10
ME2: 9/10
DAO: 6/10
DA2: 7/10

[JRCHOharry]

KOTOR: 7.5/10
ME: 7.9/10
ME2: 9.1/10
DAO: 8.3/10
DA2: 7.8/10

Modifié par JRCHOharry, 27 mars 2011 - 03:30 .

[Swordfishtrombone]

Baldur's Gate 1: 5.5/10
Baldur's Gate 2: 10/10
Throne of Bhaal (BG2 expansion): 9/10
Icewind Dale: 6.5/10
Neverwinter Nights: 7/10
The "Shadows of Undrentide" expansion for NWN: 7/10
The "Hordes of Underdark" expansion for NWN: 8.5/10
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: 8/10
Mass Effect: 9/10
Mass Effect 2: 9/10
Dragon Age: Origins: 9/10
Dragon Age 2: 8/10

[DarthCaine]

Neverwinter Nights: 2/5

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic: 6/5

Jade Empire: 3/5

Mass Effect: 4/5

Dragon Age: Origins: 5/5

Mass Effect 2: 5/5

Dragon Age II: 3/5

Modifié par DarthCaine, 27 mars 2011 - 05:12 .

[Seagloom]

Neverwinter Nights with Shadows of Undrentide and Hordes of the Underdark expansions - 10/10

Baldur's Gate II with Throne of Bhaal - 9/10

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic - 8/10

Jade Empire - 8/10

Baldur's Gate - 7/10

Dragon Age: Origins - 7/10

Mass Effect - 6/10