184 réponses à ce sujet

[Sphynx118]

ahahahah cmon man. GOTY?

[hexaligned]

Shogun 2 gets my vote up to this point, I have a feeling Skyrim is going to clinch it though.

[Seena]

DA2 is a good game. It, imo has solid replay value. Does it deserve GoTY? - No,absolutely not.

[Tantum Dic Verbo]

Seena wrote...

DA2 is a good game. It, imo has solid replay value. Does it deserve GoTY? - No,absolutely not.

Maybe not, but the nerdrage brain hemorrhaging would be awesomely hilarious.

[Everwarden]

 Depends on who is giving out the GOTY. Many of those 'Game of the Year' titles can be paid for, like the VGAs.

[Anathemic]

Everwarden wrote...

 Depends on who is giving out the GOTY. Many of those 'Game of the Year' titles can be paid for, like the VGAs.

True, but who do you think EA/BioWare is going to milk the GotY more out of? DA2 or ME3?

[Tantum Dic Verbo]

Everwarden wrote...

 Depends on who is giving out the GOTY. Many of those 'Game of the Year' titles can be paid for, like the VGAs.

Pish-tosh!  Next you'll be telling me that the White Sox threw the '19 Series! 

[Chromie]

VGA's on Spike never award the little guys or games that aren't out selling everyone else.

The Bafta awards are much much better

[smooth_operator]

It would have had a chance if no other game came out in 2011, even then it would be a long shot.

[Travie]

smooth_operator wrote...

It would have had a chance if no other game came out in 2011, even then it would be a long shot.

Don't worry, I'm sure all the reviewers would commit mass suicide if it came to that.

[sympathy4saren]

Game of the year will be either Mass Effect 3 or The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

[neppakyo]

Tantum Dic Verbo wrote...

Everwarden wrote...

 Depends on who is giving out the GOTY. Many of those 'Game of the Year' titles can be paid for, like the VGAs.

Pish-tosh!  Next you'll be telling me that the White Sox threw the '19 Series! 

It was all Shoeless Joe's fault!

But he re-deemed himself in Field of Dreams.

[Pandaman102]

Anathemic wrote...

Everwarden wrote...

 Depends on who is giving out the GOTY. Many of those 'Game of the Year' titles can be paid for, like the VGAs.

True, but who do you think EA/BioWare is going to milk the GotY more out of? DA2 or ME3?

That reminds me of Ultima Online. And how Ultima Online 2 was canned by EA because it would "compete against their own product". After sinking something like two million dollars into development.

Now I don't think EA will do anything as stupid as canning or delaying ME3 to 2012 just so it won't compete against a non-contender like DA2, but you can't really count on them to make sensical choices either.

[Gatt9]

Almost all game awards are bought at this point. Either through holding sites hostage with advertising dollars and early review copies, or through some pretty weird compositions of "Voters".

Can't remember which award series it is, but one was giving Fallout 3 all kinds of awards for "Best RPG", when I looked closer, the "Industry insiders" they claimed were voting?

A newspaper columnist, a couple magazine writers (Entertainment weekly, Time, etc), a handfull of websites that have pretty definitively proven they rate advertisers and not games. I think there were 2 of twenty that were legitimate.

It's all worthless, Awards, Reviews, Previews, they're all so bought it's not worth bothering to look at. Made by big name company? 10/10 and boatloads of awards.

[Jerrybnsn]

Right now I would say Portal 2 is Goty, but I get L.A. Noire next week.

[neppakyo]

*zombie shuffles in*

..deeeeadd....thhrreeaad... ressurected.. deeead.. thhhreeead.....

*zombie shuffles out*

[Morty Smith]

possible contender? possible. possible winner? possible, but I would take a long shower afterwards.

[billy the squid]

neppakyo wrote...

*zombie shuffles in*

..deeeeadd....thhrreeaad... ressurected.. deeead.. thhhreeead.....

*zombie shuffles out*

Ahhh! back unholy creature *pulls out shotgun* back from whence you came...

*Shoots Dragon Age 2*

[IanPolaris]

Arishok:

"NO"

-Polaris

[lionalio87]

Well, it's a good game, but to compete for the GOTY trophy, awfully there is a very very little chance for it!! Even now it has met many great opponents: Crysis 2, Shogun 2, Portal 2, and now the bomb The Witcher 2 is going to detonate!!! Far to the end of the year, Mass Effect 3 and The Elder Scroll V will be the great candidate. Uh-oh, I thought that our DA2 should expect to get some small good trophy than the overall GOTY, it's just impossible.

Let's hope DA3 will be back and reclaim what have been taken from his predecessor!!!

Modifié par lionalio87, 12 mai 2011 - 11:51 .

[sympathy4saren]

Mass Effect 3 is coming out in 2012.

Game of the Year will be Skyrim. Why? Because it will blow people's minds away with the Greater Staff of Awesomeness (Awesomeness 100% on target, Constant Effect)

[Realmzmaster]

DA 2 will not get GOTY. If Skyrim is any thing like Oblivion it will not make it either. I will withhold judgement on Skyrim until I play it. Hopefully it will be more like Morrowind and not Oblivion (with its bugs and bad story.)

[Elhanan]

Reminds me of the hype seen all pre-season and seasonal for the Heisman, when it is supposed to be for that season's performance. I gave up on that, too.

[erynnar]

I have to say no.

LA Noire lookes awesome. Skyrim, ME3 (of course), TW2

[A Crusty Knight Of Colour]

Realmzmaster wrote...

DA 2 will not get GOTY. If Skyrim is any thing like Oblivion it will not make it either. I will withhold judgement on Skyrim until I play it. Hopefully it will be more like Morrowind and not Oblivion (with its bugs and bad story.)

Agreed with the last sentence, not the first.

Oblivion received tons of GOTY awards when it came out, so it's likely if that Skyrim sticks to a simila formula, it will also receive lots of accolades. I really didn't like Oblivion until it was heavily modded, but lots of people do.

As for my GOTY, with Mass Effect 3 officially off the table, I'd have to say that the main players are Skyrim, L.A Noire, Portal 2 and Battlefield 3. Witcher 2 may pickup an RPG of the year type award, or a GOTY from an RPG centric site, but it's unlikely to win too much critical praise.