Aller au contenu

Photo

Kingdom Hearts -- One who knows nothing can understand nothing


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1045 réponses à ce sujet

#526
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

Seifer006 wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

This is a thread dedicated to all the Kingdom Hearts fans out there. Let's discuss everything there is to discuss: Storyline, characters, theories, strategies, etc..

EDIT -- Here are some gameplay vids and trailers of Kingdom Hearts: Dream Drop Distance, A.K.A Kingdom Hearts 3D

Kingdom Hearts 3D Gameplay Video #1

Kingdom Hearts 3D Gameplay Video #2

Kingdom Hearts 3D Gameplay Video #3

Kingdom Hearts 3D Gameplay Video #4

Kingdom Hearts 3D Tokyo Game Show Trailer

Kingdom Hearts 3D Jump Festa Trailer



Very big fan of KH1 & 2...the others I didn't like. I'm a big fan of Ansem (Billy Zane version) since he was far more talented then the replacement VA.

The storyline IMO of KH have gotten so ****ing weird & confusing that I gave up on the series. If KH3 proves any worth I may check it out.

Also if anyone knows where I can post suggestions to Squaresoft on KH3 please send me the contact information. I like to see if they can bring back Billy Zane (the VA for Ansem) Thanx

Ansem Dialogue (KH1)


While I enjoyed Billy Zane as Ansem: SOD, the new VA is decent

The reason they didn't get him back was money

Modifié par AresKeith, 20 novembre 2013 - 09:35 .


#527
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages

Seifer006 wrote...


Very big fan of KH1 & 2...the others I didn't like. I'm a big fan of Ansem (Billy Zane version) since he was far more talented then the replacement VA.

While not having played BBS I still find that game to be among the most interesting of all the games. The three seperate intertwining storylines, Aqua (best KH protagonist), good characters like Xehanort and Eraqus and generally a much darker tone with an intriguing plot. I do agree that I prefer the gameplay of the first 2 games and KH1 & 2 had some awesome chemistry between its characters; LIke Hayden Panettiere & Haley Joel Osment sounded great in the first game. They were pretty cute in their scenes together. Also the Organization were intriguing, characterwise they introduced duality in the villains with moral complexity.

The storyline IMO of KH have gotten so ****ing weird & confusing that I gave up on the series. If KH3 proves any worth I may check it out.

I think it goes without saying that once you introduce time travel into your plot, then it becomes a cluster****. With the arrival of 3DS I have no idea what's going on anymore either. Gametrailers has sort of made a timeline trailer, but that doesn't exactly sum up things you didn't, or couldn't have figured out yourself anyway. 

Also if anyone knows where I can post suggestions to Squaresoft on KH3 please send me the contact information. I like to see if they can bring back Billy Zane (the VA for Ansem) Thanx

Ansem Dialogue (KH1)

No idea where you do this. I guess you could try search the net for a petition for it. I do support this - While Epcar was fine in some scenes in KH2 (excluding the flashbacks to KH1 where they for some reason had him voice over Billy Zane:huh:)  -- In 3DS, however, he sounds terrible.  He's not alone though I think. Jesse McCartney is doing okay, but he isn't on the same level as he was with KH2 Roxas. For instance, when he says "Shut up" in the 358/2 Days movie to Riku, it sounds off-key and weird. When he did that scene in KH2 it sounded great. No idea why they had to re-record that in the first place.  Joel Osment & David Gallagher still sound amazing as always though. Those have remained good since the beginning.

Modifié par TheChris92, 20 novembre 2013 - 09:27 .


#528
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

Seifer006 wrote...
The storyline IMO of KH have gotten so ****ing weird & confusing that I gave up on the series. If KH3 proves any worth I may check it out.

I don't think that'll change with Kingdom Hearts III. Maybe Square Enix will learn a lesson about convolution and take that experience into the next KH saga. I doubt it though

#529
Seifer006

Seifer006
  • Members
  • 5 341 messages

AresKeith wrote...

