387 réponses à ce sujet

[Endurium]

1. Liara
2. Tali Zorah
3. Ashley/Kaidan
4. Legion
5. Miranda

Tali's really cute and I like her for the reasons I liked Aerie in BG2, but I relate best to Liara. Ashley is fun to have around and I romance her sometimes; we see eye to eye on some matters.

Other than that it's a toss-up. I really enjoy Legion as a character and there's a place in my heart for Miranda. The rest don't matter too much, as I rarely adventure with them unless recommended for an assignment or mission.

Modifié par Endurium, 27 avril 2011 - 12:00 .

[ThatDancingTurian]

1st: Garrus
2nd: Ashley
3rd: Jack
4th: Mordin
5th: Grunt

I love Wrex, he's one of my favorite characters ever, but for some reason I've never felt the need to have him on my team. He seems to be doing really well where he is.

[Faerlyte]

1. Garrus
2. Wrex
3. Legion
4. Tali
5. Mordin

*Edit: I guess I could add a little something extra here. I enjoyed all of the characters from ME2 to some extent, but with only 5 slots I have to pick and choose (the sign of a good game I suppose when you have so many favorites). I wouldn't mind seeing Jacob come back for instance, but I'll always choose alien characters over human ones. I enjoyed Samara a lot too and I'd rather have Wrex over Grunt, though Grunt did have his moments. I'm lukewarm on Thane, but I have nothing against him either and I like the Drell design. 

Modifié par Faerlyte, 27 avril 2011 - 12:13 .

[ArcanaLegacy]

Hmmmmm lets see: This is tough with JUST 5 slots

1) Garrus
2) Tali
3) Thane
4) Wrex
5) ......this is tough....Im torn b/w Mordin & Legion. Gah! Cant u put 5 points each XD since 5th has 10points.


and how there Thane b near the bottom! He must come back!!!!

[kaimanaMM]

1. Thane
2. Grunt
3. Legion
4. Mordin
5. Jacob

[TheZyzyva]

Wrexster wrote...

 1) Wrex
 2) Grunt
 3) Garrus
 4) Thane's Son (Forgot his name)
 5) Zaeed 

It's Koylot I believe... But that's going down as one for Thane since I said NO THROW-INS. Too late to change it now, this is tedious enough already.

[ThatDancingTurian]

It's Kolyat. I think it's kind of funny he voted for 'guy whose name I don't know' over a bunch of other characters. ::snicker::

EDIT: I'm calling it now, Ash/Kaidan is going to win this. They've got double the chances of being picked, because you could hate one and still like the other.

Modifié par Aris Ravenstar, 27 avril 2011 - 12:14 .

[TheZyzyva]

Endurium wrote...

Tali's really cute and I like her for the reasons I liked Aerie in BG2, but I relate best to Liara. Ashley is fun to have around and I romance her sometimes; we see eye to eye on some matters.

Other than that it's a toss-up. I really enjoy Legion as a character and there's a place in my heart for Miranda. The rest don't matter too much, as I rarely adventure with them unless recommended for an assignment or mission.

The BG2 reference really wants me to make your vote count double, and the Aerie reference makes me want to count it triple. Alas, I must do my best to be fair. Thank you none-the-less though.

[Faerlyte]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

It's Kolyat. I think it's kind of funny he voted for 'guy whose name I don't know' over a bunch of other characters. ::snicker::

EDIT: I'm calling it now, Ash/Kaidan is going to win this. They've got double the chances of being picked, because you could hate one and still like the other.

Quite true. I'm amazed Garrus has managed to out point them both this far, haha. 

[Wrexster]

[quote]TheZyzyva wrote...

[quote]Wrexster wrote...

 1) Wrex
 2) Grunt
 3) Garrus
 4) Thane's Son (Forgot his name)
 5) Zaeed [/quote]

It's Koylot I believe... But that's going down as one for Thane since I said NO THROW-INS. Too late to change it now, this is tedious enough already.

Yea sorry go ahead & put it down for thane

[Vez04]

Im gonna just say the same thing i said to a similar topic about this.

Nothing beats the old crew from the first game.

Garrus.
Liara
Kaiden.

Modifié par Vez04, 27 avril 2011 - 12:24 .

[Gethforceone]

1.Jack
2.Garrus
3.Ashley
4.Zaeed
5.Kasumi

[clerkenwell]

1. Garrus
2. Zaeed
3. Kaidan
4. Jack
5. Legion

[Merlin 47]

1. Tali
2. Garrus
3. Wrex
4. Thane
5. Legion

[jeweledleah]

Faerlyte wrote...

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

It's Kolyat. I think it's kind of funny he voted for 'guy whose name I don't know' over a bunch of other characters. ::snicker::

EDIT: I'm calling it now, Ash/Kaidan is going to win this. They've got double the chances of being picked, because you could hate one and still like the other.

