Aller au contenu

It's Impossible to Defeat the Reapers


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1062 réponses à ce sujet

#501
Almostfaceman

Almostfaceman
  • Members
  • 5 463 messages

Dave666 wrote...

Almostfaceman wrote...

Dave666 wrote...

If the Relays work by teleporting and its not an all or nothing deal then this might be plausible also, though I am skeptical mind.  Definately not saying it couldn't work though.


Check out the codex the mass of what's being "corridored" or "teleported" has to be calculated - I postulate just screwing with that on the receiving end via the Citadel.  Citadel control of the mass relays is definitely worth investigating methinks.


I still have serious doubts about the whole teleportation thing, however your idea of screwing with the mass calculations is a very good one!


You don't have to call it teleportation, just mainly making the point about the mass, which you agree with - giddyup.  Yup an entire fleet of Reaper legs and eyeballs - with the rest of their bodies scattered across a galaxy - will put a real damper in their morning.

#502
Dave666

Dave666
  • Members
  • 1 339 messages

Almostfaceman wrote...

Dave666 wrote...

Almostfaceman wrote...

Dave666 wrote...

If the Relays work by teleporting and its not an all or nothing deal then this might be plausible also, though I am skeptical mind.  Definately not saying it couldn't work though.


Check out the codex the mass of what's being "corridored" or "teleported" has to be calculated - I postulate just screwing with that on the receiving end via the Citadel.  Citadel control of the mass relays is definitely worth investigating methinks.


I still have serious doubts about the whole teleportation thing, however your idea of screwing with the mass calculations is a very good one!


You don't have to call it teleportation, just mainly making the point about the mass, which you agree with - giddyup.  Yup an entire fleet of Reaper legs and eyeballs - with the rest of their bodies scattered across a galaxy - will put a real damper in their morning.


Yup! You've gotta wonder what would happen to a ship that weighed 100 tonnes if you told the Relay that it weighed 50 tonnes or 500 tonnes...

#503
Mozer121

Mozer121
  • Members
  • 351 messages
Obviously we're not going to defeat the reapers with a massive fleet of the assembled galactic races. Liara mentioned in LotSB that the Protheans possibly had other plans for the reapers as the Shadow Broker himself was performing extensive research on them. My guess is you'll use some kind of Prothean computer virus to disable the reapers either permanently, or weaken them enough to be defeated. That, or there is some sort of master reaper you can destroy and render the rest of them useless.

#504
OrlesianWardenCommander

OrlesianWardenCommander
  • Members
  • 943 messages
You should know after two games that Shepard builds Him/her reputation on the impossible, "we will fight, we will sacrifice and we will find a way, that's what humans Do!"

#505
Nashiktal

Nashiktal
  • Members
  • 5 584 messages
I can't help but feel that anyway Bioware portrays their defeat will feel anticlimatic. If only because of how invincible they are.

I am one of the few people who liked the ending to War of the Worlds (I know its not realistic, yaddya yadda.) but I would feel disappointed if we get a similar ending here.

#506
CulturalGeekGirl

CulturalGeekGirl
  • Members
  • 3 280 messages
My god, hacking the relays is one of the most brilliant tactical maneuvers anyone has suggested yet.

Computer virus slash Independence Day scenario would make me sad. Sad sad sad.

#507
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Mozer121 wrote...

Obviously we're not going to defeat the reapers with a massive fleet of the assembled galactic races. Liara mentioned in LotSB that the Protheans possibly had other plans for the reapers as the Shadow Broker himself was performing extensive research on them.


Liara also said the Shadow Broker may have just been desperate.

#508
Homey C-Dawg

Homey C-Dawg
  • Members
  • 7 499 messages
My theory at this point?

We just found out how to blow up a solar system. I'll bet we can fit all the reapers in one system.

How to lure them all there is beyond me, but it'd probably involve harbys Shepard-fanboyishness getting the best of him.

I just hope it's not a virus or something dumb like that.

