64 réponses à ce sujet

[Giggles_Manically]

I sneezed and my dagger suddenly flew from my belt and killed her.
Tragic.

[SidheKate]

Dead dead dead. She already beat templars, that's how the party tracked her in the first place. She had a chance with me right up until she threatened the informant and Hawke's dagger was at his/her throat. She only cowered and whimpered when the shoe was on the other foot.

And yes, no matter who is in the party, you can snap out of it.

[KJandrew]

Everytime i've done that quest she tries to make me cut my throat, Hawke says no and stabs her. She never begs or babbles at me

[AshleyS3]

Filament wrote...

I thought the companion mage interventions all felt a bit... flat. Needed more... intensity. Maybe Anders could have gone all super saiyan Vengeance on her.

I do agree with you here, I was expecting more out of that interaction. 

[Rockpopple]

The Templars she beat didn't know what she was, and they weren't exactly the best the Order had to show. In fact they were basically rookies. I doubt a seasoned Templar would have any problem with Idunna.

Idunna reminds me of that Blood Mage at the Circle Tower of Fereldan. I kept getting pissed off because it seemed like no matter what I did I always ended up killing her. lol. Anyway, Idunna seemed genuinely terrified of me so I couldn't kill her (I did, btw, in one playthrough)

I see where you guys are coming from. I'm just surprised that basically everyone that's replied (save Amagoi) said they'd not only kill her, they'd dig her up again so they can stab her one more time.

Modifié par Rockpopple, 11 avril 2011 - 09:00 .

[TobiTobsen]

Wulfram wrote...

She's too dangerous. She dies.

Templar supervision couldn't keep a toddler under control, let alone a blood mage.

If you give her to the templars she gets owned pretty hard. I don't know what they do to her besides the 24/7 lockdown in her cell but it seems to be an awesome way of brainwashing.

Maybe they send Alric.... uhh... that would be evil.  Better stab her next time.

[Rockpopple]

She does say she wishes I did kill her, so maybe they did send Alric. Fate worth than death. That guy's scum of the earth

[Iosev]

AshleyS3 wrote...

I was surprised that letting her live gave me +5 rivalry with Isabella. I expected her to want me to be merciful towards Idunna.

Isabela values freedom, especially when it concerns herself.  I think Isabela gets angry with Idunna because Idunna used blood magic to manipulate Isabela into being seduced (and thus, against Isabela's free will).

[TobiTobsen]

Rockpopple wrote...

She does say she wishes I did kill her, so maybe they did send Alric. Fate worth than death. That guy's scum of the earth

Yeah... his creepy steel-blue eyes are freakin me out. I'll probably stab her the next time. Even someone like her doesn't deserve the Alric or Karras treatment.

[Joy Divison]

Rockpopple wrote...

The Templars she beat didn't know what she was, and they weren't exactly the best the Order had to show. In fact they were basically rookies. I doubt a seasoned Templar would have any problem with Idunna.

Idunna reminds me of that Blood Mage at the Circle Tower of Fereldan. I kept getting pissed off because it seemed like no matter what I did I always ended up killing her. lol. Anyway, Idunna seemed genuinely terrified of me so I couldn't kill her (I did, btw, in one playthrough)

I see where you guys are coming from. I'm just surprised that basically everyone that's replied (save Amagoi) said they'd not only kill her, they'd dig her up again so they can stab her one more time.

I actually always spared the blood mage in the Circle Tower of Fereldan; her aims and contrition struck me as genunine.  Idunna gets the knife.

[hoorayforicecream]

AshleyS3 wrote...

I killed her the first play-through (rogue) but let her live this play-through (mage).

I was surprised that letting her live gave me +5 rivalry with Isabella. I expected her to want me to be merciful towards Idunna.

If Isabela's in the party, she gets partially mind-controlled too. Isabela's usually ok with sparing people, but not when they try to mind control her. Then she gets vengeful.

[Paraxial]

Had her locked up.

[IanPolaris]

I generally let her live especially if I am playing a mage-Hawke. The only way to get one of the best bloomagic staves in the game (along with a truckload of XP and treasure) in Act 2 is to let her live in Act 1.

The way my mage-hawke justifies it is he would rather die than be sent to the Templars (esp in Kirkwall). Why do Idunna a favor by killing her. Let the Templars handle/abuse/molest her. She's earned that treatement.

