80 réponses à ce sujet

[Seewomann]

 Okay so here is the thing. I had a relationship with Kaidan in ME1, but Ive always liked Garrus much more... sooooo I decided to make Garrus my LI in ME2. I dont care about Kaidan anymore at all. I know that Bioware has said there are repercussions for "cheating" ((I dont think its cheating because it had been two years, you were dead, he tried seeing another woman (the doctor he mentions in his letter) and he yells at you when he sees you again)) anyways I assume that the repercussions will be that he wont want to be with me anymore, which I could care less. My promblem is that I am afraid for some crazy reason that my ME2 LI (Garrus) will leave me because of this 2 LI thingy. 

I want to know mostly because I dont want to have to replay all three games when the time comes just so my Shepard can be happy.

Please give me input on what you think will happen with these love triangles in ME3.

Thank you!

Modifié par Seewomann, 20 avril 2011 - 05:15 .

[Avissel]

I'm just hoping it's something more than a "Now you must choose between us" scene.

[Dante Angelo]

Kaidan will use his biotics to crush you.

[Reaper Bob]

Ashley will kill you, Kaidan will sob and cry, Liara will still love you and will ask for a 3 way.

[Twilight_Princess]

Also don't you think the repercussions should be different if you slept with Liara in LotSB after you romance someone in ME2? That, to me ,is cheating whereas going your separate ways after horizon and then moving on is not. I just hope that gets acknowledged.

[Fiery Phoenix]

If LOTSB is anything to go by, then it shouldn't be that much of a consequence. Anyone who played LOTSB with Liara cheated on knows what I'm talking about.

[Abramis brama]

Avissel wrote...

I'm just hoping it's something more than a "Now you must choose between us" scene.

Yeah, I'm too hoping that they will be severe and not just having enough renegade or paragon points and choosing. In some cases I'm hoping getting blocked off from both romances.

[Witty_Remark]

I don't think your ME2 love interest would leave you just for finding out that you were with someone before, especially since all of your love interests are aware about the whole 'two years being dead' thing.
They'd probably leave you if in ME3 you went back to your original love interest. [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie] But you already mentioned you didn't want to do that so I don't think you need to worry.

I don't think cheating is a good word for it anyway. You died and your LI started to move on in your absence. Plus they (excluding Liara) turned their back on you when you really needed their help. It only could have been more of a betrayal if they had tried to arrest you.

Unless people did this:

Also don't you think the repercussions should be different if you slept
with Liara in LotSB after you romance someone in ME2? That, to me ,is
cheating whereas going your separate ways after horizon and then moving
on is not. I just hope that gets acknowledged.

^ That is definitely cheating and deserves some kind of super dramatic backlash.


Possible repercussion that I think about?

Fighting (either between you and your original LI, or between your old and new LI)
Not getting cooperation from your original LI
Your new LI asking you questions about it and/or doubting your relationship because of it.

[Seewomann]

Witty_Remark wrote...

I don't think your ME2 love interest would leave you just for finding out that you were with someone before, especially since all of your love interests are aware about the whole 'two years being dead' thing.
They'd probably leave you if in ME3 you went back to your original love interest. [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png[/smilie] But you already mentioned you didn't want to do that so I don't think you need to worry.

I don't think cheating is a good word for it anyway. You died and your LI started to move on in your absence. Plus they (excluding Liara) turned their back on you when you really needed their help. It only could have been more of a betrayal if they had tried to arrest you.

Unless people did this:

Also don't you think the repercussions should be different if you slept
with Liara in LotSB after you romance someone in ME2? That, to me ,is
cheating whereas going your separate ways after horizon and then moving
on is not. I just hope that gets acknowledged.

^ That is definitely cheating and deserves some kind of super dramatic backlash.


Possible repercussion that I think about?

Fighting (either between you and your original LI, or between your old and new LI)
Not getting cooperation from your original LI
Your new LI asking you questions about it and/or doubting your relationship because of it.

I completely agree, I just dont want to be wrong and have to play all three game over just so i can have my ME2 LI stay with me

but lets hope for the best ha 

[Khemical]

Cat fight?

"Take pictures!"

[Witty_Remark]

Seewomann wrote...

I completely agree, I just dont want to be wrong and have to play all three game over just so i can have my ME2 LI stay with me

but lets hope for the best ha 

Ahhh, that would be terrible!

[habitat 67]

Arm wrestling contest.

[Twilight_Princess]

Witty_Remark wrote...

I don't think your ME2 love interest would leave you just for finding out that you were with someone before, especially since all of your love interests are aware about the whole 'two years being dead' thing.
They'd probably leave you if in ME3 you went back to your original love interest. ../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png But you already mentioned you didn't want to do that so I don't think you need to worry.

I don't think cheating is a good word for it anyway. You died and your LI started to move on in your absence. Plus they (excluding Liara) turned their back on you when you really needed their help. It only could have been more of a betrayal if they had tried to arrest you.

Unless people did this:

Also don't you think the repercussions should be different if you slept
with Liara in LotSB after you romance someone in ME2? That, to me ,is
cheating whereas going your separate ways after horizon and then moving
on is not. I just hope that gets acknowledged.

^ That is definitely cheating and deserves some kind of super dramatic backlash.


Possible repercussion that I think about?

Fighting (either between you and your original LI, or between your old and new LI)
Not getting cooperation from your original LI
Your new LI asking you questions about it and/or doubting your relationship because of it.

I think the super dramatic backlash for that scenario should be that the ME2 romance does what Kaidan/ash did when your shep joked about threesomes in ME1, and that’s LEAVE your two timing ass . The ME2 LIs refused to have a relationship with you if you were seeing someone else on the Normandy so why should their rules suddenly change for Liara?