#509
Tahleron1

Tahleron1
  • Members
  • 137 messages
They can run out of power, it seemed like that collapsing star near the Perseus Veil is probably something to do with how they produce power, collapse a star prematurely to produce an asston of Element Zero.

#510
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Tahleron1 wrote...

They can run out of power, it seemed like that collapsing star near the Perseus Veil is probably something to do with how they produce power, collapse a star prematurely to produce an asston of Element Zero.


Uhh, that's a bit of a stretch. How does the star Dohlen tell you anything about how Reapers generate power?

#511
monrapias

monrapias
  • Members
  • 311 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

Almostfaceman wrote...

It's your opinion, not the truth.


It is the truth until it is proven wrong. If it is wrong, demonstrate why and how. Otherwise just accept that for now you have no effective counter for anything I've said.



Judge: You killed that man, your going to hang!
victim: but you have no proof
Judge: I don't need proof! I have an opinion!

#512
monrapias

monrapias
  • Members
  • 311 messages
Reapers don't fly away from a fight. Proof is in me1.

#513
Vanaer

Vanaer
  • Members
  • 442 messages
I don't think they're undefeatable. They've already admitted their own weakness: they are each a nation. So how to beat them?

Reaper infighting! Nazara said the Reapers were each a nation. This could also mean that different Reapers represent different nations and thus all posses a matter of sovereignty. The reason I think this is because Nazara was called Sovereign for a reason. He told Saren this story and even Legion comes back at it. The Geth are a nation too, with one will (after the loyalty mission). If Reapers are each a nation, it'll mean they can come (like the Geth did before) to a different conclusion on matters and creating a possible Schism.

Legion already said that Geth reach consensus (in other words, you take the opinion all support while leaving out those elements that are disagreed on) - this is something different from consent, whereby the minority agrees to the majority. Consensus with millions of platforms is almost impossible to achieve, without coming to meager conclusions (Imagine buying Ice Cream and having to agree to whether it has to be Vanilla, Strawberry, Pistache etc. - the more platforms, the more likely it is that opinions differ - very likely only coming to the consensus that we should buy icecream). It could very well be that, with the recent events creating different circumstances, consensus among certain nations will be wailing. I'm kind of expecting a sort of Reaper civil war - they can't be all hell bent fanatics, especially considering they are usurped organics that were used against their will.

Modifié par Vanaer, 06 avril 2011 - 12:03 .


#514
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

monrapias wrote...

Reapers don't fly away from a fight. Proof is in me1.


Once he was docked to the station he had no choice but to commit to his mission. He was minutes from succeeding.

#515
Almostfaceman

Almostfaceman
  • Members
  • 5 463 messages

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

My god, hacking the relays is one of the most brilliant tactical maneuvers anyone has suggested yet.
 


Thanks!

#516
jbblue05

jbblue05
  • Members
  • 1 480 messages
Gaining the Reaper IFF should help organics to better manipulate relays

#517
Almostfaceman

Almostfaceman
  • Members
  • 5 463 messages
"It is the truth until it is proven wrong. If it is wrong, demonstrate why and how. Otherwise just accept that for now you have no effective counter for anything I've said."

That statement is the equivalent of saying that the Earth was flat until humanity proved it was round. Your argument is not truth like "the earth is round". Your argument is your opinion. I don't have to accept it and neither does anyone else. Nor do I have to refute it to your standards - I only have to satisfy my standards in this realm of conjecture.

This thread has nothing to do with proving the Reapers can be defeated, it's an exercise in trying to prove your argument false - to you. Since nobody can control you all you have to do is simply ignore anything you want and still maintain your belief.

"You can lead a horse (Saphra) to water but you can't make him drink."

#518
Rekkampum

Rekkampum
  • Members
  • 2 048 messages

Almostfaceman wrote...

"It is the truth until it is proven wrong. If it is wrong, demonstrate why and how. Otherwise just accept that for now you have no effective counter for anything I've said."

