48 réponses à ce sujet

[Sanarion]

Maybe it was just me, but I was getting some pretty strong rapist vibes from Kelder, I think it was just about as heavily hinted at without absolutely stating it as they could. Anyway, he dies. Every. Single. Time. Sorry..none of my Hawkes are going to let some sick, torturing/rapist /murder bastard get away. If the Hawke I'm playing wouldn't do it, I'll have Fenris do it.

[berelinde]

Kelder will never see the outside of those ruins in any of my games. And I don't bring Fenris because I want my Hawke to be the one to kill him.

Apart from that:
Petrice (always)
Idunna (usually)
Gascard (almost always)
Ser Varnell

[Sable Rhapsody]

Killed at one point or another: Karras, Danzig, Gascard (though he always ends up dead anyway since Varric is an awesome bro and shoots him in the throat)

Killed all the time: Kelder, Petrice, Danarius, Idunna, Varnell

[Svejk]

I killed the entire Dalish tribe by accident my first playthough. I figured telling them we killed the keeper would be for the best... They overreacted.

I also left Denarius alive once, I saw "Take him," and figured it meant for Fenris to 'take him,' as in kill him. Yeah. I reloaded that one. Lost about an hour of progress too as theres an autosave immediately after the cut scene.

Also, is it possible to kill Petrice? Other than the Qunari dropping her with a headshot in the chantry.

[Wereparrot]

Beerfish wrote...

I felt bad the one game I murder knifed Javaris, I like him (even though he's a scoundrel).

It makes sense to kill Javaris, just for insurance. It turns out that he isn't lying, but you don't know that at the time.

[Ryzaki]

I've killed everyone I could atone point or another.

Most commonly though:

Merrill, The Arishok, Gascard, Kelder, Idunna, edit: Danarius (forgot about him), Danzig

Modifié par Ryzaki, 13 mai 2011 - 06:43 .

[hoorayforicecream]

With regards to not being able to take Castillon's ship... I always assumed that Castillon's men found out about his death and simply hauled anchor and got out of the city.

[ipgd]

Nobody I don't have to.

Well, besides Kelder. But I'd let him live if Kirkwall's justice system weren't apparently just as broken as the rest of it.

[tmp7704]

highcastle wrote...

Yeah, I always kill Castillon and Izzy never gets the boat and I'm always scratching my head at the why.

The Plot dictates.

[Shacary]

anders
Kelder
Dupuis
I wanted to kill Petrice but Qunari beat me to it
Idunna
castillion [ only got to him x1 tho] btw isabella got the boat despite the death of castillion , not sure if that was a glitch in dialog, she did say something about the papers and not needing them or something. I shall have to reload for exact phrasing. this isnt norm?

[haroldhardluck]

Anders - spared the first time, killed every time after.
Javaris - Always spared as he was basically harmless and amusing.
Gascard duPuis - Killed, spared and sent Templars after him. Sending the templars after him seems the best thing.
Fenris' sister - Spared and killed but spare is best as it reveals something about Fenris's past. Otherwise I let him kill everyone.
Bartrand - Spared and killed but spare is best.
Idunna - Killed every time. Too dangerous and immoral.
Dalish - Spared but only after some trial and error to find the right speech option. Merrill would not approve of killing her clan despite no reaction to killing them.
Castillion - Spared as that is what Isabella wanted.
Ser Kerras - Spared and killed but I never figured out how I did either. Killing him does generate a quest in the next act that otherwise would not exist.
Kelder - Always killed. He wanted it and deserved it.
Petrice - Let Quanri kill her.

Harold

[MG800]

Killed in some playthroughts: Javaris, Gascard, Fensister, Bartrand, Kerras ("Meredith sent for the Right of Annaulment" why, thank you for this story-useful information)

Always killed: Keldar, Idunna, Denarious, Arishok (I would like to let him live for once - gotta keep Izzy neutral... or away from Hawke)

Modifié par MG800, 14 mai 2011 - 11:28 .

[Fieryeel]

I killed everyone possible, even companions except...