What really surprised me was that there was no "Are you sure about this Shepard? What about miranda/tali etc?"  from Liara before you hooked up with her again.  Apparently neither of you cared that much, so yes this should definitely blow up in shepard’s face

[JG The Gamer]

Here's an idea: The cheated love interest turns into a boss battle. Not of their own accord, but something happens during the game and they end up disappearing and presumed dead, only to be found later on in the game. And as you say you're glad to see them, they say they are too. And then...

ASSUMING DIRECT CONTROL.

And then you fight your former LI to the death as they're possessed by Harbinger or his ilk. And because the LI will die likely in the battle with you, they cannot be a part of a critical point in the game and someone else close to you dies.

[Witty_Remark]

Hyrule_Gal wrote...

I think the super dramatic backlash for that scenario should be that the ME2 romance does what Kaidan/ash did when your shep joked about threesomes in ME1, and that’s LEAVE your two timing ass . The ME2 LIs refused to have a relationship with you if you were seeing someone else on the Normandy so why should their rules suddenly change for Liara?

Whatreally surprised me was that there was no "Are you sure about this Shepard? What about miranda/tali etc?" from Liara before you hooked up with her again.  Apparently neither of you cared that much, so yes this should definitely blow up in shepard’s face

[Edit]: Added quote to clarify who I was talking to.

Yeah. I think that was oversight on the part of the writers. Or maybe Liara just wanted you back so bad that she didn't want to say anything that might make you come to your senses. XD

Definitely hoping people get their just desserts in some way.

Modifié par Witty_Remark, 20 avril 2011 - 05:08 .

[PlumPaul93]

I hope there is some repercussion although I would prefer it if there was a way to choose between the LI's and not just be given an FU you cheated BS.

[Raizo]

Witty_Remark wrote...

I don't think your ME2 love interest would leave you just for finding out that you were with someone before, especially since all of your love interests are aware about the whole 'two years being dead' thing.
They'd probably leave you if in ME3 you went back to your original love interest. ../../../images/forum/emoticons/lol.png But you already mentioned you didn't want to do that so I don't think you need to worry.

I don't think cheating is a good word for it anyway. You died and your LI started to move on in your absence. Plus they (excluding Liara) turned their back on you when you really needed their help. It only could have been more of a betrayal if they had tried to arrest you.

Unless people did this:

Also don't you think the repercussions should be different if you slept
with Liara in LotSB after you romance someone in ME2? That, to me ,is
cheating whereas going your separate ways after horizon and then moving
on is not. I just hope that gets acknowledged.

^ That is definitely cheating and deserves some kind of super dramatic backlash.


Possible repercussion that I think about?

Fighting (either between you and your original LI, or between your old and new LI)
Not getting cooperation from your original LI
Your new LI asking you questions about it and/or doubting your relationship because of it.

This is the way I look at it as well.

It's only cheating if you romanced Liara in LOTSB and then you go back to your ME2 LI, or if you managed to get Kelly to come back to your quarters since that appaerntly counts as intiating a romance in addition to having an LI in ME1/ME2 or if you had a LI in ME1, got a new one in ME2 then went back to your old ME1 LI .

[markvad738]

Reaper Bob wrote...

Ashley will kill you, Kaidan will sob and cry, Liara will still love you and will ask for a 3 way.

Bloody brilliant comment!

[Puzzlewell]

I'm definitely hoping there is some kind of real repercussions beyond one conversation. I only have one playthrough where my Shep isn't loyal and that's because I do want to see just how BW handles this. It'd be rather neat if it was a case of say, old LI and new LI have a lot on tension if they are paired in a group together. I just don't want it to boil down to a "Choose between us" conversation and then it's never mentioned again.

[Urdnot Orrad]

I originally romanced Ash in ME1, and then Miranda in ME2. It was then that I realized: "Oh shi- Ash is gonna hate me guts", so I replayed that Shep and stayed loyal to her.

However, I must admit, Ash vs. Miranda would be EPIC.

[Dante Angelo]

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

I originally romanced Ash in ME1, and then Miranda in ME2. It was then that I realized: "Oh shi- Ash is gonna hate me guts", so I replayed that Shep and stayed loyal to her.

However, I must admit, Ash vs. Miranda would be EPIC.

It would be Miranda vs Jack 2.0 without the crazy biotic

[ExtremeOne]

Yeah Miranda killing Bioware and the forum's little princess in Ashley would be oh so sweeet.

[Ahglock]

Can you cheat on Ashley/Kaiden? I assume Kaiden said the same things as Ashley. There are no takesbacksies when you dump someone. Or did I misinterpret, I can;t trust you, you work for evil rant differently than others. And no an I am sorry email doesn't cut it.

[Witty_Remark]

Ahglock wrote...

Can you cheat on Ashley/Kaiden? I assume Kaiden said the same things as Ashley. There are no takesbacksies when you dump someone. Or did I misinterpret, I can;t trust you, you work for evil rant differently than others. And no an I am sorry email doesn't cut it.

Yes, it was very clear for both of them that they were done with you on Horizon. Even if they didn't really mean it, they still acted that way in the heat of the moment.

I CAN see it from their side, of having lost you, mourning you for two years, and then finding out you're suddenly alive and working for this corrupt organization... but that doesn't change that you asked for their help and they abandoned you. They didn't even offer to give you information when they could, like Liara does.

So it would take a lot of gall for them to suddenly come back and say "WTF. I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU FELL IN LOVE WITH SOMEONE ELSE AFTER I TURNED MY BACK ON YOU! YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO PINE AWAY WITHOUT MEEEEEEE!"