Nathan Redgrave wrote...
evmiller wrote...
Actually it's your logic that is faulty. You assume because the ME universe has the the tech for flying vehicles it should always be used no matter what. The Mako is what it is becasue the vehicle can be made cheaper, quieter, and more durable for what it does than a hovertank could. Think of the thinks we have the tech to do today, but don't see widley available becasue of cost and practicality.
My point was never that the Mako shouldn't exist, but that there's no reason to say that the Hammerhead should not exist. In the context of the universe, the Hammerhead makes more sense than the Mako because the concept for one is obviously more on-par with current technology than the other.
Except for engines that freeze up at low temperatures that aren't even that low in the grand scheme of things and missiles that aren't much different from our missiles today replacing mass effect-based ones. Hovering isn't a step-up overall if it puts the vehicle as such a disadvantage that it can't even do what its designed for well.
If this missed the point of that "rule of cool" argument, then the "rule of cool" argument is more about gameplay design than the actual vehicle, and thus should not be mixed with "what fits in with the universe" logic--kind of confuses the point. Gameplay and level design are a matter of how well-implemented an idea is, not how well the idea fits into the universe.
The design of the levels had to be shifted to suit the gameplay though. We don't have realistic locations for The Hammerhead, we have little Hammerhead playgrounds. I'll admit that The Mako could be a bit slow and frustrating sometimes, but at least I could look at it and say, "that's a believable vehicle for the setting and task it's been designed for in-universe" without issues. I look at The Hammerhead and it just screams to me that it's an arcadey and gamey vehicle designed for naff little platformy, arcadey gamey sections in a video game. That's it. Ooooh, it flies and hovers... big deal! I could strap two hover-engines to a cow and dump it into the Mass Effect universe, but that doesn't mean it suits the universe better and is well suited to the task it's been assigned.
The only way I can accept The Hammerhead as not being a farcical joke of a vehicle is to treat it as a prototype that was largely meant for a different purpose and wasn't never quite finished, much like the only way I can look past the squaddies wearing unprotective gear on dangerous worlds is the consolation that there's only a few places in ME2 we go where it would be a really serious issue, and in those cases I make sure it's Tali and Garrus on the team.
I still think the best option is to either just give us both and let us choose which we'd prefer, or bring back a tweaked Mako. If The Hammerhead returns solo I'd at least expect a shield, armour and weapons upgrade, and maybe some improved engines.





Retour en haut




