184 réponses à ce sujet

[Chromie]

What's DA:RtP? >.>

[Eski.Moe]

lol.
Just lol.

[FellowerOfOdin]

Dragon Age: Rise to Power.

[Heather Cline]

I'm voting for ME3. Even as much as I like DA2, with all the bugs when the game released, all the bad press and reviews. It won't make it to GOTY.

[Alex109222]

Dragon Age 2 deserves biggest flop if the year, although with Oblivion wining countless awards at E3 (it won 4, its called exageration and we all do it) and nlt only that, it was GOTY 2006 or 2005, and also Fallout 3 won GOTY 2008 or 2009, so Skyrim is halfway in the bag already, ME3 may win alot of artistic prices but I dont know.

[Volourn]

How can anyone vote for ME3/ Nobody has played it yet. L0L

Anyways, almost every agme will win a GOTY. There's like 20,000 different GOTY awards out there. L0L

I bet DA2, ME3, W2, S,a nd probably 10+ other games will win GOTY no matter their quality.

R00fles!

[Shevy]

No, no chance.

[jds1bio]

Well so far this year, assuming that:

(Scoring 80-89% was considered an excellent game for its genre, but not everyone wants to recreate the battle of Little Big Horn - quote from the old PC Gamer magazine)

(Scoring 90-100% was considered an excellent game, one that either surpasses expectations for its genre, or is a game that is attractive to most every player)

Portal 2 - stellar writing and performances, non-combat game mechanics, no tedium whatsoever (unless you are not able to solve puzzles) - the clear front-runner so far.

Mortal Kombat - while not typically everyone's cup of tea, the game has already surpassed stereotypical expectations to be worth a look to everyone

Shogun: Total War - PC only, meta-scored higher than most other games, uphill climb to actually win GOTY

Dragon Age II - Great story, some great action and dialogue mechanics, but not everyone's preferred way of playing RPGs. I've gotten many hours of playtime from this game, but I don't think it has a chance of winning GOTY. And I'm not sure that any other RPG that is not multiplatform has a chance either. All RPGs tend to have some tedium in their gameplay as a side effect of the nature of questing.

L.A. Noire - Ace Attorney (not GTA-like) for the home consoles with amazing facial animations. I have no idea.

Then there's the Dead Space 2, Crysis 2, Killzone 3 etc. - shooter sequels like these that are released in the 1st quarter of the calendar year are hard-pressed to compete for GOTY in the minds of journos when COD comes out every fall. But these are all great games.

Then there's games like MLB 11 The Show that score high but are too niche to compete. Then there are games like Just Dance 2 that sell millions beyond any other game mentioned, but will never be in the running.

And then, there's ME3 - the waiting continues.

[Teredan]

too bad most japanese games aren't included ni no kuni at least has really awesome visuals...

[Cezar_Rodrigues]

Curious... No one mentioned Uncharted 3 as a strong contender.

Uncharted 2 was GOTY at 2009 and I believe that U3 will be a contender for GOTY too. No idea if it will win (a lot of competion this year), but for me it has much more chance than DA2.

[Elite Midget]

DA2 get GoTY? Hahahahahahaha... No. It wont beat the competition.

[v_ware]

Just no way.


So far I would say Portal 2

[jimmy_smith]

No way in hell DA:II will get GOTY.

In fact I doubt it will get into candidate for GOTY or ever best RPG of the year.

[ruttunenn]

If these are the oscars of Games then DA2 would win an razzie award.

[jds1bio]

Cezar_Rodrigues wrote...

Curious... No one mentioned Uncharted 3 as a strong contender.

Uncharted 2 was GOTY at 2009 and I believe that U3 will be a contender for GOTY too. No idea if it will win (a lot of competion this year), but for me it has much more chance than DA2.

Good catch!

[Romantiq]

DAII for GOTY?? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Fat chance.

[diblob]

Lol if DA2 ever gets a GOTY award I hope all the persons involved in the voting get removed from the global gene pool in a violent and punishing fashion. It's for our own safety...

[Maverick827]

Game of the Year? Probably not - that award is typically reserved for the "summer blockbuster" of games: typically low-substance action (Call of Duty, Gears of War, Halo), only occasionally overlapping with more artistically deep titles (Mass Effect 2, Red Dead Redemption, Half-Life 2).

If there were categories such as "Narrative of the Year" or "Innovation of the Year," then I would say definitely. While most fantasy games are stuck in Campbellian-oriented mindsets or, even worse, trying their damnedest to be "edgy" and "cool" (see: Witcher), Dragon Age 2 tried something completely different. Things were rather hit-or-miss, but overall the game deserves to be praised for attempting to advance the accepted narrative structure of gaming.

If they learn from their mistakes (read: their actual mistakes, not what you'll find people crying about on these forums) and refine the rough areas, then "Dragon Age 3" will be something truly special.

[Volourn]

Prettymuch every game wins GOTY. There's 100s of those awards handed out each year.

Just take a gander at last year's GOTYs. There's more than one. HA!

I'm gonna start 3 sites myself. I'm gonna give DA2, ME3, and W2 all GOTYs on them. R00fles!

[Chromie]

Honestly I'd rather have DA2 win GOTY then another CoD.

[Galad22]

Maverick827 wrote...

Game of the Year? Probably not - that award is typically reserved for the "summer blockbuster" of games: typically low-substance action (Call of Duty, Gears of War, Halo), only occasionally overlapping with more artistically deep titles (Mass Effect 2, Red Dead Redemption, Half-Life 2).

This doesn't happen.

2010 games that got goty were most often Red Dead Redemption and ME2
2009 Batman: Arkham asylum and Uncharted 2
and 2008 LittleBigPlanet, Fallout 3 and Grand Theft Auto IV.

[Lykang]

DA2 should be in worst AAA of the year poll. And it would probably win.

[Shibby Razel]

Game of the Year should go to Mass Effect 2....again

[mykeme]

I guess it could compete with CoD in the "Most linear plot" category, if such a category even existed. It still wouldn't win, but at least it'd have a fighting chance.

Modifié par mykeme, 26 avril 2011 - 06:00 .

[Galad22]

mykeme wrote...

I guess it could compete with CoD in the "Most linear plot" category, if such a category even existed. It still wouldn't win, but at least it'd have a fighting chance.

Or most "trash mobs to kill" category. It might actually won that one.