Aller au contenu

Photo

Oh no! gayness is making its way into the gaming world!!


  • Ce sujet est fermé Ce sujet est fermé
387 réponses à ce sujet

#251
Zandilar

Zandilar
  • Members
  • 312 messages

ostemanden wrote...
I try to avoid homosexuals, and other sexual deviants. Simply because I have had enough of the "hey, look at me, I am homosexual" that we see today. I understand why it was needed, but I think you are doing yourself a "bears favor" today, insisting on informing people, and demanding that they take a public stance, to what is supposed to be your private life.


The thing is, visibility matters. If some of us don't stand up to be counted, then homosexuality will alwasy be a dirty little secret hidden away in a closet, always treated as "other" and "wrong". This will mean that gay people will continue to be killed, by means legal and otherwise depending on the country you're in. (There are some countries in the world where the punishment for homosexual behaviour is death, by the way.) I agree that some of us are a little too out there, but they deserve just as much respect as those of us who could pass for straight. The same could be said of other "sexual deviants" who happen to be heterosexual, and there's a lot more of them than homosexuals in the world! (By the way, despie it's somewhat inocuous meaning "outside the norm", deviant is a rather emotionally charged word.)

I've found the best way to handle things is simply this - live and let live. If they're not hurting you, why be bothered by what they do (short of harming others, of course)?

Therefore I am very exclusive as to what forums I visit, I chose to stay away from places where sexuality, religion and politics are disccused, simply because it is a waste of my own private energy. It is therefore a frustration when I do make a choise, about what I want to read about, and is then forced to read about other peoples sexuality on a forum for games. I do not mind the general discusssion, about whether or not homosexuality and bisexuality should be included in the game, I do feel that is totally relevant, and in context of this forum.


Sexuality, religion, and politics (or lack of any of the above), are three fundamental topics that inform our point of view. I am not sure if you've been successful at finding a fourm that avoids discussions of all three from time to time, but I suspect such a fourm would be extremely rare (orange as opposed to purple or blue. ;))

I can understand the frustration to a certain extent, but I am one of those who actually enjoys discussing those things.

What I do not understand is why, everytime homosexuality is discussed, "you" homosexuals always have to tell us your life story, aswell as your political view.


Because heterosexuals also feel this need, to clarify their point of view - because sexuality and politics inform our view point of the world (along with religion, and countless other things). It's fundamental to communication, how can you understand a person's view point if you don't know where they're coming from? You probably just don't notice it as much, because our society is heteronormative, so anything that is "heterosexual", is kind of blanked out on. It's a form of tunnel vision. You're far more likely to notice when a woman mentions her girlfriend than when a man mentions his wife.

There is also a tendency to make personal attacks against anyone who have a viewpoint that does not correlate with your own. (I am making a generalisation here, this is not aimed at you, I find you very formal and polite, and you obviously adhere to general mannars and decorum.)


Sadly, the internet is an anonymous forum where people don't always suffer the consequences of their words. There'll always be less than polite people of all stripes online. (And thank you. :))

As an outsider I can see a reference to the Zionist problem, where anyone disagreeing with the political view of Zionism is labeled and Anti-Semite. Just as I was labeled with different mental disorders, advised to seek professional help, and being a homophobic.


That's just plain rude and disrespectful.

I had no intention of herding cats, what ever that means, I used World of Warcraft as an example, no pun was intended.


Trying to guide people on a public forum to be polite and avoid certain topics is just as impossible as herding cats. If you've ever experienced living in a household with a cat, you'll understand what I mean. :D

As for World of Warcraft discussions, you mentioned that you'd rather go to a WoW forum to talk about it, than talk about it on a forum dedicated to another game. My comment was based in my experience of the forums of other MMOs - World of Warcraft is impossible to get away from, because it's the benchmark by which other MMOs are measured. The game is so pervasive that it informes the point of view of a large number of gamers, whether they've actually played it at one point or not, which means like religion, politics, and sexuality, it's almost impossible to avoid discussing it at some point on a MMOgaming forum.

#252
Sabariel

Sabariel
  • Members
  • 2 826 messages

klmg8 wrote...

