29 réponses à ce sujet

[JrayM16]

The results of the that quest seem quite integral to the game's ending.  I don't know if someone asked this question already but I couldn't find out cause the search sucks. 

So how 'bout it?  Spoil away.

[Humakt83]

It will happen anyway. Anders will just do the quest without Hawke's help

Modifié par Humakt83, 01 mai 2011 - 07:49 .

[Alex Kershaw]

This is Dragon Age 2. What do you think is the outcome to a so-called choice?

[Dave of Canada]

A bit of dialogue changes but nothing drastic.

[Big I]

Anders still screws you over

[Faroth]

Yep, no difference.

Tell him yes
Tell him no
Never talk about it
Same end result

What infuriated me is that if you say you'll help, he lies and says he's trying to recreate a ritual to separate himself from Justice. Yet once you distract the Grand Cleric....he never mentions the ritual again and you can't ask about it?

[TJPags]

Yup - he needs Hawke's help.

If you don't help him, he somehow does it alone . . .or gets help somewhere else, which seems more plausible to me.

[Morroian]

Faroth wrote...

What infuriated me is that if you say you'll help, he lies and says he's trying to recreate a ritual to separate himself from Justice. Yet once you distract the Grand Cleric....he never mentions the ritual again and you can't ask about it?

He does mention it, he says he lied.

[Sabariel]

TJPags wrote...

Yup - he needs Hawke's help.

If you don't help him, he somehow does it alone . . .or gets help somewhere else, which seems more plausible to me.

...Somehow I can see him coaxing Merrill into helping him.

Anders: I'll give you candy!
Merrill: 'Kay!

[Barefoot Warrior]

lol...I just did that, and told Anders I wouldn't help him because he lied to me. It's a no win situation no matter what you do. I'd stop using him if I could but he is the only healer. oh well.... 'boom'

[JabbaDaHutt30]

Alex Kershaw wrote...

This is Dragon Age 2. What do you think is the outcome to a so-called choice?

The only answer that's needed tbh.

[Realmzmaster]

The fact that you help or do not help Anders is a choice. It does not mean that Anders cannot seek aid elsewhere. What you are trying to say is that the choice has to change the outcome. Which is not necessarily true.
You choose to remove your Hawke from any implication. Which is a personal choice. It does not have to affect the outcome.
Just like you choose to help the mages during Act of Mercy. Some escaped others were captured, which happens after your choice and beyond your control.

[JabbaDaHutt30]

Realmzmaster wrote...

The fact that you help or do not help Anders is a choice. It does not mean that Anders cannot seek aid elsewhere. What you are trying to say is that the choice has to change the outcome. Which is not necessarily true.
You choose to remove your Hawke from any implication. Which is a personal choice. It does not have to affect the outcome.
Just like you choose to help the mages during Act of Mercy. Some escaped others were captured, which happens after your choice and beyond your control.

Is there a reason you are restating the fact that this game gives us no meaningful choices?

[Sabriana]

Oh? I must've missed something in "Act of Mercy". I let the mages escape, yet they were still captured later on. Hmm....

As for the OP's question. Nothing changes. Anders will do the same thing in the end, any which way you play.

[Shadowbanner]

That's rather lame.

[Morroian]

Barefoot Warrior wrote...

lol...I just did that, and told Anders I wouldn't help him because he lied to me. It's a no win situation no matter what you do. I'd stop using him if I could but he is the only healer. oh well.... 'boom'

You don't need a spirit healer, stock up on mythals favor and life ward potions.

[Wolf Of Khorne]

i dont get how he is even in DA2. I sent him to be executed without becoming a grey warden in DA awakening, yet he still somehow became a warden, lived and was a royal pain in my @ss through all of the game.

He was somewhat funny in Awakening (if u kept him). But seeing as i didnt keep him and had the lil bugga taken away.. why is he here?!!!

[Macropodmum]

Morroian wrote...

Barefoot Warrior wrote...

lol...I just did that, and told Anders I wouldn't help him because he lied to me. It's a no win situation no matter what you do. I'd stop using him if I could but he is the only healer. oh well.... 'boom'

You don't need a spirit healer, stock up on mythals favor and life ward potions.

Agreed, I actually found him quite ineffective as a healer and being that everyone in your party can use mythals favor I found that preferable.

Wolf Of Khorne wrote...

i dont get how he is even in DA2. I sent him to be executed without becoming a grey warden in DA awakening, yet he still somehow became a warden, lived and was a royal pain in my @ss through all of the game.

He was somewhat funny in Awakening (if u kept him). But seeing as i didnt keep him and had the lil bugga taken away.. why is he here?!!!

Because his middle name is Houdini   Honestly I don't think even the circle has been able to keep track of how many times he has escaped....

[Plaintiff]

You miss out on the satisfaction that comes with helping to strike the first blow against a brutal theocratic dictatorship.

However, luckily for Thedas, the fireworks show goes on regardless.

[Blitzkrieg0811]

Alex Kershaw wrote...

This is Dragon Age 2. What do you think is the outcome to a so-called choice?

Damn straight.

[Sajuro]

Alex Kershaw wrote...

This is Dragon Age 2. What do you think is the outcome to a so-called choice?

That Anders isn't totally dependant on Hawke and if need be he can get some other people to help him?

[Wulfram]

I don't think it's unreasonable that Anders can manage it without Hawke. He just needs a couple of ingrediants and a distracted Grand Cleric, after all.

Cullen totally ignoring your warning is silly though

[Sinaxi]

Don't worry...you still see the prettiest explosion ever created! Also please continue the dragon age QQ over choices. Bioware decided you were dumb for killing off several loveable characters and therefore brought them back to life to spite you.

[CrimsonZephyr]

Wulfram wrote...

Cullen totally ignoring your warning is silly though

In character, though. He's not particularly bright.

[Sajuro]

CrimsonZephyr wrote...

Wulfram wrote...

Cullen totally ignoring your warning is silly though

In character, though. He's not particularly bright.

and you are warning him about the mage who heals the poor and takes care of kittens.