125 réponses à ce sujet

[HealthyGiraffe]

I still don't know what one I prefer .

[gorrillasnake]

Ashley!...miranda is to superficial

[Battlepope190]

Unfortunately not an issue for my Shepard; I refuse to play as Manshep.

[mereck7980]

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

Funnily enough, my canon Shep originally romanced both Ash and Miranda... I might just make two versions of him: One where he stays with Ash, the other where he hooks up with Miranda. That way I can see both outcomes.

Me to.  In fact, aside from the whole defeat the Reapers save the galaxy thing this is one of the most exciting aspects to ME3.  The catfight is going to be EPIC and my Shep is going to have a front row seat. 

Kinda of like this...

www.youtube.com/watch

[N7 Vanguard]

I didn't know a massive crater in the ground could have a argument with blown up space debris.

[Donixs]

I lol'd.

[mereck7980]

N7 Vanguard wrote...

I didn't know a massive crater in the ground could have a argument with blown up space debris.

Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

[Dazaster Dellus]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Dazaster Dellus wrote...

Really?! Are you 12?!

Sure they are grown women. I am guessing you have never been with one because if you have you would know that women are very jealous and territorial over their men. Also the fact that Ashley and Miranda both have strong and outspoken personalities also come into play. Along with the fact that Ashley HATES Cerberus and Miranda doesn't really have a liking for the Alliance. They are complete opposites in most areas and depending on how you played, they both may be in love with Shepard. So it only seems natural they would clash. Also, if you have ever even played ME you should know that the women in it fight with each other over a lot less.

Odd how one can now be called childish for assuming women would have a semblance of maturity.

While most of what you said is true to some extent, both Ashley and Miranda are grown, disciplined and militaristic women who've most likely had their own previous experiences with relationships.

However, I admit I am assuming what the OP meant by "catfight" was a physical confrontation. I could understand and would fully expect there to be a verbal confrontation. Heck, I would think it likely that there would be a confrontation between the two of them regardless of whether or not Shepard was in a romance with either of them.

If a verbal confrontation was what the OP meant, then that would be my mistake. However I stand by my conviction that niether or the characters would stoop to the level of an immature, ear-biting, hair-pulling tussle that everyone seems to be envisioning.

I didn't call you childish because you think both of the women are mature. I made reference to you being a child because in your very first sentence you decided to call me a moron which is something a teenager would do instad of just stating their own opinion.

Anyways, Yeah....I don't forsee them getting into a hairpulling match but then again with their different standings and ideals it wouldn't be suprising to see them go at it over something like their ideals but with their affection for Shepard acting as a catalyst.

[AngelicMachinery]

I'd think it'd be hilarious if they both left you, possibly for Legion.

[Legbiter]

Commander Shepard has alot of things on his plate, so the exact location of his ****** in ME 2 should not be given more than a precursory glance at best. If Ashley wants to call Shepard on the carpet for out****ting her in the intermediate period, she should be prepared to get schooled in the Beyotch I Have A Reaper Invasion Problem tradition.

Modifié par Legbiter, 23 avril 2011 - 02:00 .

[Dazaster Dellus]

I do think if they were to fight.......Man......I don't know. It would def have to be close quarters for Ashley to stand a chance. Take away her weapons and Ashley has nothing. Miranda has Biotics, superior speed, agility, intelligence, etc,.....at least from what she claims. I love me some Ash but I don't know if she could win that fight, even in close combat style. Though at close range she definitely has a much, much higher chance of possibly holding her own.

[Dazaster Dellus]

AngelicMachinery wrote...

I'd think it'd be hilarious if they both left you, possibly for Legion.

Ladies like guys with big hard drives

[Dazaster Dellus]

Legbiter wrote...

Commander Shepard has alot of things on his plate, so the exact location of his ****** in ME 2 should not be given more than a precursory glance at best. If Ashley wants to call Shepard on the carpet for out****ting her in the intermediate period, she should be prepared to get schooled in the Beyotch I Have A Reaper Invasion Problem tradition.

[N7 Vanguard]

mereck7980 wrote...
Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

Its not so much a issue with her, it is a issue of what her character represents. The suit... that damn suit. She is basically just a clever guise to replace interesting characters with a set of breast and cocky attitude.