My only complaint is the romances are so "cheap" everyone is bisexual. Everyone is all "in your face" and promiscuous. Even the encounter with Zev, oh lets go off behind some bushes in the sand and "do it" Lets hope for male champions who accept AIDS doesn't exsist in Dragon Age universe.

Romances should be something that just occur after working through a series of events gradual and not so easily accessed. Working through issues with them first then eventually leading into a relationship.Doing it this way would remove the complaints about "gayness" as not everonye would be trying to hump each other every second dialiog box.

As for the op. Remember prop 8 in california? Very liberal state but still voted no to change what marriage is. Homosexual people just aren't as accepted in society as much as you or some others want to beleive. It go as far to assume based on that vote that 50% of people have some kind of problem with it.

I could care less what people do in their bedrooms though. I'm sure all of us do stuff that someone elese would think is "kinky" or "disgusting" :devil:


Fenris and Merrill are "in your face"? Merrill is promiscuous? And Fenris? And Anders? Really?

Fenris gets pissed off when Zevran hits on Hawke and tells him to eff off. You'd think if Fenris were so promiscuous he'd just ask to join in...

Modifié par Sabariel, 29 mars 2011 - 11:27 .


#253
Painiess

Painiess
  • Members
  • 11 messages

Therefore I am very exclusive as to what forums I visit, I chose to stay away from places where sexuality, religion and politics are disccused,

Damn, if I did that I think I'd only visit two forums on the whole net. 

And be very bored.;)

#254
ReinaHW

ReinaHW
  • Members
  • 354 messages
'Normals' are the ones who 'in the face' as it were with their misguided hatred of any difference.

Homosexuality, bi-sexuals and so on has been around for centuries, it's always been a part of the human race.
Forcing everyone to be hertrosexual just because of the fear of difference is revolting and only leads to a lot of problems.

I find it funny though with the homophobics who think playing with a male lead is the way to go, but some one, there are so many of them and they're so stereotypical, so doesn't that make the homophobics who play as male into that which they hate?
After all they are staring at and adoring a male while demanding for more bland male leads so that they can feel like men.

The same could be said of all the men who worship sports and the men in sports. Homophobics are hypocrites.

#255
AtreiyaN7

AtreiyaN7
  • Members
  • 8 397 messages
Some people get their knickers in a twist over the horror of flirty banter with someone of the same gender. I guess it somehow threatens their heterosexuality? *shrug* At this point I just headdesk when I see someone start whining about getting hit on by Anders (or whatever horrible thing it is that pushes their buttons).

#256
ReinaHW

ReinaHW
  • Members
  • 354 messages
"Oh no, my character got hit on with Isbella! Oh wait...that's not a bad thing even though my character is female, hmm...Fun"

Homophobics really need to get over themselves, ******/bi/trans aren't a danger to anyone, it's the haters who are the real danger.

#257
Heavensrun

Heavensrun
  • Members
  • 383 messages

Medhia Nox wrote...

Just checking in - are gays still taking over?


Depends who you ask.

#258
seebs

seebs
  • Members
  • 8 messages

ostemanden wrote...

Never said that you could not mention you spouse. There is a difference though, between saying; Hey I play this game with my GF/BF and we bla. bla. bla" and "IT IS MY RIGHT TO BE GAY; I CAN TALK ABOUT MY SEXUAL PREFERENCE; EXPERIENCE AND ORIENTATION IN A FORUM FOR GAMES; AND THERE IS NOTHING YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT; BECAUSE IF YOU DO; I WILL PULL THE HOMOPHOBIC CARD"


Of course there's a difference.  The first is what actually happened, the second is something that cannot possibly happen unless you give people a hard time about it when they do the first.

Think it through.  That block caps thing you have there cannot exist except as a response to someone saying otherwise.  It doesn't appear fully-formed in a void; it's a reaction.

Without people saying that homosexuality should be "hidden", there would be no people saying "no, blow that, I am not hiding".

What exactly are you accusing me of lying about? How can I lie if I am not conscious about it? Then I would be talking from a standpoint of ignorance wouldn't I? And unless there is something I do not understand, being ignorant is not the same as lying!


