387 réponses à ce sujet

[TheZyzyva]

So here goes, since regular polls make you choose 1 person from over a dozen, I'm doin my own.

Rules: Pick the top 5 squadmates you want to return as PERMANENT members. Lable them 1-5 or I'll go the order they're listed. Please no throw-ins or choosing more/less than 5 as it's gonna throw off my points and I will ignore it.

I'm giving each vote a point worth, which are as follows:
1st: 80p
2nd: 55
3rd: 35
4th: 20
5th: 10

That makes each post 200 total points, which makes my math easier in the long run.
What math you ask? I'm gonna add up the points and give them percentages of the vote. I'm setting 40p per vote as 100%, mostly because that makes my math easier but also cause with the amount of people to choose from, anything higher would result in a lot of .5% which isnt realistically helpful. This setup means that should everyone vote Tali as their number 1 (and what heartless soul wouldn't), she would have a score of 200%. Because that's how badly the collective group would want her in it. Trust me, it makes sense.

Also, please do NOT let "confirmed" characters sway your vote, I would like this to be as acuurate as possible, on the off chance the devs stumble accross it. I dream at night of having an impact on these things, just let me keep dreaming.

Feel free to defend your selections if need be (like if you have Jacob as your 1), but only votes are really needed.

I'll try to keep this updated for as long as people keep voting in it. Oh, and please don't vote more than once, it's going on the honor code since I'm far to lazy to double check these things. If you want to have any other discussions in here I don't really mind, just as always, no trolling please.

And finally, the choices. (And later results). 282 votes in.

Ashley/Kaiden: 73.4%
Garrus: 95.3%
Wrex: 48.8%
Tali: 55.1%
Liara: 43.3%
Jacob: 07.7%
Miranda: 29.7%
Mordin: 34%
Grunt: 10.6%
Jack: 18.8%
Thane: 15.3%
Samara/Morinth: 08.8%
Legion: 37.7%
Zaeed: 07.6%
Kasumi: 12.3%


Garrus might actually make it over 100%. I think it's safe to say at this point he's a pretty popular character.

Modifié par TheZyzyva, 09 mai 2011 - 09:16 .

[TheZyzyva]

Here are my votes in example form.

1. Tali
2. Wrex
3. Legion
4. Garrus
5. Thane

Tali is simply my favorite, with Wrex a very close second. Legion is to me one of the most interesting, even if he very likely was just a toss in by Bioware. Garrus is of course just Garrus freaking Vakarian, and Thane barely beats out Mordin for me, mostly cause I like monks more than scientists, however hilarious said scientist may be.

You can of course say more or less than that though.

[FireEye]

1. Kaidan
2. Ashley
3. Liara
4. Legion
5. Kasumi

1. Kaidan/Ashley
2. Liara
3. Legion
4. Kasumi
5. Wrex

Modifié par FireEye, 26 avril 2011 - 11:29 .

[jeweledleah]

KaidAn and Ashley should be one vote since they are technicaly enterchangable as far as being Virmire survivor.  if you get one, you get the other.

also, not everyone thinks that world revolves around Tali and that doens't mean they are hearltess, it doesn't even mean they hate or dislike her, it means they have different preferences.

and without further ado

1. Kaidan/Ashley
2. Garrus
3. Jacob
4. Jack
5. Thane

Modifié par jeweledleah, 26 avril 2011 - 11:07 .

[cold52]

1.wrex
2.tali
3.garrus
4.mordin
5.legion

[StefanBW]

1. Jack
2. Grunt
3. Wrex
4. Garrus
5. Legion

[TheZyzyva]

jeweledleah wrote...

KaidAn and Ashley should be one vote since they are technicaly enterchangable as far as being Virmire survivor.  if you get one, you get the other.

also, not everyone things that world revolves around Tali and that doens't mena they are hearltess, it doens't even mean they hate or dislike her, it means they have different preferences.

Good call, I'll fix that.

And it was a joke. I like to joke. Really, if anything I say sounds even halfway joking, it's because it totally is. Although to be fair, I can see how you might read that seriously, I've heard rumors of Tali fans...

[ME_Fan]

1 Miranda
2 Garrus
3 Wrex
4 mordin
5 legion

[Lyaria]

1. Garrus
2. Legion
3. Wrex
4. Kasumi
5. Tali

[Gust4v]

1. Tali
2. Mordin
3. Garrus
4. Zaeed
5. Jacob

[Malanek]

1 Jack
2 Mordin
3 Garrus
4 Grunt
5 Legion

[Razorsedge820]

1. Jack
2. Ashley
3. Garrus
4. Legion
5. Wrex

[catgirl789]

1. Kaidan/Ashley
2. Wrex
3. Garrus
4. Tali
5. Mordin

[LadyJaneGrey]

Won't defend this from a story stand point.  I most want:

• Mordin
• VS
• Garrus
• Wrex
• Kasumi

[halO bendeR]

1. Liara
2. Tali
3. Mordin
4. Legion
5. Jacob

I would have put Jack on the list, but if we get Jack back as a companion I think there's a greatly diminished chance we'll be seeing Gillian Grayson as a companion which I'd much rather have.

[FireEye]

TheZyzyva wrote...

Fireyed, since I made Ash and Kaiden one, your 5th vote goes to Samara and Morinth, because the masth was easy and I have that power.

In that case...

1. Kaidan/Ashley
2. Liara
3. Legion
4. Kasumi
5. Wrex

[CulturalGeekGirl]

1. Mordin
2. Wrex
3. Garrus
4. Kasumi
5. Tali

(I just can't vote for the VS, as much as I like them both. I sort of had and have a "we'll get what we get from them" attitude, ever since Horizon. This may be partially influenced by the fact that they're already announced, but meh, you can't turn us all into robots. STOP TRYING TO MAKE US ROBOTS.)

Modifié par CulturalGeekGirl, 26 avril 2011 - 11:29 .

[thespianicism]

1. Kaidan/Ashley
2. Liara
3. Mordin
4. Samara
5. Wrex

[Gill Kaiser]

1. Tali
2. Garrus
3. Legion
4. Jack
5. Kasumi

[nickkcin11]

1. Ashley/Kaiden
2. Garrus
3. Wrex
4. Miranda
5. Kasumi

[SpiderFan1217]

1. Jack
2. Kasumi
3. Samara
4. Grunt
5. Ashley/Kaiden

[Abramis brama]

1.Wrex
2.Mordin
3.Liara
4.Ashley
5.Garrus

[TomY90]

Miranda
Ashley
Garrus
Mordin
Legion

Modifié par TomY90, 26 avril 2011 - 11:52 .

[Sabre4000]

1.Liara
2.Tali
3.Wrex
4.Miranda
5.Ashley

[Wrexster]

 1) Wrex
 2) Grunt
 3) Garrus
 4) Thane's Son (Forgot his name)
 5) Zaeed