128 réponses à ce sujet

[Jorithel Ravencrest]

totally the worst game D&D ever put out...decent to undermountain. that game was painfully bad.

[Romeriez Galenar]

Best:



Fallout 1,2,3 - Awesome games! Along with Master of magic, these are games I'll never get rid of.



The Witcher - Enhanced Edition - Fun, fun, fun.



Baldur's Gate 1 and 2 - I spent so many hours playing these.. I rank these up there with the fallout series.



Final Fantasy IX - This is my favorite FF



Final Fantasy X - (not sure this is technically an rpg...)



Kotor 1 - wonderful game!



NWN - the story was mediocre but still enjoyable.







Most Disappointing:





NWN2 - Ugliest graphics excepting the terrain, small areas, mediocre story, the list goes on and on...



Mass Effect - Not a bad RPG in any sense but the watered down gameplay, and third rate graphics disappointed me.



Temple of Elemental Evil - Love the mechanics but meh on the bugs..



Gothic 1,2,3 - just plain horrible....

[Ponce de Leon]

Best :

BG 1 and 2

Morrowind with Tribunal and Bloodmoon

Diablo 2



Most disappointing

Oblivion ( I see many consider it disappointing, at least I am not alone)

NWN1 (I am sorry, but after BG, seriously, it wasn't worth it. gets better with expansions).

Icewind Dale 2 (I am sorry to say so, it is a very playable game, very enjoyable, but... I think it's the rules).

[the_one_54321]

i am going to have to say that Dungeons & Dragons is the best RPG ever made.

[Stagmar]

Best:



Final Fantasy 6 and 12

.hack//G.U.

Shadow Hearts and Shadow Hearts: Covenant

Tales of the Abyss and Vesperia

Lost Odyssey

Persona series

BG1&2

Mass Effect

KotOR

Jade Empire



Most Dissapointing (though still good games for the most part)

Final Fantasy 7 and 8 (in 7 I could stand Cloud, Barret, or Sephiroth. In 8 I didn't like any other characters or the story)

Shadow Hearts: From the New World (can't put my finger on why I disliked it, but I couldn't even bring myself to finish it)

Tales of Legendia (I was expecting it to be like Tales of Symphonia and Tales of the Abyss. It wasn't and so I was disapointed)

Icewind Dale (I had just finished BG1&2. I was expecting this to be like them. Can't remember what I thought of the story, but having to create all my party meant that there was no interesting character background or party interaction)

NWN (It had in my opinion the worst Bioware storyline and I have no interest in multiplayer so it wasn't for me)

Jade Empire (no this isn't a mistake. I have it on both lists. I loved it, but was disapointed in it because it seem to me that they cut a lot of what they originally wanted to put in)

[Lucy Glitter]

Best:
Bloodlines
KotOR 1 and 2
Deus Ex
Witcher Enhanced Edition
NWN2 - MoTB
Fallout 1 and 2
BG2

Disappointing:
Mass Effect - It was a great story driven fps, but as an RPG I hated it. I did love Wrex, though.
NWN - Story... yeah.
Folklore - Don't buy this. Please.
Gothic 2 - Ehh.. no.

Enjoyable games that have no backbone:
Oblivion - It is fun with lots of mods
Fallout 3 - Again, fun with mods

Modifié par Lucy_Glitter, 31 octobre 2009 - 01:39 .

[Silentplanet]

My favorites or my personal best are..
NWN
Disgaea
Tales of Symphonia
Star Ocean
The Witcher
Gothic 3 (I can't rate this as a best game, just a personal favorite. The game was horribly buggy and unfinished but I had alot of fun playing it)

The most dissapointing for me were..
NWN 2
KOTOR 2

Modifié par Silentplanet, 31 octobre 2009 - 02:00 .

[Nighteye2]

Most disappointing: Mistmare.



The game had an interesting setting, but there was a horrible time system implemented. I picked it up from the bargain bin for about 3 guilders (equivalent to about $3), and it still managed to make me feel like it was a waste of money. >_>

[Deviija]

Best:

Fallout 1 and 2

Planescape: Torment

Baldur's Gate 2 and TOB

Vampire: Bloodlines

Grandia

Star Ocean

Legend of Dragoon

Legend of Legia

Final Fantasy X

Hordes of the Underdark



Most Disappointing:

NWN

Fallout 3

KOTOR 2

Valkyrie Profile 2

Final Fantasy 8

Modifié par Deviija, 31 octobre 2009 - 02:32 .

[SpinachPuff]

FF8?!? Really... It was amazing!

[Amberyl Ravenclaw]

Haven't played many RPGs, so the list is limited.

Personal favorites:
NWN (well, the entire toolset and module works included, not just the OC)
KOTOR2
NWN2: MOTB

Most disappointing:
NWN2 OC

Modifié par Amberyl Ravenclaw, 31 octobre 2009 - 02:37 .

[Mystranna Kelteel]

Best:
Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
Mass Effect
Valkyrie Profile
Final Fantasy 8
Final Fantasy 12
Chrono Cross
Legend of Dragoon
NWN HotU

Most Disappointing:
The Witcher
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga 2
KOTOR 2
Lost Odyssey

Most Milquetoast:
The Elder Scrolls: Morrowind / Oblivion

[DaySeeker]

Best: Final Fantasy X, KOTR, Jade Empire, Mass Effect, Bioshock (I'm counting it)



Most disappointing: Fable II Lost Odyssey, Jason and the Argonauts

[Nameless Two]

Sword For Hire wrote...

Most disappointing:

*snip*

11. Pretty sure Diablo III is going to be on this list, because im cynical at this point on my number list

and that's just off the top of my head
<_<

*sigh* and this thread was going so well.