The reason they didn't get him back was money


Actually the Truth wasn't about the Money...it was about masculinity. Billy Zane was too masculine compared to the replacement VA (including the Ansem version in the off-side-quels.......yeah I know terrible but it's the truth.

I don't have the reference of it anymore since it was years ago when they did the Developer Interview from the translated Japanse site

Modifié par Seifer006, 21 novembre 2013 - 03:35 .


#530
Seifer006

Seifer006
  • Members
  • 5 341 messages
Just thankful that the KH1 remix KEPT THE SAME ANSEM VA........

#531
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

Seifer006 wrote...

AresKeith wrote...

The reason they didn't get him back was money


Actually the Truth wasn't about the Money...it was about masculinity. Billy Zane was too masculine compared to the replacement VA (including the Ansem version in the off-side-quels.......yeah I know terrible but it's the truth.

Real talk, this makes little to no sense. Masculinity? What that even mean here?

#532
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages

J. Reezy wrote...

Seifer006 wrote...

AresKeith wrote...

The reason they didn't get him back was money


Actually the Truth wasn't about the Money...it was about masculinity. Billy Zane was too masculine compared to the replacement VA (including the Ansem version in the off-side-quels.......yeah I know terrible but it's the truth.

Real talk, this makes little to no sense. Masculinity? What that even mean here?

What he said^ Not sure what you're on about, Seifer. :?

Apparently, some people speculate it's because the man got 'blacklisted' or something. I don't think anyone truly knows the reason why he got switched out, same as why they keep switching out Christopher Lee with Corey Burton.

Modifié par TheChris92, 21 novembre 2013 - 04:15 .


#533
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages
Wait... I recall that being brought up earlier in the thread.... pretty sure by Seifer himself. And I don't buy into it still.

think it goes without saying that once you introduce time travel into your plot, then it becomes a cluster****


True, but that to me really only applies if it's not a stable time loop. And it's not like it hasn't been introduced before, where it's still a stable time loop.

For instance, the reason King Mickey knows about the Keyblade? Because Sora traveled back in time to protect Disney Castle. And then if I understand it correctly he became a Musketeer probably to learn about swordsmanship and then apprenticed himself under Yen Sid, and eventually took part in the BBS storyline and then sought out Ansem the Wise.

It's all internally consistent, but you'd definitely need to look at all the games.

#534
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages

Yeah, I don't like the sound that. I certainly hope the Command system of BBS is better than that. I'll miss the system of KH1 & 2.


BBS has the cooldown you were referring to, where it's just wait a bit and you get the attacks back. But definitely check out Re:CoM. It's not too bad to get used to gameplay wise, but it's really the story that's worth it.

#535
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages

J. Reezy wrote...

Seifer006 wrote...

AresKeith wrote...

The reason they didn't get him back was money


Actually the Truth wasn't about the Money...it was about masculinity. Billy Zane was too masculine compared to the replacement VA (including the Ansem version in the off-side-quels.......yeah I know terrible but it's the truth.

Real talk, this makes little to no sense. Masculinity? What that even mean here?


I was right, Seifer006 did say it earlier in the thread.

TEWR wrote...

Seifer006 wrote...

I'm a big fan of
KH1. I love how SquareSOFT (not enix at the time) made KH1. Ansem was
my favorite character. Billy Zane was the best VA for Ansem. I wish they
kept him. I remember reading somewhere from one of the devs that they
wanted a different VA for Ansem because they didn't like how Ansem was
to masculine............that's what happens when you merge with
Enix.....


Well, first, merging with Enix was hardly a bad thing.

Actually, IIRC from something I read (no source to provide, unfortunately) Zane wanted more money.

And Richard Epcar's
voice is deeper then Billy Zane's (so kinda gets rid of the "Ansem was
too masculine in KH1" point). Though Zane's voice did fit perfectly with
it, such that it's forever entombed within my mind how he was Ansem.

