TheBigMatt90 wrote...
Starfang is one of the best weapon's in the game, due to it being T8.
Nug Crusher isn't all that good, are you saying it because you don't have CGM?
dag/dag will outdamage a sword build any day, why no Rose's Thorn? It's the best weapon in the game. There are better longsword's than Duncan's also.
Yeah, Starfang is nice, though for Alistair I prefer Maric's Blade and Cailan's Shield, as the combo gives you a nice bonus.

And just to be corny, for his alt weapon I'll have Duncan's Sword and Duncan's Shield (well, most likely Fade Wall, though I like how the names match better lol). Fade Wall is nice, but imo, at least before testing it for myself, Cailan's Shield > Fade Wall. That's just imo.
As for the Rose's Thorn, I know tests have been done to calculate dmg and all that, though I did a little one of my own, and Rose + Duncan's Dagger did more dmg and was noticeably faster than Duncan's Sword + Rose. I was thinking of Duncan's Sword for the bonus it gives to CUN, and whether it would be a big enough bonus to be noticeable through my Lethality. It wasn't. Now just to see how the Dad Thaig Shanker stacks up to Duncan's Dag.
I'm never sure if I simply play slowly, or what it is, but I always take a long time to get three of the main quests done to open the second tier shops all around Ferelden, so no, I don't have the CGM *yet*. And yes, after looking at it's stats and whatnot, it clearly takes the cake. And probably smashes it to smithereens... I just need more GM Runes...

And after all that fuss, I'll probably end up taking "Dog" along with me instead of Sten (Oghren just doesn't cut it imo). I still think you should be able to enchant Dog's collar or paint with one rune lol After all, it is "equipment"...