583 réponses à ce sujet

[jesuno]

DA:O - 9.5
DA:A - 8 (rated as an expansion)
DA 2 - 7 by itself, but a 5 as a sequel to Origins

[fn_outlaw]

jesuno wrote...

DA:O - 9.5
DA:A - 8 (rated as an expansion)
DA 2 - 7 by itself, but a 5 as a sequel to Origins

Pretty much agree...

While DA 2 had some pretty good ideas about it, its execution was terrible. 

I liked that, in Origins, you could play the same difficulty on each class and it would feel like the same difficulty.  In DA2, I found it difficult to defeat the first Ogre (first playthrough, btw) with a warrior...so I started over and played a Mage, which made the battle relatively simple.

Another problem I had with DA2 was Lore Plotholes.  For example:  weilding magic in Templar Central Station.  Talking with Templars as though your just another person when Ser Wesley knew straight off that you were an apostate as Templars should.  I mean, if they would have added a few random groups of Templars ambushing every once in awhile, it would have made the mage playthrough a little more believeable.

[Drachasor]

Going with 5 as an average quality game, I'd rate DA2 at around a 4 or 3.

[Vlud]

Dragon Age Origins : 9.5

The Other Game (they call it dragon age II , but it really should be named Torchlight : The Expansion ) : 0 , just because it isn't Dragon Age

Obviously , I did not spend 1$ on "dragon age 2" and I'm really glad I didn't

[xkg]

Vlud wrote...

... 0 , just because it isn't Dragon Age ...

Wow, nice reasoning. But please - don't write any reviews on sites such as Metacritics etc.

[csfteeeer]

Volourn wrote...

"and the story of DAO at least has severals endings!!!"

Nope. One ending. Archdemon is killed. Game over.


"People who think DA2 is better than DAO are fanboys of bioware xD"

O RLY? You do realzie that both DA1 and DA2 are BIO games right? So.. you are claiming preferring one BIO game over another makes you a BIO fanboy? That doesn't even make sense.

wow, you like to troll do ya?

"Nope, one ending, archdemon killed, game over"

there are so many things wrong with that sentence....

ok, first of all, you don't know what an ending is.

an ending serves as a way to conclude a story arc and tell what happened to the chracters on a story, in that sense, DAO had multiple endings, it tells what happened to your character, what happened to your companions, and how did you influenced the world, by your logic then nothing has multiple endings.
DA2 did not even had a bloody ending, it just ends.

also, you thing DA2 story was better and characters?

i don't like to make fun of peoples opinion but since you're a troll:
 
LOLOLLOLOLOL.

DAO story and character > DA2 story and character

not gonna say anything else to you.

[Anti-villain]

DAO = 10
DAII = 8 overall, some parts better than others though/inconsistent quality

[Kroepoek]

DAO - 8.5
DA2 - 5

[Serpieri Nei]

csfteeeer wrote...

Volourn wrote...

"and the story of DAO at least has severals endings!!!"

Nope. One ending. Archdemon is killed. Game over.


"People who think DA2 is better than DAO are fanboys of bioware xD"

O RLY? You do realzie that both DA1 and DA2 are BIO games right? So.. you are claiming preferring one BIO game over another makes you a BIO fanboy? That doesn't even make sense.

wow, you like to troll do ya?

"Nope, one ending, archdemon killed, game over"

there are so many things wrong with that sentence....

ok, first of all, you don't know what an ending is.

an ending serves as a way to conclude a story arc and tell what happened to the chracters on a story, in that sense, DAO had multiple endings, it tells what happened to your character, what happened to your companions, and how did you influenced the world, by your logic then nothing has multiple endings.
DA2 did not even had a bloody ending, it just ends.

also, you thing DA2 story was better and characters?

i don't like to make fun of peoples opinion but since you're a troll:
 
LOLOLLOLOLOL.

DAO story and character > DA2 story and character

not gonna say anything else to you.

Well said, that describes an ending very well.

[Giggles_Manically]

DA:O- 8.5

Fun game, played it lots.
Just lots of bugs, and drag, and poor divide between talking and combat (Deep Roads), lack of any real life to the PC, bland combat, and well seen it all before.

DA:A- 8.0

Okay xpac with a somewhat annoying lack of challenge, or connection to it.

DA2- 9.0

I enjoyed most aspects of this game.
A few big failures though: Not enough family interaction, re-used environments, and lack of life to Kirkwall.

Still I enjoyed Dragon Age 2 a bit more since Origins really felt dated in this day and age.
I could see my PC actually do things rather then just stare at the back of their head.
I could actually not run around watching my words horribly afraid of MORRIGAN DISSAPROVES.
Combat was actually FUN instead of a bland event I hated playing through.
Varric!

While Origins is on my top 10 fave games, I liked DA2 just a little bit more really.

[neppakyo]

Revised Edition.

DAO: 8.5 /10
DA2: 4 /10

*slips in a non BW game*

TW1: 7.5 / 10
TW2: 9 / 10

*whistles innocently*

[Luvinn]

DAO: 9/10
DA2: 6.5/10

Now im rating 5 as middle of the line average/mediocre, so its slightly above that, but not in the good (7-8) range.

neppakyo wrote...

Revised Edition.

DAO: 8.5 /10
DA2: 4 /10

*slips in a non BW game*

TW1: 7.5 / 10
TW2: 9 / 10

*whistles innocently*

I see what you did there!! Although i agree with that other games ratings!

[fightright2]

DAO: 9/10
DA2: 6/10

[Ryzaki]

DAO: 9/10
DA2: 7/10 (If act 3 hadn't been so terrible it might've gotten an 8.)

[mesmerizedish]

DA:O - 8/10
DAII - 9/10

[lanmao]

DAO: 9/10
DA2: 6/10

I enjoyed my first playthrough of DA2 but it was nowhere near as compelling as Origins.

[amers1015]

DAO: 9/10
DA2: 9/10

I absolutely loved both of them. I know I'm in the minority on DA2 and I'm okay with that.

[RaenImrahl]

neppakyo wrote...

Revised Edition.

DAO: 8.5 /10
DA2: 4 /10

*slips in a non BW game*

TW1: 7.5 / 10
TW2: 9 / 10

*whistles innocently*

There are appropriate topics on this forum to discuss "The Witcher".  This is not one of them.  <_<

[armonistan]

DA:O: 8.25/10
DA2: 9.25/10

[Verilee]

DA:O 9/10
DA2 3/10

[FiachSidhe]

DA:O - 9/10
DA:2 - 8/10

[dujh]

da0 - 9.999999995/10
da2 - 3 or 4?

[Murphy Nox]

DA:O = 9/10
DA2 = 6/10

DA2 after playing The Witcher 2 = 3/10

[Biodrone9001]

DA2 0/10
Witcher 2 10/10