Yakko77 wrote...
What choice did Shep really have?
Why, the choice is pretty obvious - refuse to mass murder batarians and let the Reapers come. Because you see, the bargain might not be that great.
It's not about saving the Galaxy for good, is it? For the price of 300 000 lives Shep bought... a short delay to the inevitable, probably half a year, or maybe less. And the galaxy so far seems unable to adequately prepare for the Reapers beforehand: those who rise to the challenge end up indoctrinated, those who choose to live in denial well... continue to live in denial. Nothing will change in half a year, so what do we need this time for? So there could be a viable option (especially for the Renegade Shep) - to finally cut to the chase, stop procrastinating and face the Reapers there and then. Otherwise it's kinda like pulling teeth - except the dentist charges you thousands of innocent lives here.
Ah, but then it would not be much of a bridge between ME2 and ME3, would it? Because Bio has the Reaper arrival scheduled for that precise moment befor Christmas and Shepard's own logic can't get in the way of the Gods of Narrative, right?
So yeah... Bio has spoken, the sacrifice must be carried on, and the plot must continue it's ongoing movement on it's lonely rail. I'm fine with that - except there is a thousand and one way to actually do it without derailing the player character. Say, introduce another interested party who pulls the trigger if Shepard absolutely refuses to? Or a different McGuffing (there's plenty of them in there already, so what's one more?) that triggers the Project by mistake while Shepard is trying hard to save the batarians? Bio was getting rather adept at presenting us with these kinds of fake choices to create an illusion of certain non-linearity where in fact there was none. So why stop now?
P.S. It's the problem I always seem to have with sacrifices - when you examine them closely, they usually seem so pointless... When the Reapers come, noone is prepared and everyone goes running around screaming their 'oh noes', what will Shepard think of? "Ooops, all those batarian lives I've thrown away back then - for nothing"?