97 réponses à ce sujet

[Turnip Root]

charmingcharlie wrote...

Turnip Root wrote...

The PC's performance can differ dramatically depending on the user's processor and GPU so therefore I don't think it makes sense to outright delcare the PC version as superior when that isn't the case on every PC user's hardware.
I own all three versions of Mass Effect 2 so I'm not biased on way or the other.  I'm just calling it as it is, the PS3 version is the best.

Yes you are biased because you are ignoring the PC version so you can make a ridiculous claim that the PS3 is somehow "superior".  The PS3 version is not better than the PC version so at the end of the day the superior version is on the PC. 

Now you may have a claim to say that "the PS3 version is slightly better than the Xbox 360" but you cannot say the PS3 version is the superior version because that version is on the PC.

The PC version may or may not be better than the PS3 version so to include it in a comparison between platforms wouldn't make sense unless I was mentioning the specific hardware the PC version was running on.  Just comparing the PC version in general though the performance isn't necessarily better than the console versions.

[PlumPaul93]

stop trying to start something dude if I remember correctly you were the guy who said PS3 should be the only ones to get the ME2 comic.

[charmingcharlie]

Turnip Root wrote...

The PC version may or may not be better than the PS3 version so to include it in a comparison between platforms wouldn't make sense unless I was mentioning the specific hardware the PC version was running on.  Just comparing the PC version in general though the performance isn't necessarily better than the console versions.

Yes it does make sense to compare the PC version with the console versions because the game is on the PC.  Therefore if you are after the "superior" version then you want the PC version since that is the "superior" version.  You are just ignoring the PC version because you want to portray the PS3 version as being the "superior" one when it clearly isn't.

[Turnip Root]

charmingcharlie wrote...

Turnip Root wrote...

The PC version may or may not be better than the PS3 version so to include it in a comparison between platforms wouldn't make sense unless I was mentioning the specific hardware the PC version was running on.  Just comparing the PC version in general though the performance isn't necessarily better than the console versions.

Yes it does make sense to compare the PC version with the console versions because the game is on the PC.  Therefore if you are after the "superior" version then you want the PC version since that is the "superior" version.  You are just ignoring the PC version because you want to portray the PS3 version as being the "superior" one when it clearly isn't.

Saying the PC version is superior is assuming that every PC owner has a PC which is capable of running Mass Effect 2 better than the PS3 version which cannot be possible.
It's not a matter of bias or preferance, it's just that the PC platform as a piece of hardware is not static like a console.  It can be bad, it can be good and therefore it doesn't make sense to definitively state that the PC version is superior, end of story.  It can be, or it can't be and if I'm going to compare the PC version as it appears on superior PC's it's only fair that I include inferior PC's.

[Turnip Root]

PlumPaul82393 wrote...

stop trying to start something dude if I remember correctly you were the guy who said PS3 should be the only ones to get the ME2 comic.

Well yes, I was.  We did wait a year for our version so it only makes sense that we get additional content not found on any other platform.

Mass Effect 3 will be released simutaneously on all three platforms though so I'll be content with just having superior graphics.

[lolwut666]

I vote on ignoring the sad fanboy and letting his dumb thread rot.

Who's with me?

Modifié par lolwut666, 16 avril 2011 - 02:08 .

[Turnip Root]

Fanboy? You're mistaken. I own every current gen console and a game ready PC. I believe every platform has it's strengths and weaknesses but in the case of Mass Effect 2, the PS3 version is clearly the best.

[charmingcharlie]

Turnip Root wrote...

Saying the PC version is superior is assuming that every PC owner has a PC which is capable of running Mass Effect 2 better than the PS3 version which cannot be possible.

IT DOES NOT MATTER you claimed the PS3 version is superior, it is not superior on the PS3 it is superior on the PC.  If you want the "superior" version of Mass Effect 2 then you should play it on a PC.

Turnip Root wrote... It's not a matter of bias or preferance, it's just that the PC platform as a piece of hardware is not static like a console.  It can be bad, it can be good and therefore it doesn't make sense to definitively state that the PC version is superior, end of story.  It can be, or it can't be and if I'm going to compare the PC version as it appears on superior PC's it's only fair that I include inferior PC's.