I
think Richard Epcar is a very talented actor and perfect for Terranort,
Xehanort, and maybe a few other -norts. And I think he does an
astounding job as Ansem as well (especially now that the people at KH
weren't trying to make him outdo Billy Zane's voice acting*), but I also
think Zane was amazing as well.

*For KHII, the people at Square
Enix did want Richard Epcar to outdo Billy Zane's voice acting, which
resulted in it seeming... while not bad, certainly was kinda hammy. In
Re:CoM, Epcar was allowed to tone it down a notch, which he was thankful
for.


Now, I'm hesitant to say I'm certain Zane wanted more money, because I don't have a source and it could just be me thinking I read something somewhere when I never did. Plus, I don't want to make him seem like a douche.

But, that's really all I can think up.


In 3DS, however, he sounds terrible


Nah, he didn't sound terrible there. I liked his voice acting there. Now that he's not being forced to outham Billy Zane

Modifié par The Ethereal Writer Redux, 21 novembre 2013 - 08:03 .


#536
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...


In 3DS, however, he sounds terrible


Nah, he didn't sound terrible there. I liked his voice acting there. Now that he's not being forced to outham Billy Zane

In 3DS he sounds like he has a cold or something - Completely terrible. Especially when he utters the line 'You, can try!" at 10:14 in this video. The prime of his cringyness is of course when he voices over the scenes, originally with Billy Zane, in KH2. That aside he's okay, but not great at all. He's not charismatic and doesn't carry that same aura of intimidation as Zane. Nimoy & Paul St. Peter carry the scenes their respective characters are in. Absolutely perfect.

#537
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

TheChris92 wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...


In 3DS, however, he sounds terrible


Nah, he didn't sound terrible there. I liked his voice acting there. Now that he's not being forced to outham Billy Zane

In 3DS he sounds like he has a cold or something - Completely terrible. Especially when he utters the line 'You, can try!" at 10:14 in this video. The prime of his cringyness is of course when he voices over the scenes, originally with Billy Zane, in KH2. That aside he's okay, but not great at all. He's not charismatic and doesn't carry that same aura of intimidation as Zane. Nimoy & Paul St. Peter carry the scenes their respective characters are in. Absolutely perfect.

After coming across this today, even though his lines are delivered kind of horrible, I still have to give him a pass.

Modifié par J. Reezy, 21 novembre 2013 - 10:16 .


#538
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Wait... I recall that being brought up earlier in the thread.... pretty sure by Seifer himself. And I don't buy into it still.

think it goes without saying that once you introduce time travel into your plot, then it becomes a cluster****


True, but that to me really only applies if it's not a stable time loop. And it's not like it hasn't been introduced before, where it's still a stable time loop.

For instance, the reason King Mickey knows about the Keyblade? Because Sora traveled back in time to protect Disney Castle. And then if I understand it correctly he became a Musketeer probably to learn about swordsmanship and then apprenticed himself under Yen Sid, and eventually took part in the BBS storyline and then sought out Ansem the Wise.

It's all internally consistent, but you'd definitely need to look at all the games.

But again - The thing with time travel is that it always creates paradoxes. Let's take an example from Legend of Zelda -  In Ocarina of Time there's this Windmall Man, a music enthusiast, that teaches Link 'A Song of Storms' he can use to stop speeding windmill., Paradoxically, this is the song Link played for him seven years earlier, which caused the windmill to speed up in the first place. Link can then go back seven years and play that same melody inside the windmill, which will drain the Kakariko Well completely and allow entry to the Bottom of the Well in order to search for the Lens of Truth. This becomes a clusfter****, because then you have to ask. Where did the song come from? It becomes an endless circle of contrived nonsense. This is the same thing with Xehanort suddenly being able to travel back ine time. Since the Seeker of Darkness does not allude to anything other than wanting access to the Realm of Darkness, and not to fulfill some old man's Xanatos Gambit in placing 13 hearts inside 13 dudes or whatever -- Stuff has definitely been retconned or changed, which has caused me to scratch my head a couple of times. When Xehanort confronted Sora on the islands for instance, why was he 'REALLY' there at all? Was it to lead Riku astray so that he'd ultimately attract the heartless there Also how, a bit unrelated, but how does Xion suddenly have a heart? I don't really know. Right now I'm trying to think what it was that Young Xehanort said in 3DS but I can't remember, because writing this makes my mind go on recess. A lot of things in Kingdom Hearts can't be understood unless one reads the director's own reports or interviews, because there are so many confusing things going on.