You've claimed that you have a single consistent standard, which is that people should not disclose their sexuality.  However, that standard doesn't really exist.  People say things that reveal their sexuality all the time, and no one notices if they're straight.  But if they're gay, then they get accused of rubbing everyone's noses in it by making it possible to figure it out.

So if you think I'm male, and I refer to my spouse as "he", then suddenly we get all these rants about gay people being all in-your-face about their sexuality, because you suddenly become conscious of me being gay.  But if you think I'm male, and I refer to my spouse as "she", you don't even become aware of my sexuality, because I fit the default your brain automatically assigned me.

So even though your intent may be that you're following a consistent rule, the actual rule is inconsistent.

In the real world, gays are much less in-your-face about their sexuality than straights.  It's just that we're so used to seeing male/female couples kissing and holding hands and so on that we don't even consciously notice it.

If you see a hundred straight couples in public, and a hundred gay couples in public:

1.  More of the straight couples than the gay couples will have been doing something that made the relationship obvious to an onlooker.
2.  You will experience seeing more gay people flaunting their sexuality than straight people flaunting their sexuality.

Brains notice statistical anomalies and assign disproportionate weight to those experiences and/or recollections.

I guess "lying" is not the right word, you're right on that, and I apologize; that was a poor choice of words.  You're saying a thing which is definitively, provably, untrue -- a thing which cannot be true of any living human.  That is not how human brains work.

#259
Heavensrun

Heavensrun
  • Members
  • 383 messages

Painiess wrote...

Therefore I am very exclusive as to what forums I visit, I chose to stay away from places where sexuality, religion and politics are disccused,

Damn, if I did that I think I'd only visit two forums on the whole net. 

And be very bored.;)


You know of -two-???

#260
ITSSEXYTIME

ITSSEXYTIME
  • Members
  • 1 201 messages
I don't have an issue with homosexuality, I have an issue with it being inserted solely to say they have it "on the back of the box".

Case and point: why is it every homosexual character in Dragon Age 1 or 2 is bisexual and an available option for both sexes? ( as far as I know anyway, I'm nowhere near finished DA2)  I'm sure it's much easier to rewrite a couple of lines of dialogue than having a character whose only path is homosexual.

(Romances are stupid to begin with though. I prefer the Persona approach over the Bioware approach to them, because atleast in Persona there's a significant build up and not just light flirting into sex before the end game)

#261
Caralampio

Caralampio
  • Members
  • 372 messages
I think that the one problem with gender in this game is that particular conversation choice with Anders when he hits on you and where you can't avoid the choice of accepting or rejecting. I think the vast majority of straight players, even those you could call homophobic, don't object that there is gay content in the game or gay romance possibilities. If they did, after playing DAO they would never have bought DA2. What they object being forced into that "no third choice" situation. It's too irritating.

With Zevran, although you could turn him down outright and get disapproval, you could also weasel around the question. By picking smart answers you could avoid the question the entire game. Even he recognized it, when you had done that finely he said; "I see the wardens don't recruit fools".

The typical rebuke against people who complain about that Anders incident are things like "people get hit by gays in the real life, just say no and get over it", "what's a little rivalry just get over it", etc. I wonder if there were something anti-gay in the game, suppose some insults when you're down in the darktown or something like that. How would you take it if people posted things like; "gays get insulted in the real life so just get over it"?

#262
Heavensrun

Heavensrun
  • Members
  • 383 messages

ostemanden wrote...

Grestorn wrote...

Well, I find it sad that you'd call around 7% of the population of earth as being perverse and abnormal. Especially since those people don't do any harm to anyone.

BTW, regarding sexual practices, if that's what you're concerned about, there are much much more straight people having "unnormal", some might even say "perverse" sexual practices, including anal intercourse, than gay people.

The funniest thing, though, is that you insist on not being homophobic, yet you stand by your opinion that all gays are perverts.

There's nothing more to add to this.


I think you have a hard time understanding what the words perverse and abnormal means.



I think you need to take a moment to understand that words have meaning that extends beyond the dictionary.