You can include what you like the fact remains the PC version is the superior version.  If you are that hell bent on having the "superior" version then you will have a PC that plays the game in a "superior" fashion to the consoles.  Thus the "superior" version of Mass Effect 2 is actually on the PC and not on your biased choice of console.

[PlumPaul93]

Turnip Root wrote...

PlumPaul82393 wrote...

stop trying to start something dude if I remember correctly you were the guy who said PS3 should be the only ones to get the ME2 comic.

Well yes, I was.  We did wait a year for our version so it only makes sense that we get additional content not found on any other platform.

Mass Effect 3 will be released simutaneously on all three platforms though so I'll be content with just having superior graphics.

isn't the highest any game game be viewed right now 720p or i on all platforms? If you think having slightly better graphics matter than

[Razorsedge820]

"Superior version" ?

The OP is obviously a PS3 fanboy looking to get a rise out of others.
If your trying to start a console war go to IGN plox.

[Turnip Root]

charmingcharlie wrote...

Turnip Root wrote...

Saying the PC version is superior is assuming that every PC owner has a PC which is capable of running Mass Effect 2 better than the PS3 version which cannot be possible.

IT DOES NOT MATTER you claimed the PS3 version is superior, it is not superior on the PS3 it is superior on the PC.  If you want the "superior" version of Mass Effect 2 then you should play it on a PC.

Turnip Root wrote... It's not a matter of bias or preferance, it's just that the PC platform as a piece of hardware is not static like a console.  It can be bad, it can be good and therefore it doesn't make sense to definitively state that the PC version is superior, end of story.  It can be, or it can't be and if I'm going to compare the PC version as it appears on superior PC's it's only fair that I include inferior PC's.

You can include what you like the fact remains the PC version is the superior version.  If you are that hell bent on having the "superior" version then you will have a PC that plays the game in a "superior" fashion to the consoles.  Thus the "superior" version of Mass Effect 2 is actually on the PC and not on your biased choice of console.

No you're wrong.  the PS3 version is superior.  The PC does not count as a platform for valid comparison unless you're talking about a very specific hardware build up.  If I were to bring up all three versions and mention a PC with ATI Radeon 6870, I7 processor, etc then in that case I would say the PC version is superior but just talking about the PC version in general....it depends and thus it would not be accurate to flat out declare the PC version superior.  It isn't necessarily since the PC's hardware can vary dramatically in quality.

[Jamesnew2]

Turnip Root wrote...

PlumPaul82393 wrote...

stop trying to start something dude if I remember correctly you were the guy who said PS3 should be the only ones to get the ME2 comic.

Well yes, I was.  We did wait a year for our version so it only makes sense that we get additional content not found on any other platform.

Mass Effect 3 will be released simutaneously on all three platforms though so I'll be content with just having superior graphics.

Oh you lost my unbias with that remark. Dude Ps3 if anything have the least rights to superior gameplay. They should be delayed release if anything.  And prepare to be uncontent for 1 It all started on Xbox and was then ported to pc so if bioware have any sense theyll focus on those 2 and secondly PS3 dont have superior graphics do your research and you'll find out.... and finallly to meet the lowest requirements for pc Your computer has to be good or it doesnt run it. It took me 5 years to get a gaming pc and before then no game worked. If you can play ME2 on pc then your computer is better than the ps3's. And quite frankly your a bit of a fool to think that ps3 users can demand additional content in a game that was brought up by the pc and xbox and the forums are full of pc and xbox users..... Your asking to be flamed at. And btw welcome to my world I have to wait an extra 6 months for every assassin creed game... You dont see me complaining, Im content with getting the dlc for free. LIKE YOU DID!

Modifié par Jamesnew2, 16 avril 2011 - 02:14 .

[Grey21]

I have to admit, as a 360 owner this TC and topic are really annoying me. Not just because I've seen the PS3 version in action and it is only slightly looks better while having a worse framerate.