Let me just add that I preferred it all when KH2's Organization XIII were misunderstood villains, who just wanted hearts of their own. The addition of duality and struggles within the villains was great, and it even made Xemnas partially sympathetic, when it's then revealed that he probably never lost his memories anyway in 3DS and wanted to fulfill an Old Man's nonsensical Batman Gambit plan.. It just makes all the character development in KH2 & 1 feel a bit pointless, especially when they chose to bring Axel back, somehow. Xehanort even said that everything didn't go to 'plan' with Sora interferring, and yet it did anyway because reasons. And Xion having a heart, even though hearts is beyond any system, according to Ansem; It can't be 'data' so to speak, given that she was created from data.. Yeah, let's just say the plot has just become so downright confusing I cannot even keep up with it all anymore.

Modifié par TheChris92, 21 novembre 2013 - 11:05 .


#539
Guest_Miscellaneous Mind_*

Guest_Miscellaneous Mind_*
  • Guests
"One who knows nothing can understand nothing"

Wow. That is so profound. It's like I got shot through the heart (and this statement is to blame) by a truth-coated arrow via the Great Bow of Knowledge.

#540
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages

Since the Seeker of Darkness does not allude to anything other than wanting access to the Realm of Darkness, and not to fulfill some old man's Xanatos Gambit in placing 13 hearts inside 13 dudes or whatever -- Stuff has definitely been retconned or changed, which has caused me to scratch my head a couple of times.


To be fair, if you're going ahead with a plot of this scale, you're not going to blab about it to people so they can stop you.

When Xehanort confronted Sora on the islands for instance, why was he 'REALLY' there at all? Was it to lead Riku astray so that he'd ultimately attract the heartless there


Do you mean the Seeker of Darkness? If so, it was so he could 1) Destroy the world so it would help form a Kingdom Hearts from the hearts of worlds and 2) seek out potential vessels, probably because he could sense the darkness in Riku.

We know the Seeker of Darkness had full command over the Heartless, being one himself. Naturally, he was spearheading an invasion. Part of his original Xehanort persona still drove him to seek out knowledge in this way, and it happened to be consistent with helping Master Xehanort achieve his ends.

If it succeeded, great! If it didn't, no problemo!

Also how, a bit unrelated, but how does Xion suddenly have a heart?


Xemnas answers this. He says that a heart can grow in anything, even beings that have banished their own heart.

Xion may not have had a heart, but as she had memories to go off of she was able to feel emotions. As a result, the emotions allowed a heart to form. She's not so much data as she is just a puppet, a construct. Her memories are data, true, but they allowed her genuine emotions and experiences which gave her a genuine heart.

Let me just add that I preferred it all when KH2's Organization XIII were misunderstood villains, who just wanted hearts of their own. The addition of duality and struggles within the villains was great, and it even made Xemnas partially sympathetic, when it's then revealed that he probably never lost his memories anyway in 3DS and wanted to fulfill an Old Man's nonsensical Batman Gambit plan.. It just makes all the character development in KH2 & 1 feel a bit pointless, especially when they chose to bring Axel back, somehow. Xehanort even said that everything didn't go to 'plan' with Sora interferring, and yet it did anyway because reasons. And Xion having a heart, even though hearts is beyond any system, according to Ansem; It can't be 'data' so to speak, given that she was created from data.. Yeah, let's just say the plot has just become so downright confusing I cannot even keep up with it all anymore.