[naledgeborn]

N7 Vanguard wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...
Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

Its not so much a issue with her, it is a issue of what her character represents. The suit... that damn suit. She is basically just a clever guise to replace interesting characters with a set of breast and cocky attitude.

If you manage to look past the "suit", da ass, and her breasts there's a well written and complex character there. Yes, physically she's fan service. But it's not like the writers on staff said "let's make her a good looking mute with no character development." If you give her a chance, she's pretty deep.

[Urdnot Orrad]

naledgeborn wrote...

N7 Vanguard wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...
Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

Its not so much a issue with her, it is a issue of what her character represents. The suit... that damn suit. She is basically just a clever guise to replace interesting characters with a set of breast and cocky attitude.

If you manage to look past the "suit", da ass, and her breasts there's a well written and complex character there. Yes, physically she's fan service. But it's not like the writers on staff said "let's make her a good looking mute with no character development." If you give her a chance, she's pretty deep.

^This.

Modifié par Urdnot Orrad, 23 avril 2011 - 03:11 .

[mereck7980]

Is this the magical relocking thread or what? This thing has been locked down at least four times in the last hour or so.

[Urdnot Orrad]

mereck7980 wrote...

Is this the magical relocking thread or what? This thing has been locked down at least four times in the last hour or so.

DON'T JINX IT, BRO!!!

[mereck7980]

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...

Is this the magical relocking thread or what? This thing has been locked down at least four times in the last hour or so.

DON'T JINX IT, BRO!!!

My bad...

[Urdnot Orrad]

mereck7980 wrote...

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...

Is this the magical relocking thread or what? This thing has been locked down at least four times in the last hour or so.

DON'T JINX IT, BRO!!!

My bad...

Lol. Also, I just joined the group in your sig.

[mereck7980]

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

naledgeborn wrote...

N7 Vanguard wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...
Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

Its not so much a issue with her, it is a issue of what her character represents. The suit... that damn suit. She is basically just a clever guise to replace interesting characters with a set of breast and cocky attitude.

If you manage to look past the "suit", da ass, and her breasts there's a well written and complex character there. Yes, physically she's fan service. But it's not like the writers on staff said "let's make her a good looking mute with no character development." If you give her a chance, she's pretty deep.

^This.

I agree Miri is a very deep character (as deep as any other squad member in the game).  I am trying to wrap my head around all the angst some people have to her catsuit, it isn't like she walks around in a thong.  The game even pokes fun at her choice of atire in Miranda's loyalty mission.  Plus, it seems all the angry surrounding this subject could be alleveated by just buying the alt app pack and equiping Miranda with her armor.  

[Urdnot Orrad]

mereck7980 wrote...

Urdnot Orrad wrote...

naledgeborn wrote...

N7 Vanguard wrote...

mereck7980 wrote...
Man you have some serious Miranda issues.  Why all the hate? She was designed to be perfect after all...

Its not so much a issue with her, it is a issue of what her character represents. The suit... that damn suit. She is basically just a clever guise to replace interesting characters with a set of breast and cocky attitude.

If you manage to look past the "suit", da ass, and her breasts there's a well written and complex character there. Yes, physically she's fan service. But it's not like the writers on staff said "let's make her a good looking mute with no character development." If you give her a chance, she's pretty deep.

^This.

I agree Miri is a very deep character (as deep as any other squad member in the game).  I am trying to wrap my head around all the angst some people have to her catsuit, it isn't like she walks around in a thong.  The game even pokes fun at her choice of atire in Miranda's loyalty mission.  Plus, it seems all the angry surrounding this subject could be alleveated by just buying the alt app pack and equiping Miranda with her armor.  

Ehh... people are people. I personally liked all the squadmates, from both games, to varying degrees. But there was never one that flat-out didn't like. I dunno, I guess I'm a minority here in that regard.

[ExtremeOne]

I hope Miranda destroys her

[Urdnot Orrad]

ExtremeOne wrote...

I hope Miranda destroys her

Fanboy.

[Elite Midget]

Ashley will want nothing to do with you. You cheated on her and she has an upbringing where she doesn't just take **** from anyone if you can avoid it. Miranda might say a few snide things but that'll be the most of it.

After all, who would fight over a cheater if they have any self-respect at all?