I'm really getting annoyed because the 360 has both games, nothing beats being able to bring your Shepard from start to finish. The way the TC formulates his first posts clearly shows he is aware of this and therefore hammers on how the PS3 version of ME2 is superior. I know it shouldn't annoy me but it does....

Anyway, I will answer the question just to show that we 360 owners are good people and not trolls as we all know some other people are... The PS3 version of ME2 is arguable superior as it uses the new ME3 engine. ME3 on the 360 will use this as well. It is impossible to say which version will be 'superior' but it is safe to say both versions will be very much alike. To such an extent that it doesn't really matter which one you get... unless you want to play through the entire story ofcourse

[Turnip Root]

Razorsedge820 wrote...

"Superior version" ?

The OP is obviously a PS3 fanboy looking to get a rise out of others.
If your trying to start a console war go to IGN plox.

Bayonetta on the Xbox 360 is superior to the PS3 version.

Am I an Xbox 360 fanboy now?

[Jamesnew2]

Grey21 wrote...

I have to admit, as a 360 owner this TC and topic are really annoying me. Not just because I've seen the PS3 version in action and it is only slightly looks better while having a worse framerate.

I'm really getting annoyed because the 360 has both games, nothing beats being able to bring your Shepard from start to finish. The way the TC formulates his first posts clearly shows he is aware of this and therefore hammers on how the PS3 version of ME2 is superior. I know it shouldn't annoy me but it does....

Anyway, I will answer the question just to show that we 360 owners are good people and not trolls as we all know some other people are... The PS3 version of ME2 is arguable superior as it uses the new ME3 engine. ME3 on the 360 will use this as well. It is impossible to say which version will be 'superior' but it is safe to say both versions will be very much alike. To such an extent that it doesn't really matter which one you get... unless you want to play through the entire story ofcourse

Well said.

[Jamesnew2]

Turnip Root wrote...

Razorsedge820 wrote...

"Superior version" ?

The OP is obviously a PS3 fanboy looking to get a rise out of others.
If your trying to start a console war go to IGN plox.

Bayonetta on the Xbox 360 is superior to the PS3 version.

Am I an Xbox 360 fanboy now?

Bayonetta was released for both platforms. Me1 was released for Xbox and PC ... .You cant walk in a demand that ps3 get extra content.

[sympathy4saren]

I had my save file carried over from the original Mass Effect.

You had a cheesy comic.

Combined with massive lag issues, I don't know if ps3 can comprehend the epicness of Mass Effect.

[Irrepressible]

"Will the PS3 version of Mass Effect 3 be better than the Xbox 360 version?"

Holdup, let me get my crystal ball out for you.

[charmingcharlie]

Turnip Root wrote...

No you're wrong.  the PS3 version is superior.  The PC does not count as a platform for valid comparison unless you're talking about a very specific hardware build up.  If I were to bring up all three versions and mention a PC with ATI Radeon 6870, I7 processor, etc then in that case I would say the PC version is superior but just talking about the PC version in general....it depends and thus it would not be accurate to flat out declare the PC version superior.  It isn't necessarily since the PC's hardware can vary dramatically in quality.

Yes the PC version does count as a platform, it exists and the game is available on that platform.  Therefore if you want the "superior" ME 2 experience it is on a PC end of discussion, fullstop.  The only reason you want to ignore the PC is because you KNOW that the PC version is vastly "superior" to the PS3 version and that doesn't fit in with your console, trolling perspective.  So you do what all good trolls do and totally ignore the PC version because it does not "fit" with your bias.

The "superior" version of ME 2 is not on the PS3 it is on the PC.

[Turnip Root]

Grey21 wrote...

I have to admit, as a 360 owner this TC and topic are really annoying me. Not just because I've seen the PS3 version in action and it is only slightly looks better while having a worse framerate.

I'm really getting annoyed because the 360 has both games, nothing beats being able to bring your Shepard from start to finish. The way the TC formulates his first posts clearly shows he is aware of this and therefore hammers on how the PS3 version of ME2 is superior. I know it shouldn't annoy me but it does....