See, I still see Xemnas as being sympathetic because I think that's one of the few instances where Terra shines through. Remember, he lost his memory and only had vague recollections of who he was before he became Xehanort. Then, he only had a year's worth of memories to draw off of, all of them filled with a lusting for power, rage, hatred, and other things.

So when he says "Unfortunately... I don't..." I still see that as Terra's self shining through because he doesn't remember anything other then those things. And he's unable to be anything other then this pawn in Master Xehanort's game. Xemnas is a very complicated individual, particularly because it's two souls in one body, with one practically being forced into doing these things.

He's still sympathetic.

And while Master Xehanort didn't account for Sora, Sora's actions still helped the plan. For instance, his giving himself over to darkness because Kairi's heart was within him made him a suitable spare vessel, as is explained. In addition, it's said (by Nomura, I believe) that the constant fighting combined with the Anti-Form Sora drawing itself from his Heartless experience is gradually beginning to increase the levels of darkness in Sora.

As for Axel, this is also explained. When a Heartless and a Nobody are destroyed in that order, a person can be brought back. Logically, this means that sometime between KH1 and KH2, we fought Axel's Heartless. The logical assumption is that it was the Volcanic Lord Heartless, or a Heartless Roxas fought. The heart stays in a sort of stasis until its host body and soul are then destroyed.

Go out of order, however, and a person cannot be brought back.

"One who knows nothing can understand nothing"

Wow. That is so
profound. It's like I got shot through the heart (and this statement is
to blame) by a truth-coated arrow via the Great Bow of Knowledge.


You have proven the point of the quote by coming into a thread discussing Kingdom Hearts without even understanding Kingdom Hearts or the quote in its actual context when it's used.

Modifié par The Ethereal Writer Redux, 21 novembre 2013 - 11:40 .


#541
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

To be fair, if you're going ahead with a plot of this scale, you're not going to blab about it to people so they can stop you.

I think that's partly the problem, I'm gonna mention this below but.. The problem is the fact that the plot has been spread so thin now on so many side-games for different platforms, that one can barely keep track of it. It doesn't help that a lot of necessary exposition for why this and that happened, can only be explained through reading interviews with the director, because the game never provide enough of an explanation.

Do you mean the Seeker of Darkness? If so, it was so he could 1) Destroy the world so it would help form a Kingdom Hearts from the hearts of worlds and 2) seek out potential vessels, probably because he could sense the darkness in Riku.

We know the Seeker of Darkness had full command over the Heartless, being one himself. Naturally, he was spearheading an invasion. Part of his original Xehanort persona still drove him to seek out knowledge in this way, and it happened to be consistent with helping Master Xehanort achieve his ends.

If it succeeded, great! If it didn't, no problemo!

But in 3DS it was explained that apparently worlds never get destroyed, but 'put to sleep?'. The actual Kingdom Hearts is behind the door, as far I know, unless they confirmed in one of the side-games that it was but an artificial gathering of all hearts like in KH2. I think my problem with the story is that there are no threads that helps integrate these revelations that the director keeps pulling out of nowhere with every game, like say with the stuff about Xion below here.

Xemnas answers this. He says that a heart can grow in anything, even beings that have banished their own heart.

Xion may not have had a heart, but as she had memories to go off of she was able to feel emotions. As a result, the emotions allowed a heart to form. She's not so much data as she is just a puppet, a construct. Her memories are data, true, but they allowed her genuine emotions and experiences which gave her a genuine heart.

The process of encoding a heart is incalculable. It's so much more than any system. If what we take from Ansem then the whole thing about Xion shouldn't make sense since she was created from data; Like Ansems Twilight Town inhabitants. They too were created from real hearts like the Riku Replica & Xion. She can feel emotions, but they aren't supposed to be hers but that of someone else. That was what was established with the Nobodies, and I just hate the fact that it is now a fact; That they can 'grow hearts of their own'.