Quite true. I'm amazed Garrus has managed to out point them both this far, haha. 

not relaly amazing.  Garrus is one of the few characters that's liked be pretty much every character fanbase, he's one of the oldest squadmates, and he's a bro for most.  if you notice, a lot of people who are voting for VS, are also voting for Garrus, often pretty high up on their list, becasue you get 5 choices instead of just 1.

I won't be surprised if he's the winning squadmate, not at all.

[TheZyzyva]

ArcanaLegacy wrote...

Hmmmmm lets see: This is tough with JUST 5 slots

1) Garrus
2) Tali
3) Thane
4) Wrex
5) ......this is tough....Im torn b/w Mordin & Legion. Gah! Cant u put 5 points each XD since 5th has 10points.

Well technically I could have, but if you do it then everyone else will and then what are the rules up for? Mostly for my own records and to keep it simple I just gave it to Mordin, since you typed his name out first. Thats some Freudian psych at work there.

[TheZyzyva]

jeweledleah wrote...

Faerlyte wrote...

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

It's Kolyat. I think it's kind of funny he voted for 'guy whose name I don't know' over a bunch of other characters. ::snicker::

EDIT: I'm calling it now, Ash/Kaidan is going to win this. They've got double the chances of being picked, because you could hate one and still like the other.

Quite true. I'm amazed Garrus has managed to out point them both this far, haha. 

not relaly amazing.  Garrus is one of the few characters that's liked be pretty much every character fanbase, he's one of the oldest squadmates, and he's a bro for most.  if you notice, a lot of people who are voting for VS, are also voting for Garrus, often pretty high up on their list, becasue you get 5 choices instead of just 1.

I won't be surprised if he's the winning squadmate, not at all.

More suprising: The Tali boards havent caught wind of this and posted a dozen 1-5 for Tali. I guess I thought more people would vote for her considering they are typically the most rabid fanbase.

And yes, Garrus is awesome, did really no one see that coming?

[CulturalGeekGirl]

So happy that my bro Mordin is doing so well. Soooo happy. Sheesh, he's leading the ME2 newbies!

Also, kudos to the OP for setting this up. I wouldn't wish this math on my worst enemy.

Modifié par CulturalGeekGirl, 27 avril 2011 - 12:56 .

[Faerlyte]

jeweledleah wrote...

Faerlyte wrote...

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

It's Kolyat. I think it's kind of funny he voted for 'guy whose name I don't know' over a bunch of other characters. ::snicker::

EDIT: I'm calling it now, Ash/Kaidan is going to win this. They've got double the chances of being picked, because you could hate one and still like the other.

Quite true. I'm amazed Garrus has managed to out point them both this far, haha. 

not relaly amazing.  Garrus is one of the few characters that's liked be pretty much every character fanbase, he's one of the oldest squadmates, and he's a bro for most.  if you notice, a lot of people who are voting for VS, are also voting for Garrus, often pretty high up on their list, becasue you get 5 choices instead of just 1.

I won't be surprised if he's the winning squadmate, not at all.

It'd be tough for any character, even Garrus, to out point the combined popularity of two others, especially when he's usually second in popularity to Tali. I expect him to rate very highly, but he is at a disadvantage for the reason that Aris Ravenstar pointed out. You're getting two votes for the price of one with Ashley/Kaidan. I understand the combining of the two for the purpose of the poll and that's cool by me, but if you're going strictly for specific squadmate popularity they would have to be seperate for an accurate reading. 

[lazuli]

1. Jacob
2. Miranda
3. Zaeed
4. Samara
5. Mordin

[PMC65]

1) Wrex
2) Liara
3) Zaeed
4) Mordin
5) Ash/Kaiden

[TheZyzyva]

Faerlyte wrote...

It'd be tough for any character, even Garrus, to out point the combined popularity of two others, especially when he's usually second in popularity to Tali. I expect him to rate very highly, but he is at a disadvantage for the reason that Aris Ravenstar pointed out. You're getting two votes for the price of one with Ashley/Kaidan. I understand the combining of the two for the purpose of the poll and that's cool by me, but if you're going strictly for specific squadmate popularity they would have to be seperate for an accurate reading. 

Honestly I didn't think they would do so well, I really wasn't a fan of either, especially Ash. I'm pretty surprised that Kaiden just got his first solo vote though while Ash had like 6. I literally never used either one, and on Vimire I close my eyes and click. I'm actually almost upset that they make a return; as much as I didn't care for Jacob and Miranda, I didn't care for them less than those 2. Besides, Jacob brought some much needed Bro-ness.

[TheZyzyva]

CulturalGeekGirl wrote...

So happy that my bro Mordin is doing so well. Soooo happy. Sheesh, he's leading the ME2 newbies!

Also, kudos to the OP for setting this up. I wouldn't wish this math on my worst enemy.

Yeah, I never use Mordin because I don't think he's that great, but he is far and away my favorite to talk to.

The math isn't so bad, mostly just tedious. I have a really big calculator though, so that helps. Wait, that sounds bad, I mean it really is a big calculator, its a TI-92. I'm guessing most people have never heard of it.