Anyway, I will answer the question just to show that we 360 owners are good people and not trolls as we all know some other people are... The PS3 version of ME2 is arguable superior as it uses the new ME3 engine. ME3 on the 360 will use this as well. It is impossible to say which version will be 'superior' but it is safe to say both versions will be very much alike. To such an extent that it doesn't really matter which one you get... unless you want to play through the entire story ofcourse

Having the comic book though is such an advantage though when it comes to being able to quickly customize a Shepard for a new playthrough.  It's much better than having to play all the way through Mass Effect 1 again.

I have no doubt that both versions of Mass Effect 3 will be similar but I think the PS3's hardware advantage will be apparent in the game's visuals, especially since Bioware knows how to program well with the PS3.

[Da_Lion_Man]

This topic reminds me... My PS3 and 360 are so boring right now... I haven't touched them for like 2 weeks, I'm just playing PS2 and old PC games because the current games are so boring for some reason. Bring on the next generation already.

[Turnip Root]

charmingcharlie wrote...

Turnip Root wrote...

No you're wrong.  the PS3 version is superior.  The PC does not count as a platform for valid comparison unless you're talking about a very specific hardware build up.  If I were to bring up all three versions and mention a PC with ATI Radeon 6870, I7 processor, etc then in that case I would say the PC version is superior but just talking about the PC version in general....it depends and thus it would not be accurate to flat out declare the PC version superior.  It isn't necessarily since the PC's hardware can vary dramatically in quality.

Yes the PC version does count as a platform, it exists and the game is available on that platform.  Therefore if you want the "superior" ME 2 experience it is on a PC end of discussion, fullstop.  The only reason you want to ignore the PC is because you KNOW that the PC version is vastly "superior" to the PS3 version and that doesn't fit in with your console, trolling perspective.  So you do what all good trolls do and totally ignore the PC version because it does not "fit" with your bias.

The "superior" version of ME 2 is not on the PS3 it is on the PC.

If you want to include just the PC as a platform for comparison and not a very specific PC build then you must also account for the PC's that have inferior hardware and can't run Mass Effect 2 as well as it appears on consoles.

Just because it looks good on some PC's doesn't mean it looks good on all PC's.  That is why the PC version in general should not be compared to the consoles because not every PC is the same.  Every PS3 and Xbox 360 however pretty much is the same in terms of raw processing and GPU power.

[Paul Sedgmore]

Turnip Root wrote...

Razorsedge820 wrote...

"Superior version" ?

The OP is obviously a PS3 fanboy looking to get a rise out of others.
If your trying to start a console war go to IGN plox.

Bayonetta on the Xbox 360 is superior to the PS3 version.

Am I an Xbox 360 fanboy now?

I think that even the biggest PS3 fanboy would admit that.

Come on a loading screen to bring up the pause menu? no one could say that was good.

[Turnip Root]

Paul Sedgmore wrote...

Turnip Root wrote...

Razorsedge820 wrote...

"Superior version" ?

The OP is obviously a PS3 fanboy looking to get a rise out of others.
If your trying to start a console war go to IGN plox.

Bayonetta on the Xbox 360 is superior to the PS3 version.

Am I an Xbox 360 fanboy now?

I think that even the biggest PS3 fanboy would admit that.

Come on a loading screen to bring up the pause menu? no one could say that was good.

Ok, Crysis 2 on the Xbox 360 is better than the PS3 version.  Still not convinced?

[ShepardsAssassin]

 I´ve be honest, I´m a PS3 fan and played ME2 on it and on PC too.
Sorry, but the only thing that was diffrent from X360/PC was the lighting and some content.
And if you that big PS3 fan, then you should be glad that you get the same looking version as the X360.
Multiplaforms on PS3 are a lot better now, but still there are issues. (RDR, Black Ops, Mafia 2 and yes I played them all)
And still, do you really think Bioware will spent much more money on PS3 than X360, to have PS3 better graphics?
I´m no tech guy, but please read what I wrote, thank you.

Modifié par ShepardsAssassin, 16 avril 2011 - 02:24 .