70 réponses à ce sujet

[LexXxich]

Let's not forget that Ashley's granddad is now not "the only human who surrendered to aliens instead of fighting to death", but "a victim of politicians, residing from army after he was made to make peace with aliens".
Of course, one can say that we only *thought* Ashley was telling the truth, and that we only *thought* she knew how it happened.

[CroGamer002]

No more comics.
Please.

[Ninjapino]

Overall, it wasn't that good, but I thought it was much better then Redemption at least. It had a decent story, but it definitely left a lot of things open. I think I might have gone too deep into the entire ME lore that all the "unanswered" questions the comic left are actually already answered for me from other books or the wiki that I browse through on random occasions when I'm bored at work. I think the main point of Evolution was to show you who he was before hand, what role he played in humanity's expansion to the stars, and why he came to the decision in the first place to start Cerberus. Truthfully, though, if they actually want to do a ME comic, they need to do an official series with some real length to it. This four-issue crap is only going to give you a snapshot at best.

[TMA LIVE]

Nerevar-as wrote...

TMA LIVE wrote...

After reading what's on the wiki, I don't get why Saren hates humans. Before we thought it was because his brother was killed in the first contact, but that didn't happen. So why does he hate humans, and thinks they need to know their place? Because a human husk made his crazy brother (who he was already fighting against) a husk?

And he does hate humans. He expresses it in the book, and he even says "Humanity needs to know it's place" and "What do you expect from a human."

That was Drew, now it´s Walters.

Yeah, but he says those two things in ME1.

[TMA LIVE]

Ninjapino wrote...

Overall, it wasn't that good, but I thought it was much better then Redemption at least. It had a decent story, but it definitely left a lot of things open. I think I might have gone too deep into the entire ME lore that all the "unanswered" questions the comic left are actually already answered for me from other books or the wiki that I browse through on random occasions when I'm bored at work. I think the main point of Evolution was to show you who he was before hand, what role he played in humanity's expansion to the stars, and why he came to the decision in the first place to start Cerberus. Truthfully, though, if they actually want to do a ME comic, they need to do an official series with some real length to it. This four-issue crap is only going to give you a snapshot at best.

I already feel like they extended it a bit too much just to make 4 comics. Issue 2 is pointless, because despite TIM having glowing eyes, they let him go. And then TIM goes to illium just to get caught... again.

[Kusy]

dreman9999 wrote...
[...] itwas only in comic one when he was xenophobic, and in a war with a new species you never met and not understand everyone is xenophoic because they are the eneimy. By the comic 2, he starts to come around as he starts understanding and by 4 he's looking past the other species to the demons in the darkness.

Read Retribiution then. He's quite xenophobic there. Along with his right had who is alphaxenophobic.

[Mir5]

So Cerberus isn't evil from start, it's just humanity's anti-Reaper force?
Saren hates humans because he had to bomb his idiot brother?
And tim got rich by exploiting rich racist pricks?

The comic was, uh... kind of George Lucassy.

So, where do you guys think that earth's monolith is? Dome of rock? Mecca? Pyramids? Atlantis?

[Paulinius]

Mr.Kusy wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
[...] itwas only in comic one when he was xenophobic, and in a war with a new species you never met and not understand everyone is xenophoic because they are the eneimy. By the comic 2, he starts to come around as he starts understanding and by 4 he's looking past the other species to the demons in the darkness.

Read Retribiution then. He's quite xenophobic there. Along with his right had who is alphaxenophobic.

Yep. I guess it is too difficult for Bioware to get the stories straight. You would think it would not be that difficult since there are only 4 games, 4 books, and 4 comics. I am not very impressed when the average fan can quickly detect major differences in the stories while people paid to work on it cannot.

[Elvis_Mazur]

Ehhhh... I can't not like it. I think I'm too much of fan of the Mass Effect series to ever do something alike. So, I liked having at least something from Mass Effect for me to be entertained while I get stressed with university.

Even though I know its flaws, I enjoyed the read, but I wanted it in a book, because there the writer has more free space. A comic book is too short IMO.

[Rivercurse]

I preferred #3 and #4 to numbers 1 and 2, but all of them were pretty poor.

I wish they'd leave it alone, but no.. The next one is already announced. *sigh*

[Kusy]

Hope dies last... maybee this one will be good.

[didymos1120]

dreman9999 wrote...

The arm being a Geth are is just Speculation.

No, it's a fact.  Not only does it look exactly like one, the ME1 Artbook says it is: "A geth arm was grafted onto his left side."

[dreman9999]

Mr.Kusy wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...
[...] itwas only in comic one when he was xenophobic, and in a war with a new species you never met and not understand everyone is xenophoic because they are the eneimy. By the comic 2, he starts to come around as he starts understanding and by 4 he's looking past the other species to the demons in the darkness.

Read Retribiution then. He's quite xenophobic there. Along with his right had who is alphaxenophobic.

Yes, I read retribution......And calling Omega scum is an easy guess by anyone. That doesn't mean him xenophobic, just observent. The only xenophobic one in the book was Kai Leng.

Modifié par dreman9999, 25 avril 2011 - 03:48 .

[dreman9999]

didymos1120 wrote...

dreman9999 wrote...

The arm being a Geth are is just Speculation.

No, it's a fact.  Not only does it look exactly like one, the ME1 Artbook says it is: "A geth arm was grafted onto his left side."

Art books are not lore, just conspets and planning. Unless the game, books or any story medium says it, it's a sepeculation.

[bald man in a boat]

 Yeah I really didn't catch what was being explained in the comics.

Modifié par bald man in a boat, 25 avril 2011 - 03:56 .

[dreman9999]

bald man in a boat wrote...

 Yeah I really didn't catch what was being explained in the comics.

1. TIM started cerburus as a ragtag gorilla group ageint Turians in the first contact war.
2.Saren and TIM have the same eyes because of th same type of contact to reaper tach.
3. Tim start Cerburus offically to uplift humaity into space by force because he new something stonger then every thing in the galexy is coming.

[bald man in a boat]

Yeah dreman, I got that but I had that figured by the end of the first rag. The other 3 were missed opportunities mixed with wtf.

[dreman9999]

bald man in a boat wrote...

Yeah dreman, I got that but I had that figured by the end of the first rag. The other 3 were missed opportunities mixed with wtf.

And that's what makesit bad....The pacing...
It  feel so rush and thing just happen with out a proper explination.

[DRSH]

Lizardviking wrote...

The Turians in Evolution reminded me of the ****s in Indiana Jones movies.

The way TIM was dressed in the whole comic reminded me of Indiana Jones without the hat.

[XXIceColdXX]

Thought the evolution series was lame. To me the story telling in the games is great, why!!!! cant they get it right in the comics. It lowers the overall high standard of Mass Effect.

[didymos1120]

XXIceColdXX wrote...

Thought the evolution series was lame. To me the story telling in the games is great, why!!!! cant they get it right in the comics. It lowers the overall high standard of Mass Effect.

One major problem is that they only do 4-issue mini-series. For something trying to cover as much ground as Evolution, that's just not sufficient.