[CalJones]

Anders - Always spared (and always romanced) but I'm finally on a templar run and will have to kill him this time. I'm rather dreading it. In spite of what he did, he's my favourite companion.
Javaris - Always spared. He's obnoxious but he hasn't actually done anything wrong. Killing him would be straight up murder.
Gascard duPuis - He died accidentally in my first game - I spared him and then forgot to go and tell the templars he was innocent. He got hanged. I've spared him since then but I understand killing him, given the blood magic and demons.
Fenris' sister - Spared every time.
Bartrand - Killed first time but spared in subsequent runs.
Idunna - Killed three times, sent to templars once. She doesn't get away with it, either way.
Dalish - Spared every time (also after a bit of trial and error with the dialogue options - the obvious one isn't the one to use, it seems).
Castillion - Spared once, killed once. (Isabela didn't return on my third run, the dirty pirate ****).
Ser Kerras - Haven't killed him thus far - I've always either tricked the templars into letting the mages leave or (current game) handed the mages over to the Circle.
Kelder - Spared him the first time because the girl asked me to but killed him every time since.
Petrice - If I could have killed her myself I would have. But a Qunari arrow to the head will have to do.

[The Dubious]

My most recent play-thru...

Killed...
-Kelder (retribution!).
-Slavers (I loath slavery/slavers- got what they deserved).
-Castillion (slaver!).
-Idunna (I just can't bring myself to trust her entirely).
-Arishok (to heck if he's running off with my pirate friend, I'd like to spare him).

I wanted to kill several other characters I (unfortunately) couldn't because someone else beat me- Petrice and Elthina

Spared...
-Anders (worms his way into my heart and sympathies each time- never killed).
-Javaris (doesn't do anything heinous).
-Gascard duPuis (ties into some profound rationalization- but I felt better about him than Idunna).
-Varania (really for Fenris' sake due to his horrible ability to rationalize during outbursts of rage).
-Bartrand (cause Varric asked when Anders did his thing).
-Dalish (what more can these people lose? I sometimes contemplate if it would be sort of a mercy killing, but I'm not the type to wipe out a clan- I respect the Dalish).
-Ser Kerras (Varric my silver-tongued buddy always got my back)

Think that's all...

[Master Shiori]

My list of people who kicked the bucket on my canon playthrough:

Kelder
Idunna
Gascard du Puis
Mother Petrice
Ser Alrik
Arishok (in duel)
Anders (my favorite victim)

[Lintanis]

Modifié par Lintanis, 14 mai 2011 - 02:45 .

[Liliandra Nadiar]

It shifts some, but generally I try to avoid killing outside of forced combat, and make fair attempts to avoid conversation paths that end in combat. There are exceptions.

Kelder. Like everyone else, though I'm more surprised that no one has mentioned that his prefered victims were children. If one considers mid-teens (was guessing Lia was around 14-15) still children.
Karras. Other then my very first game where I let Verric talk us out, and my templar support game.
Gascard. Via Varric. Because Verric's lines/expressions are just awesome like that.

Also highly disappointed that only my Rogues could murder knife the bandit leader in the Wayward Son quest. Most. Epic. Kill. EVER!

Modifié par Liliandra Nadiar, 14 mai 2011 - 02:48 .

[CalJones]

I love that kill! I saw that one for the first time recently and was practically bouncing on my chair with glee. (I'm not sure that my deportment befits a middle aged woman but once a gamer, always a gamer).

[Liliandra Nadiar]

Oh I hear you. By the time I ran a rogue through, I had already beaten the game with 2 mages and had a warrior at act 3 and another in the deep roads and a third (very first) deleted in act 3 due to realizing I had messed up a great deal. The quest was pretty mundane by that point. I got there, not expecting much more then normal, but noticed a new option. Thought something along the lines of 'Oh, must be something to do with having talked to both his dad and Thrask'. Two seconds later my jaw was on it's way to the apartment's ground floor and if it wasn't for the 'pause at combat start' option, I very likely would've been killed before I moved.

[Avilia]

Died :

Idunna - she might whine and blame that other chick, but she's happy enough to have Hawke slit her own throat
Kelder - Fenris is all over that one
The slaver whose name I can't remember who sends you to the Wounded Coast
Gascard - in his Estate
Anders - or what's left of him by that time
Varania - but that's Fenris' decision imho - if the game mechanics dictate she dies, well, she dies
Ser Alrik - (Can you not kill him? Didn't know that)
Carver - does it count if you meta game the decision to go to the Deep Roads without Anders?

I see no reason to kill Javaris - but I did on one occasion.

Modifié par Avilia, 14 mai 2011 - 11:11 .

[MoMan313]

Spared eveyone except anders.. >_> for seb |D

[Sabariel]

I've killed everyone who can possibly be killed at least once.