See, I still see Xemnas as being sympathetic because I think that's one of the few instances where Terra shines through. Remember, he lost his memory and only had vague recollections of who he was before he became Xehanort. Then, he only had a year's worth of memories to draw off of, all of them filled with a lusting for power, rage, hatred, and other things.

So when he says "Unfortunately... I don't..." I still see that as Terra's self shining through because he doesn't remember anything other then those things. And he's unable to be anything other then this pawn in Master Xehanort's game. Xemnas is a very complicated individual, particularly because it's two souls in one body, with one practically being forced into doing these things.

And yet he did, apparently. In 3Ds it was explained that the whole idea behind the Organization was to scatter the hearts of Xehanort into 13 vessels. Which means he must not have forgotten, otherwise he could have not seen this plan through; It's all there in the opening cutscene of that same game. When he was characterized as a 'Nobody' cast off from the original Xehanort in KH2 who wished for a of his own; That's where I found him sympathtic. In BBS I can understand that the idea is that Xemnas is the part that looks like Terra, whereas Xehanort looks more like a Young Xehanort. The thing is though that Terra wasn't a character that existed during the time of KH2, so I don't count that quote as any relation to him.

As for Axel, this is also explained. When a Heartless and a Nobody are destroyed in that order, a person can be brought back. Logically, this means that sometime between KH1 and KH2, we fought Axel's Heartless. The logical assumption is that it was the Volcanic Lord Heartless, or a Heartless Roxas fought. The heart stays in a sort of stasis until its host body and soul are then destroyed.

Go out of order, however, and a person cannot be brought back.

The thing is that I find this to be a rather poor explanation when one only has assumptions to go on, especially when it's related to a central plot element of Xehanort somehow being revivied. A concept that should have been introduced in KH2, where the Nobodies were in the spotlight -- It also beckons the question of why Xehanort needed to throw his heart away in first place. Why couldn't he assemble these vessels without throwing his own heart away? It was first established from his reports in the first game, that he did it all, so he could research the heart and enter through the DTD. But apparently his motives were 'changed' in BBS/DDD to fit this contrived nonsense that is Xehanort's Batman Gambit. The story at this point feels like a desperate attempt to drag the horse out for too long 'till it dies of exhaustion. Every game has introduced new contrived revelations to Nobodies, Heartless, Xehanort, stuff we thought we already had a good grasp of. It's getting rather annoying, especially when time travel came to be. In fact, let's all just have this video explain things for us.

Anyway, I feel like there's more to discuss, but I gotta go, so I'll see what you have to say when I back. :)

Modifié par TheChris92, 21 novembre 2013 - 12:42 .


#542
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests
Nomura has reached Kishimoto levels of pullings things out of thin air to make the plot or elements of it more contrived. I guess it's not all that hard to do but it's still pretty impressive.

#543
Guest_Miscellaneous Mind_*

Guest_Miscellaneous Mind_*
  • Guests
Hah. I must have touched a nerve, The Ethereal Writer Redux (<--- lol). Look, I know people like you hold certain game plots and quotes from it more sacred than Muslims do the Quran, but there's no need to get so defensive about it.

#544
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages
No, you didn't hit a nerve. I just found it funny, is all.

#545
TEWR

TEWR
  • Members
  • 16 989 messages

But in 3DS it was explained that apparently worlds never get destroyed, but 'put to sleep?'.


Not so. Worlds do get destroyed, but after Sora sealed Kingdom Hearts and brought the worlds back some of them weren't completely brought back and were thus sleeping.

The actual Kingdom Hearts is behind the door, as far I know, unless they confirmed in one of the side-games that it was but an artificial gathering of all hearts like in KH2.


Both were valid means to attain Kingdom Hearts, through different means. No one knows what Kingdom Hearts is precisely other then the light, but there are many different ways to create it, the common theme between them being hearts.

I think my problem with the story is that there are no threads that helps integrate these revelations that the director keeps pulling out of nowhere with every game, like say with the stuff about Xion below here.