Perverse and abnormal have perjorative connotations.  They're insults.  Whether you mean them as such, or you're just rying to abide by the literal meaning (or hide behind it), they -are-, and they're going to be taken as such.

#263
seebs

seebs
  • Members
  • 8 messages

ITSSEXYTIME wrote...

I don't have an issue with homosexuality, I have an issue with it being inserted solely to say they have it "on the back of the box".


I don't see any evidence that it's just a checklist item.

Case and point: why is it every homosexual character in Dragon Age 1 or 2 is bisexual and an available option for both sexes? ( as far as I know anyway, I'm nowhere near finished DA2)  I'm sure it's much easier to rewrite a couple of lines of dialogue than having a character whose only path is homosexual.


Much simpler explanation:

Think of a single play-through of the game.  You conceive of your character.  You know whether your character is attracted to men, women, or both.  You play the game.  You have characters that you spend a lot of time with.  You decide to hit on the ones you think are attractive.  What happens?  It happily turns out that the story you want to tell (your character's romance) is an option for you!

The "bisexual" characters don't exist in any one telling of the game, just as different play-throughs may have different history for the main character.  It's only when we look at multiple play-throughs that we can say "hang on, we've seen that guy in relationships with both men and women, he must be bi".  But in fact, you never really see that guy in relationships with both men and women in any given play-through.

So for all we know, he's actually gay in the stories where you hit on him and you're a guy, actually straight in the stories where you hit on him and you're a girl, and actually asexual in the stories where you don't hit on him.

(Romances are stupid to begin with though. I prefer the Persona approach over the Bioware approach to them, because atleast in Persona there's a significant build up and not just light flirting into sex before the end game)


I'm not a huge fan of romance plots (and I tend to just ignore them and not play them), but I think they are a thing that makes for a richer world.  In the real world, people have romances.  Characters who somehow magically never have romances are sorta creepy, really.

#264
Heavensrun

Heavensrun
  • Members
  • 383 messages

Caralampio wrote...
The typical rebuke against people who complain about that Anders incident are things like "people get hit by gays in the real life, just say no and get over it", "what's a little rivalry just get over it", etc. I wonder if there were something anti-gay in the game, suppose some insults when you're down in the darktown or something like that. How would you take it if people posted things like; "gays get insulted in the real life so just get over it"?


There's a character in the first game who suggested that women shouldn't be Grey Wardens.  As a feminist, I was offended by his attitude, but you encounter that attitude in real life, so I got over it.

Also, I was -totally- crushing on Aveline, and spent the whole game hitting on her, but she never caught a clue and married some sideburny douchebag.  Stuff like that happens in real life, though, so I got over it.

In fact, to specifically refer to your example, Oghren had some not-too-kind things to say about gays, and reacted pretty harshly if you hit on him in Origins as a male.  That stuff happens in real life, though...

#265
Caralampio

Caralampio
  • Members
  • 372 messages

Heavensrun wrote...

Caralampio wrote...
The typical rebuke against people who complain about that Anders incident are things like "people get hit by gays in the real life, just say no and get over it", "what's a little rivalry just get over it", etc. I wonder if there were something anti-gay in the game, suppose some insults when you're down in the darktown or something like that. How would you take it if people posted things like; "gays get insulted in the real life so just get over it"?


There's a character in the first game who suggested that women shouldn't be Grey Wardens.  As a feminist, I was offended by his attitude, but you encounter that attitude in real life, so I got over it.

Also, I was -totally- crushing on Aveline, and spent the whole game hitting on her, but she never caught a clue and married some sideburny douchebag.  Stuff like that happens in real life, though, so I got over it.

In fact, to specifically refer to your example, Oghren had some not-too-kind things to say about gays, and reacted pretty harshly if you hit on him in Origins as a male.  That stuff happens in real life, though...

Hmm, too bad Aveline isn't romanceable eh? But especially Bethany. You know, I had a similar but contrary experience in my first DAO playthrough. I thought Alistair was little too friendly, and I avoided being nice to him so he wouldn't hit on me! Image IPB

You make good points to my good points. Almost the first reasonable counterarguments I've found about this subject.  

#266
Sabariel

Sabariel
  • Members
  • 2 826 messages

Caralampio wrote...