Given that Diablo 1 & 2 were never role-playing games I doubt that Diablo 3 could ever be considered one either, given that Blizzard aren't deviating from the style and mechanics of the first two games to that extent.

Would have loved it if this thread could have remained devoid of any mention of the Diablo series.

[BLACK RAVEN21]

the best RPG that i've evr play well there are two which are: Legend of Dragoon & Xenogears amazing stories and great gameplay.



The worst Rpg that i have played was Baroque. It just sucked out loud.

[MrGOH]

BLACK RAVEN21 wrote...

the best RPG that i've evr play well there are two which are: Legend of Dragoon & Xenogears amazing stories and great gameplay.

The worst Rpg that i have played was Baroque. It just sucked out loud.

Egads - I forgot to put the first disc of Xenogears in my post! Thanks for the reminder.

Modifié par MrGOH, 31 octobre 2009 - 03:40 .

[BLACK RAVEN21]

best: Mass Effect

Xenogears

Legend of Dragoon

Valkyria Chronicles

Legend of Legaia

FFVII & FFX

Starocean Til The End of Time

Jade Empire

Fable

Magna Carta: Tears of Blood

Growlancer Generation

Persona 3 & 4

Lost Odyssey

Dot. Hack G.U. Series



Worst:

Baroque

Legaia 2: Duel Sages

FFX-2

FFVIII

Last Remnant

Wild Arms 3

Unlimited Saga

Steambot Chronicles

Rpg Maker 3 ( TOO MANY LIMITATION)

Inuyasha: Cursed Mask

[Tharael]

Best:
Fallout 3 (love the modding community for that game)
Mass Effect (great story!)
KotOR (loved that game!)
Vampire: The Masquerade Bloodlines (one of the few rpgs in a modern setting and vampires)
Morrowind (one of first open world / sandbox rpgs I played)
Final Fantasy IX (my favourite Final Fantasy game)
The Witcher Enhanced Edition (enjoyed the story)

Most disapointing:
KotOR 2 (disappointing story compared to KotOR 1)
Oblivion (disliked that clean and plastic-like world)

Modifié par Tharael, 31 octobre 2009 - 04:23 .

[GhoXen]

Best:

Fallout 3

Mass Effect

KOTOR 1&2

Vampire: The Masquerade Bloodlines (with unofficial patch).

Gothic 3(with unofficial patch)

Risen

The Witcher Enhanced

Morrowind

Fable

Neverwinter Night: Horde of Underdark

Planescape Torment

Baldur's Gate 2 & expansion



Most disappointing:

Baldur's Gate 1(simply can't get into it)

Gothic 3(vanilla)

Icewind Dale series(again, can't get into it)

[Zinras]

That's tough to decide, although I'll give it a try.

Best:

Morrowind: Extremely awesome for its time but I've played it so much I simply can't be arsed playing anymore.. Literally played it to death

Fallout series: Yes, even 3, because FO is based on exploring a wasteland which it does very well.

VtM: Bloodlines: It has the be the buggiest game in the universe and even the trillions of fan patches doesn't make it close to bug free. However, it had many cool elements and the haunted hotel was actually scary back then.

NWN, once you got online. Really shows what a great toolset and dedicated fans can do to a game

Diablo 1: Yes, it was a bit light on the roleplaying part but there were no real classes (everyone could learn everything) and the story and setting was great.

Mass Effect: The story was epic and there were great cinematics and an excellent feel to the game. Unfortunately, it's far fom the best ever because Bioware seemingly forgot to make more than 5 maps for it (moving some boxes around doesn't count!).

BG series: Because GO FOR THE EYES BOO!!!

Most dissapointing:

Oblivion: Shows exactly how to do free-form sandbox wrong. Monsters are based on your level and you can do everything at level 1, thus eliminating levelling, and as a consequence, most of the choices in the game. Nearly every quest was kill/fetch but rarely sent you out to truly explore something, as most caves and ruins were linear. Still quite fun using the console and fan made stuff. Just dissapointing, since it was basically set in a medieval European forest. Morrowind is the polar opposite of this, even though it also had some issues.

[aaniadyen]

AustrianAndI wrote...

I see a lot of disappointment in Mass Effect, could someone explain why they were dissapointed? I personally adored the game. That said...
.

Personally, I found mass effect disappointing because it had an excellent story, but it was revealed in a wierd way that could have been done a lot better. It was a very short game, and I thought it was way too easy. You didn't need tactics, just cover, even on the unlockably hard difficulties. If you do absolutely everything, all the side quests, exploring all the planets, everything, it takes what? 40 to 50 hours? On top of all that, the skills, abilities, items, and general gameplay were kinda lackluster. Granted, it wasn't a bad game, I thought it was good, actually, just expected more. It was disappointing because it could have been a lot better if they made a few minor changes, like enemy ai.

[aaniadyen]

the_one_54321 wrote...

i am going to have to say that Dungeons & Dragons is the best RPG ever made.

You, sir, do infact unequivocally win.

[AnzacTrooper]

Kings Field 1-4 and Demon Souls

[AgentGeej]

chiliztri wrote...

Off the top of my head...

Best -

Vampire: The Masquerade Bloodlines

this

A vastly  unappreciated game

Worst.
TOEE
Oblivion
WoW (dear gods its not a rpg)

[Rower_DK]

Best:

Baldur's Gate II

Fallout 1, 2 and 3

NWN 1 and 2

Arcanum

Oblivion

KOTOR i and 2

Morrowind

Mass Effect

Vampire: The Masquerade Bloodlines

The Witcher



Most disappointing:

Two Worlds

Jade Empire

Gothic 3

Icewind Dale

Fabel