That statement is the equivalent of saying that the Earth was flat until humanity proved it was round. Your argument is not truth like "the earth is round". Your argument is your opinion. I don't have to accept it and neither does anyone else. Nor do I have to refute it to your standards - I only have to satisfy my standards in this realm of conjecture.

This thread has nothing to do with proving the Reapers can be defeated, it's an exercise in trying to prove your argument false - to you. Since nobody can control you all you have to do is simply ignore anything you want and still maintain your belief.

"You can lead a horse (Saphra) to water but you can't make him drink."


I am Commander Shepard and this is my favorite response to a potential troll topic.

#519
Ice Cold J

Ice Cold J
  • Members
  • 2 369 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

100k wrote...

 And then, against all odds, Shepard and Vigil threaten to cause mass delay after mass delay.


The delay has set the invasion back a few thousand years at most. That is assuming the Reapers had anything to do with the Rachni Wars which is by no means certain. Such a short time span to a species as long lived as the Reapers is the blink of an eye.

Things will be harder for the Reapers than they have before, but nothing has been done to hinder them in any lasting way. They can still reach the galaxy and they can still capture the Citadel. Once they do the war will be effectively over.


BUT... why haven't they done this since the beginning? Obviously, they'd prefer not ot do this for SOME reason. Maybe the trip from Dark Space greatly weakens them, thus, giving us a better chance of winning.

Skirlasvoud wrote...

[snippets]

It reeks of over-the-top sercuitous villainy, blindness and utter stupidity. It their actions are anything to go by, the reapers aren't insidious geniuses helbent on subtle manipulation that takes all organic reaction into account. No, they're actually rigid, daft and narrow-minded, so convinced in their own superiority that they refuse to improve or adept. Granted, they have some pretty good, grand plans, but they've been repeating them over and over with no more intelligence than a common gopher. They're more like machines following programing. Plan A was to take the citadel. Plan B was the collectors and now that this hasn't worked, they're slowly ambling towards the galaxy, obsessed with shepard and earth like a bull to a red cloth, guns blazing, blind to all other concerns like they're desperate and running out of creative ideas. It's like they need earth to understand why things haven't worked out for them so far. It's like a zombie pawing at a pane of glass.

"Fatal flaw in our design? Naw, can't be. We're reapers after all. We've done the things we've done for millenia now. Attention flecks of dust, this is infinity and your destiny speaking. Stand still and surrender already.... (pretty please)? Pay no heed to the exaust port while we figure out our heads from our asses!"

For all their bluster, they're more desperate, flawed and stupid than you think. We just need to find a way to exploit this and mitigate their advantage in fleet strength. Because it's all down to that now: fleet strength. Pretty big advantage, but its pretty pathetic that this is all that the reapers have left to them. We can easily outsmart them, no matter how terrifying they appear to be. 


Beautifully stated.

Nathan Redgrave wrote...

You know, there is the distinct possibility that Mass Effect 3 won't necessarily end with the complete defeat of the Reapers, simply with the end of the first battle in a long, long war. (Not a "buy the sequel" cliffhanger or a "bad ending," simply an open-ended conclusion that leaves the fate of the galaxy to the imagination, or which reveals the eventual result during an epilogue.)


I've thought about this, as well. It would be an interesting and, in a somewhat frustrating, fitting ending, to the most interactive video game series yet. "We're not going to tell you how it ends. It's up to you and your imaginations."

zthix wrote...

To OP: Crazy crack pot theory in Reaper defeat - the Geth!

Throughout the games we have it reiterated that the Reapers seeded the galaxy with their technology to ensure its development followed their designs and ease their harvesting. Every cycle repeats along the same path as each new group of civilisations builds its existence upon the same technology assuming it was remnants of the previous. The Reaper rely on consistency for the plan to work, anything not on their path is a problem that they cant quantify and leaves a weakness.

