380 réponses à ce sujet

[Zatwu]

Now this is not meant to insult Ashley or anything, she's really good at fighting. But given the kind of things the Spectre's have to di I get the impression that there are a lot of logistics they need to be able to handle, and Ash has never demonstrated an ability for that. I can see her getting promoted pretty high, like I said she's a great soldier. She just dosn't seem subtle enough for a secret agent.

Modifié par Zatwu, 23 avril 2011 - 05:24 .

[JeffZero]

A lot of things can change in a person's life when their place in history is so chaotic.

[Collider]

That's what I thought.
Kaidan, sure.
Ashley? Harder to believe.
But, Bioware will take their story wherever they want. After all, socially awkward recluse Liara became Shadow Broker.

[armass]

Did i miss something? She's made to a spectre? Where is the info?

[N0touchi]

armass wrote...

Did i miss something? She's made to a spectre? Where is the info?

It's not just you. Apparently I missed the announcement.

[The-Person]

And was survivor or ruthless Shepard any more qualified?

Collider wrote...

That's what I thought.
Kaidan, sure.
Ashley? Harder to believe.
But, Bioware will take their story wherever they want. After all, socially awkward recluse Liara became Shadow Broker.

And how is Kaidan more qualified?

Modifié par The-Person, 23 avril 2011 - 05:30 .

[snfonseka]

The-Person wrote...

And was survivor or ruthless Shepard any more qualified?

Yea, they saved a god damn colony from total distruction.

[Zatwu]

Survivor and Ruthless Shepard still demonstrate a bit of brilliance on Eden Prime and finding proof of Saren's guilt.

A lot can change sure but it didn't seem to have changed by ME2, from what we got to see anyway.

[MadCat221]

N0touchi wrote...

armass wrote...

Did i miss something? She's made to a spectre? Where is the info?

It's not just you. Apparently I missed the announcement.

Me three.

[The-Person]

Zatwu wrote...

Survivor and Ruthless Shepard still demonstrate a bit of brilliance on Eden Prime and finding proof of Saren's guilt.

A lot can change sure but it didn't seem to have changed by ME2, from what we got to see anyway.

And how much do you know of what she has done since the last 2 years + couple of months since SHepard last saw her?

[JeffZero]

It was either the PSM3 article or the first of the two crudely-translated international magazine articles.

Either way, I wouldn't put this on the 100% certainty angle.

[ADLegend21]

Zatwu wrote...

Now this is not meant to insult Ashley or anything, she's really good at fighting. But given the kind of things the Spectre's have to di I get the impression that there are a lot of logistics they need to be able to handle, and Ash has never demonstrated an ability for that. I can see her getting promoted pretty high, like I said she's a great soldier. She just dosn't seem subtle enough for a secret agent.

She's alot better at logistics than Saren or Tela Vasir that's for sure.

[DanPman0317]

The-Person wrote...

Zatwu wrote...

Survivor and Ruthless Shepard still demonstrate a bit of brilliance on Eden Prime and finding proof of Saren's guilt.

A lot can change sure but it didn't seem to have changed by ME2, from what we got to see anyway.

And how much do you know of what she has done since the last 2 years + couple of months since SHepard last saw her?

No one here knows anything. The Virmire survivor becomes a spectre based on recent info from magazines

How the hell did that happen, I am sure they will explain that key piece of information

[didymos1120]

snfonseka wrote...

The-Person wrote...

And was survivor or ruthless Shepard any more qualified?

Yea, they saved a god damn colony from total distruction.

No, that's War Hero Shepard.  Or were you talking about Eden Prime?  Didn't Ash help out a bit there?

Modifié par didymos1120, 23 avril 2011 - 05:57 .

[Naltair]

Ashley would make a fine Spectre.

[Northern Sun]

She might not have had a choice. Anderson makes it clear during the ME1 prologue that Shepard doesn't.

Then again, I'm still not 100% believing the magazine about the Spectre thing.

[atheelogos]

Zatwu wrote...

Now this is not meant to insult Ashley or anything, she's really good at fighting. But given the kind of things the Spectre's have to di I get the impression that there are a lot of logistics they need to be able to handle, and Ash has never demonstrated an ability for that. I can see her getting promoted pretty high, like I said she's a great soldier. She just dosn't seem subtle enough for a secret agent.

Where did you get the idea that Spectres are secret agents or subtle?!! Their names are not classified, and Spectres usually go in guns blazing. Hell even the Councilor said this in the first game "spectres often attract a lot of attention."

[atheelogos]

N0touchi wrote...

armass wrote...

Did i miss something? She's made to a spectre? Where is the info?

It's not just you. Apparently I missed the announcement.

read masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/File:ME3-PSM3-05.png

Modifié par atheelogos, 23 avril 2011 - 06:04 .

[atheelogos]

lol my bad on that post. Link is good though.

[didymos1120]

atheelogos wrote...

Where did you get the idea that Spectres are secret agents or subtle?!! Their names are not classified, and Spectres usually go in guns blazing. Hell even the Councilor said this in the first game "spectres often attract a lot of attention."

Some of their names aren't.  But not all of them are known.  Both high- and low- profile Spectres have their uses.  For obvious reasons, the devs decided Shep would be the high-profile sort.

Modifié par didymos1120, 23 avril 2011 - 06:07 .

[ThatDancingTurian]

I don't think either Ashley or Kaidan are qualified, frankly. I'm kind of annoyed about it, I don't know that they've done anything to deserve it aside from just being there during the events of ME1. And if that's criteria, well then any of those nameless folks on the Normandy has a shot. I'm not saying they're bad soldiers. I think they're excellent soldiers. But I don't think they're Spectre material. Not yet.

Maybe we'll hear about some awesome work they've been doing while Shepard was dead, but so far we've seen them... Fail to protect colonists and refuse to assist Shepard in defeating the Collectors.

[Chaos Gate]

I think both Ash and Garrus are definitely Spectre material.

[Manic Sheep]

Zatwu wrote...

Survivor and Ruthless Shepard still demonstrate a bit of brilliance on Eden Prime and finding proof of Saren's guilt.

A lot can change sure but it didn't seem to have changed by ME2, from what we got to see anyway.

You were being looked at to be a spectre BEFORE Eden Prime (and was that even really meant to be impressive?) and both Ash and Kaidan were involved in that too. You didn't exactly see allot of them in ME2.

Modifié par Manic Sheep, 23 avril 2011 - 06:35 .

[BeardedNinja]

yeah something about that link just makes me not believe anything in it, especially about how you can unlock Liara and sex her up till she's blue in the face and they show James Sanders as the British guy from the trailer, which has been confirmed by devs to not be him.

[didymos1120]

Manic Sheep wrote...

Zatwu wrote...

Survivor and Ruthless Shepard still demonstrate a bit of brilliance on Eden Prime and finding proof of Saren's guilt.

A lot can change sure but it didn't seem to have changed by ME2, from what we got to see anyway.

You were being looked at to be a spectre BEFORE Eden Prime (and was that even really meant to be impressive?) and both Ash and Kaidan were involved in that too. You didn't exactly see allot of them in ME2.

That's a really strange objection to make too, considering that after the Prologue, what we did see was them on an actually rather Spectre-like assignment: a covert, solo operation in the Terminus, ostensibly to install colony defenses as part of an Alliance outreach program, but in truth to investigate rumors of Cerberus' involvement in the colony abductions.

Modifié par didymos1120, 23 avril 2011 - 06:39 .