I think that the one problem with gender in this game is that particular conversation choice with Anders when he hits on you and where you can't avoid the choice of accepting or rejecting. I think the vast majority of straight players, even those you could call homophobic, don't object that there is gay content in the game or gay romance possibilities. If they did, after playing DAO they would never have bought DA2. What they object being forced into that "no third choice" situation. It's too irritating.

With Zevran, although you could turn him down outright and get disapproval, you could also weasel around the question. By picking smart answers you could avoid the question the entire game. Even he recognized it, when you had done that finely he said; "I see the wardens don't recruit fools".

The typical rebuke against people who complain about that Anders incident are things like "people get hit by gays in the real life, just say no and get over it", "what's a little rivalry just get over it", etc. I wonder if there were something anti-gay in the game, suppose some insults when you're down in the darktown or something like that. How would you take it if people posted things like; "gays get insulted in the real life so just get over it"?


Use the "neutral heart" (middle slot) when Anders first hits on you. Don't pick any hearts after that. No rivlary points gained. No ghey relationship. Tada!

#267
Heavensrun

Heavensrun
  • Members
  • 383 messages

Caralampio wrote...

Heavensrun wrote...

Caralampio wrote...
The typical rebuke against people who complain about that Anders incident are things like "people get hit by gays in the real life, just say no and get over it", "what's a little rivalry just get over it", etc. I wonder if there were something anti-gay in the game, suppose some insults when you're down in the darktown or something like that. How would you take it if people posted things like; "gays get insulted in the real life so just get over it"?


There's a character in the first game who suggested that women shouldn't be Grey Wardens.  As a feminist, I was offended by his attitude, but you encounter that attitude in real life, so I got over it.

Also, I was -totally- crushing on Aveline, and spent the whole game hitting on her, but she never caught a clue and married some sideburny douchebag.  Stuff like that happens in real life, though, so I got over it.

In fact, to specifically refer to your example, Oghren had some not-too-kind things to say about gays, and reacted pretty harshly if you hit on him in Origins as a male.  That stuff happens in real life, though...


Hmm, too bad Aveline isn't romanceable eh? But especially Bethany. You know, I had a similar but contrary experience in my first DAO playthrough. I thought Alistair was little too friendly, and I avoided being nice to him so he wouldn't hit on me! Image IPB

You make good points to my good points. Almost the first reasonable counterarguments I've found about this subject.  


The thing about looking for reasonable counterarguments is that the unreasonable ones are usually a lot easier to see.  ;p

#268
Medhia Nox

Medhia Nox
  • Members
  • 5 066 messages
People... puh-lease. We've got a show to put on come Dec. 21st 2012 when we reveal ourselves as the hetero's New Gay Overlords... we really need to solidify our grasp on the gaming industry or how else will we maximize conversion before "it's time".

I think this should be what Dragon Age 3 is about. Dragon Age 3: Rise of "The Gay".

#269
Chaos_1001

Chaos_1001
  • Members
  • 498 messages

Medhia Nox wrote...

People... puh-lease. We've got a show to put on come Dec. 21st 2012 when we reveal ourselves as the hetero's New Gay Overlords... we really need to solidify our grasp on the gaming industry or how else will we maximize conversion before "it's time".

I think this should be what Dragon Age 3 is about. Dragon Age 3: Rise of "The Gay".


*edit*

Modifié par Chaos_1001, 30 mars 2011 - 04:36 .


#270
Grestorn

Grestorn
  • Members
  • 75 messages

ostemanden wrote...

Never said that you could not mention you spouse. There is a difference though, between saying; Hey I play this game with my GF/BF and we bla. bla. bla" and "IT IS MY RIGHT TO BE GAY; I CAN TALK ABOUT MY SEXUAL PREFERENCE; EXPERIENCE AND ORIENTATION IN A FORUM FOR GAMES; AND THERE IS NOTHING YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT; BECAUSE IF YOU DO; I WILL PULL THE HOMOPHOBIC CARD"


You say: 

"It's my right to be straight, I can talk about my sexual preference, experience and orientation in a forum for games, and there's nothing you can do about it, because if you do, I will pull the "it's normal" card!"