Enter Mass Effect 2 and Geth further development. We find out one big thing in conversation with Legion - that the Reaper contacted the Geth and offered them their end game, a Reaper body capable of processing the entire Geth consciousness - the Geth having been working on just that. The Geth were split, some took up the offer and joined the Reaper attack on the Citadel but more importantly the larger group declined the offer on the basis that to follow another's path of development is not development at all. Despite Reaper efforts on containment this puts the Geth outside the plan and outside their control and predictability the very things they rely on to harvest the galaxy.

Lastly you have to look at what the Reaper are (indeed conversation again with Legion are the most revealing on this). Each single Reaper is billions of AI living within a hull all working together. The Hull or ship itself is pretty much unstoppable - see ME1 - So a fleet could be never be engaged in direct combat with any chance of success as hardware wise they over power any enemy in the galaxy...but the same is not true of software. The Geth exist in the same state but on a smaller scale, Legion is thousands of programs working within one unit.

All of this seems to lead to one conclusion, a Reaper fleet can not be beaten directly in combat and would have to be taken out individually through Cyber Warfare and the only thing in the Galaxy capable of launching that kind of attack and standing any kind of chance would be the Geth. The Geth exist outside Reaper plans and technological dependence and would be able to fight in a way no other force could, they are the big X-factor in the harvesting plan so in short, Geth to the rescue!


Umm... couldn't the Quarians do this as well? Or the Salarians? Or any other races dependant on their intelligence rather than their physical strength?

#520
Vanaer

Vanaer
  • Members
  • 442 messages

Ice Cold J wrote...

Saphra Deden wrote...

100k wrote...

 And then, against all odds, Shepard and Vigil threaten to cause mass delay after mass delay.


The delay has set the invasion back a few thousand years at most. That is assuming the Reapers had anything to do with the Rachni Wars which is by no means certain. Such a short time span to a species as long lived as the Reapers is the blink of an eye.

Things will be harder for the Reapers than they have before, but nothing has been done to hinder them in any lasting way. They can still reach the galaxy and they can still capture the Citadel. Once they do the war will be effectively over.


BUT... why haven't they done this since the beginning? Obviously, they'd prefer not ot do this for SOME reason. Maybe the trip from Dark Space greatly weakens them, thus, giving us a better chance of winning.

They tried to get the Citadel already, as it gives them the power to isolate star systems. They're already weakened by the fact they will have to meet concentrated fleets and an enemy that is not (completely) taken by suprise. It's very likely the Citadel can also be used as a weapon against the Reapers, possibly by going core deep into the Citadel.

#521
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Vanaer wrote...

It's very likely the Citadel can also be used as a weapon against the Reapers, possibly by going core deep into the Citadel.


How did you arrive at that conclusion? We don't even know where the Keepers get their resources from. To use the Citadel against the Reapers we'd have to understand it.

#522
Nashiktal

Nashiktal
  • Members
  • 5 584 messages
concentrated fleets? One concentrated fleet was crippled by a handicapped reaper. (Fifth fleet)

One concentrated reaper fleet will trump any concentrated fleet they might face so far. You need an edge, a card.

#523
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests
Agreed. The problem is we don't have one.

The Reapers can still capture the Citadel too. If they do, it's Game Over for us.

#524
dill72

dill72
  • Members
  • 13 messages
this probably isn't going to happen but it would be sick if there was like a control station in dark space and shepard had to race across the galaxy find and destroy it. Not plausible but it could incorperate a lot of gameplay. Make it like the first and second combined. assemble a small fleet to go fight and find a relay or how to work the citedal (spelled wrong i know) and go and have another suicide type mission to maybe knock out the reapers communication or where they build reapers so we may not win but the cycle will be broken. idk just a thought i think it would be cool

#525
Sajuro

Sajuro
  • Members
  • 6 871 messages

thatguy212 wrote...

We just need to think "What would Kamina do?" so the answer is we need to somehow hijack a reaper, once we figure out how to avoid indoctrination it'll work

three words: GIGA DRILL BREAKER!
oh and
Image IPB