149 réponses à ce sujet

[brightblueink]

Anders +2
Aveline +1
Bethany +1
Carver 0
Fenris +2
Isabela -1
Merrill +1
Sebastian 0
Varric +2

Boy, a lot of people just can't stick to the scale, can they?

I almost put Anders as +1 and Aveline as +2 but I changed my mind on both of them. When I think of who I liked better personally (in the sense of who I would enjoy hanging out with more IRL), I liked Aveline more than I did Anders...but when I think about which character actually interested me more, Anders sunk his claws into me and wouldn't let go. I'm constantly on the hunt for Anders fanart, fanfic, want to analyze him more, etc, while Aveline has had less of an impact on me since I finished the game. Funny how that works sometimes...
I also wanted to dock him points for being so different from Awakenings!Anders, but...I couldn't. I wish we could've seen more of a transition, but he was still there and had moments of acting like the old Anders--and even when he didn't I still found him to be a compelling character. I probably would've liked him more if he'd been a separate character, but oh well.

Also, Sebastian is 0 because I don't have his DLC yet. Dunno if I'd like him or not.

I agree with kenelis about liking DA2's characters more overall, too. Besides Isabela (who I probably just haven't spent enough time with yet) I didn't really dislike anyone, and I love how the game developed the characters and your relationship with them. I definitely wish there were a few more interactions, though.

Modifié par brightblueink, 09 avril 2011 - 06:22 .

[DeathStride]

Anders -2
Aveline -infinty(for scale's sake: -2)
Bethany -1
Carver -2
Fenris +1
Isabela +1
Merrill +1
Sebastian +1
Varric 0

[brownybrown]

Anders -2 (what happened to that funny fellow from DAA??)
Aveline +1 (appearance put me off but like a lot of us she grew on me)
Bethany +1 (bit of a wet blanket but petty)
Carver -1
Fenris +1
Isabela + 2 (moah)
Merrill +2 (bit silly fluff light but kinda like a small kitten)
Sebastian 0 (no dlc)
Varric +2 (finally a companion with a bit of banter in him)

[DeeLite808]

Here is what I rated them:

Anders +1
Aveline +1
Bethany +1
Carver -1
Fenris +2
Isabela 0
Merrill 0
Sebastian -1
Varric +2

[Zkyire]

Filament wrote...

Bethany: 1
Carver: 2
Sebastian: 1
Anders: 2
Varric: 2
Merrill: 2
Isabela: 1
Fenris: 2
Aveline: 2

You like everyone?

[Monica83]

Bethany 1
Carver 1
Anders 2
Varric 2
Isabela -1
Aveline 1
Fenris -2

[randName]

IEatWhatIPoo wrote...

Filament wrote...

Bethany: 1
Carver: 2
Sebastian: 1
Anders: 2
Varric: 2
Merrill: 2
Isabela: 1
Fenris: 2
Aveline: 2

You like everyone?

Nothing wrong in it, right?

[silver-crescent]

Anders +2
Aveline +2
Bethany +1
Carver 0
Fenris +2
Isabela +2
Merrill +1
Sebastian -2
Varric -2

Cool topic. I personally like all the characters except Varric and Sebastian.

Modifié par silver-crescent, 09 avril 2011 - 11:07 .

[Veracruz]

Varric +2
Aveline +2
Merrill +1
Bethany +2
Isabela +1
Fenris -1
Anders -2 (should play a healer so I can ignore him...)
Sebastian 0
Carver -2

[BanksHector]

Anders -2
Bethany -2
Isabela - 2
Merrill -2
Carver +2
Fenris +2
Sebastian +2
Varric +2
Aveline +2
Just something about this group that I either really liked them or I really hated them. None of them was in the middle for me.

Modifié par BanksHector, 09 avril 2011 - 11:11 .

[Thibbledorf26]

Varric +2

Aveline +1

Merrill +2

Bethany +1

Isabela 0

Fenris +2

Anders -2

Sebastian 0

Carver +1

[Zkyire]

randName wrote...

IEatWhatIPoo wrote...

Filament wrote...

Bethany: 1
Carver: 2
Sebastian: 1
Anders: 2
Varric: 2
Merrill: 2
Isabela: 1
Fenris: 2
Aveline: 2

You like everyone?

Nothing wrong in it, right?

Nothing wrong with it.

But there isn't a single character that annoys him to even a small degree?

Modifié par IEatWhatIPoo, 09 avril 2011 - 12:14 .

[saresy]

Anders -1
Aveline +1
Bethany +1
Carver -1
Fenris +2
Isabela +2
Merrill -2
Sebastian +1
Varric +2

Just my personal opinion. They were all brilliantly done.

[JediHealerCosmin]

Anders -2
Aveline +2
Bethany +2
Carver -1
Fenris 0
Isabela +1
Merrill 0
Sebastian 0
Varric +2
 

[Purple People Eater]

Anders -1
Aveline +2
Bethany +1
Carver -2
Fenris 0
Isabella +2
Merril +2
Sebastian 0
Varric +2

[MistySun]

Anders +1
Varric +3
Isabela +100
Sebastian +3
Aveline +4
Carver 0
Bethany +5
Fenris +3
Merril +6

[Ohiodruid]

Anders -2
Aveline -1
Bethany +1
Carver -2
Fenris -1
Isabella +1
Merril +2
Sebastian 0
Varric +2

[PsyCoil]

Anders -2
Aveline 0
Bethany +2
Carver -2
Fenris -2
Isabela +1
Merrill +2
Sebastian 0
Varric +1

[.shea.]

Anders -2
Aveline 0
Bethany 0
Carver -1
Fenris +1
Isabela +2
Merrill +2
Sebastian -1
Varric +2

[Ryenke]

Anders +2
Aveline -1
Bethany 0
Carver -1
Fenris +2
Isabela +1
Merrill -1
Sebastian -2
Varric +2

[Liou]

Anders +2. I liked the more humerous and less serious Anders from Awakening better but the change makes sense and he is still an excellent character.
Aveline 0. She was rather borring compared to the others but i can't say i hated her. She had her moments.
Bethany 0. Didn't really spend very much time with her but she seems okay.
Carver +2. Sure he was an ass but that is exactly why i liked him. It's refreshing with a companion like that. And the fact that he and Hawke was also brothers just made the whole thing more intense.
Fenris +2. The best companion in the game. Fenris had everything, an interesting background, personality, good comments and interesting dialogue.
Isabella 0. Meh. She was alright, surely better than Aveline and speaking of Aveline, i enjoyed their dialogue. But overall, she was not really all that interesting.
Merrill +2. She was sweet and had some of the same traits that made Liara my favourite LI but sadly, she was just a little too stupid and overstrung to really be loveable. I also found the total shift in personality from Origins a little strange.
Sebastion. Didn't buy him.
Varric 0. He was ok. He wasn't all that interesting compared to some of the others but i generely liked his dialogue and personal quests and the voice over was perfect.

Modifié par Liou, 09 avril 2011 - 03:01 .

[DJBare]

MistySun wrote...
Isabela +100

It's the eyes is'nt it

[jmadsen]

Bethany -1
Carver 2
Anders 2
Varric 2
Isabela 1
Aveline 0
Fenris -1