People shouldn't even recognize gayness or straightness as something to be worth thinking about in a non-relationship and non-sexual environment.

Since it's still a rare feat that a game containing relationships is allowing for gay and lesbian relations, so you might forgive the OP that he posted his happiness about DA:2 open view on relationships. That alone caused you to go ballistic. It's not that the IP shoved his gayness into your face or forced you to see something that could make you puke, did he?

If you look through this forum, you'll find many many threads where straight people complain about the possibility of gay relationships in this game, that Anders might hit on male Hawkes in some situations and stuff like that. Do you think that's ok? Because those people have the "normality" on their side?

But if one gay person is posting that he's glad that he can court another man in a game, you have to pull out your "it's not normal, it's perverse" card?

After insulting me and other people in this thread by saying we're being perverts, you even seem to be amazed that we're not happily standing by, applauding you.

Modifié par Grestorn, 30 mars 2011 - 06:11 .


#271
Grestorn

Grestorn
  • Members
  • 75 messages

seebs wrote...

You've claimed that you have a single consistent standard, which is that people should not disclose their sexuality.  However, that standard doesn't really exist.  People say things that reveal their sexuality all the time, and no one notices if they're straight.  But if they're gay, then they get accused of rubbing everyone's noses in it by making it possible to figure it out.

So if you think I'm male, and I refer to my spouse as "he", then suddenly we get all these rants about gay people being all in-your-face about their sexuality, because you suddenly become conscious of me being gay.  But if you think I'm male, and I refer to my spouse as "she", you don't even become aware of my sexuality, because I fit the default your brain automatically assigned me.

So even though your intent may be that you're following a consistent rule, the actual rule is inconsistent.

In the real world, gays are much less in-your-face about their sexuality than straights.  It's just that we're so used to seeing male/female couples kissing and holding hands and so on that we don't even consciously notice it.


That's so true, and sums up my (our) point so much better than I could.

Thanks.

Modifié par Grestorn, 30 mars 2011 - 07:08 .


#272
Biefstukfriet

Biefstukfriet
  • Members
  • 115 messages
There is nothing wrong with gayness in games and I applaud Bioware for integrating it into games. It's just the unrealistic way Bioware created all party members to be bisexual that rubs me the wrong way.

#273
Grestorn

Grestorn
  • Members
  • 75 messages

Biefstukfriet wrote...

There is nothing wrong with gayness in games and I applaud Bioware for integrating it into games. It's just the unrealistic way Bioware created all party members to be bisexual that rubs me the wrong way.


They didn't. I already wrote in this thread why it's not really correct to see all of them as bisexual.

#274
Soulcheg

Soulcheg
  • Members
  • 93 messages
edit 
Nah, nevermind, keep going.

Modifié par Soulcheg, 30 mars 2011 - 08:58 .


#275
Dridengx

Dridengx
  • Members
  • 1 813 messages

colex91 wrote...

 Alright now that I have your attention. I just wanted to point something out that has been bothering me..

Why all the controversy? We are in 2011 now, gay people are here forever, have been here forever, and will always be...Get used to it.


Before I'm judged. let me say I live in San Francisco and have gay friends, my BFF is Bi but with that said.. there is something I don't understand sooo....

Well, let me ask you this. I really don't care how you like sex or with what type of people you like sex with.. but why should I know your private business or even care about it? How would it look if some random guy ran around the streets, posted blogs, and flaunted around town saying he likes screwing, blowing, and such? Hey, whatever turns you on or makes you happy is fine with me, but since when does sexual orientation need to be a public affair? Is there no decency left, nothing is private?

I understand you want equal rights, benefits, marriage etc but why shove it down everyone's throat? I don't brag around town how I want king kong shoved up my ass while having painted toes in my mouth everywhere I go nor do I say GET USED TO IT because we are here to stay! just comes across rather wrong to me personally. I know you had to live in opression and want to vent but like you said its 2011! you are accepted, no one cares! so stop telling everyone lol

And as for gayness in games its always been in gaming you just haven't noticed.

Modifié par Dridengx, 30 mars 2011 - 09:08 .