I have found that mage-Hawke can with a special interrupt, resist her mind-control magic and completely break free allowing her to live. If you aren't a mage-hawke then you need to get help from a Bethany, Anders, or Merrill if you want to keep her alive. Otherwise as a non-mage, you have to kill her to break free.

-Polaris

[BigEvil]

First playthrough I killed her after she tried to mind control me. Second I saved her and kind of glad I did. Got the Forbidden Knowledge quest from her and that was an interesting one. Saved her on my third playthrough as well. Fourth I'm probably going to kill her as that character is going to be heavily against blood magic.

[primero holodon]

I don't recall her having the chance to beg for her life when I did it.

Modifié par primero holodon, 11 avril 2011 - 09:20 .

[AlexXIV]

First time I killed her and I don't remember having a choice. Second time around I was looking for a way to spare her and so I did.

[naughty99]

Rockpopple wrote...

And if so, how could you?

Sure, I wanted to put her to the sword myself, but when she started blubbering and begging repeatedly for her life, and when she sang like a canary when I questioned her... I couldn't do it.  Could you?

Are your hearts so black? 

Are you joking? After she didn't even blink twice about forcing you to slit your own throat? 

I had no problem ending her, just wish it could have been a battle instead of in a cutscene.

@BigEvil, you don't need to save her to get the Forbidden Knowledge quest. I killed her and still got the quest and found the books.

Modifié par naughty99, 11 avril 2011 - 09:22 .

[Lord Gremlin]

My Hawke was a power-hungry blood mage. That Idunna dare use blood magic on her? Instant stab in the gut. That will teach her who's the most powerful blood mage here.

[alaska the 1st]

IanPolaris wrote...

I generally let her live especially if I am playing a mage-Hawke. The only way to get one of the best bloomagic staves in the game (along with a truckload of XP and treasure) in Act 2 is to let her live in Act 1.

The way my mage-hawke justifies it is he would rather die than be sent to the Templars (esp in Kirkwall). Why do Idunna a favor by killing her. Let the Templars handle/abuse/molest her. She's earned that treatement.

I have found that mage-Hawke can with a special interrupt, resist her mind-control magic and completely break free allowing her to live. If you aren't a mage-hawke then you need to get help from a Bethany, Anders, or Merrill if you want to keep her alive. Otherwise as a non-mage, you have to kill her to break free.

-Polaris

You can still do the tome quest even if she's dead.

[ReallyRue]

I killed her because she was a manipulative deranged shrew. Easy enough.

[IanPolaris]

alaska the 1st wrote...

IanPolaris wrote...

I generally let her live especially if I am playing a mage-Hawke. The only way to get one of the best bloomagic staves in the game (along with a truckload of XP and treasure) in Act 2 is to let her live in Act 1.

The way my mage-hawke justifies it is he would rather die than be sent to the Templars (esp in Kirkwall). Why do Idunna a favor by killing her. Let the Templars handle/abuse/molest her. She's earned that treatement.

I have found that mage-Hawke can with a special interrupt, resist her mind-control magic and completely break free allowing her to live. If you aren't a mage-hawke then you need to get help from a Bethany, Anders, or Merrill if you want to keep her alive. Otherwise as a non-mage, you have to kill her to break free.

-Polaris

You can still do the tome quest even if she's dead.

How.  The quest doesn't open up if she's dead.  AFAIK it only opens up when a reformed Idunna sends you a letter from the gallows.

-Polaris

[Iosev]

IanPolaris wrote...

alaska the 1st wrote...

IanPolaris wrote...

I generally let her live especially if I am playing a mage-Hawke. The only way to get one of the best bloomagic staves in the game (along with a truckload of XP and treasure) in Act 2 is to let her live in Act 1.

The way my mage-hawke justifies it is he would rather die than be sent to the Templars (esp in Kirkwall). Why do Idunna a favor by killing her. Let the Templars handle/abuse/molest her. She's earned that treatement.

I have found that mage-Hawke can with a special interrupt, resist her mind-control magic and completely break free allowing her to live. If you aren't a mage-hawke then you need to get help from a Bethany, Anders, or Merrill if you want to keep her alive. Otherwise as a non-mage, you have to kill her to break free.

-Polaris

You can still do the tome quest even if she's dead.

How.  The quest doesn't open up if she's dead.  AFAIK it only opens up when a reformed Idunna sends you a letter from the gallows.

-Polaris

I think an alternate way to start the quest is to simply find one of the evil tomes.