3DS actually has a feature that allows you to understand a lot of the previous games' elements. Memoirs, IIRC. Explanations of past characters, plots, etc.

The process of encoding a heart is incalculable. It's so much more than any system.


True, but Vexen wasn't encoding a heart into Xion. It seems I was wrong on Xion though. She was a replica created from Roxas by Vexen, and a lot of her memories are the result of this creation. Because she was a replica born from Sora's Nobody Roxas, memories leaked into her (the Keyblade, Kairi, etc.) and this is why she has Sora's memories.

This also influences how people see her. Roxas and Axel begin to see her as her Kairi-esque self, while Xigbar sees her as Ventus. Saix sees her as just a hollow puppet.

Let's also remember that Ansem is not the be-all, end-all authority. He's as prone to error as we are. After all, if data couldn't have a heart, why does Tron exhibit emotions and show he has a heart?

That said, Ansem's quote refers more to how it's foolish to assume you can understand a heart's limits, because the heart has NO limits. He was thoroughly convinced the Data TT inhabitants would behave in a way he thought and envisioned. They didn't. They still exhibited free will and emotions, which shocked him to the core.

The point is that you can't understand the heart, because the heart is beyond mortal comprehension. Data itself can create a heart (again, Tron, who is a program yet feels emotions). Axel even says that the Riku Replica managed to gain a sense of self in the Secret Reports of Days. Vexen even classifies them as being special forms of a Nobody, rather then simply "data".

She can feel emotions, but they aren't supposed to be hers but that of someone else. That was what was established with the Nobodies, and I just hate the fact that it is now a fact; That they can 'grow hearts of their own'.


Her memories of those emotions help her to understand emotions, not feel another person's emotions. Eventually, those understanding of emotions became real emotions, and she could grow a heart because of it. That was what KHII told us, through Saix, and DDD told us through Xemnas' reveal.

"True we don't have a heart. But we remember what it's like. That's what makes us special".

Other material in KHII and Re:CoM told us that they do this so they can simply remember what it was like, because they don't think they can have genuine emotions of their own. And in Re:Chain and the original Chain of Memories, Axel felt an actual emotion and caught himself in the moment, expressing surprise.

It was something I picked up upon immediately, foreshadowing how Nobodies can grow their own hearts. This wasn't the only moment. Axel's entire story in KHII is laden with emotions and Roxas shows rage, sorrow, and acceptance of his fate.

What aren't hers are the original memories she had. But those, as I said, influence some of her actions and as she lives she gains her own memories which go back to her having emotions of her own, thus creating a heart.

And yet he did, apparently. In 3Ds it was explained that the whole idea behind the Organization was to scatter the hearts of Xehanort into 13 vessels. Which means he must not have forgotten, otherwise he could have not seen this plan through; It's all there in the opening cutscene of that same game. When he was characterized as a 'Nobody' cast off from the original Xehanort in KH2 who wished for a of his own; That's where I found him sympathtic. In BBS I can understand that the idea is that Xemnas is the part that looks like Terra, whereas Xehanort looks more like a Young Xehanort. The thing is though that Terra wasn't a character that existed during the time of KH2, so I don't count that quote as any relation to him.


But Terra did exist during KH2. Final Mix anyway, where you fight his Lingering Sentiment. And Xigbar says in both FM and the reg. version that Sora isn't anything "like the others", implying Terra, Ven, and Aqua. And of course, Final Mix showed him visiting Aqua's armor, calling it "friend".

Xemnas doesn't remember his previous life as Terra. As Xehanort sure. If we assume Xehanort was one of the 13 vessels (likely) then he was present in the gathering in 3D, which explains his understanding of the 13 vessels bit. He doesn't need memories of his time as Master Xehanort to know what's going on. Remember, Xehanort is essentially another name for Terranort, since it's their union.

A concept that should have been introduced in KH2, where the Nobodies were in the spotlight --


It was touched upon a lot in some subtle moments in Re:Chain and shown all throughout KHII. Days further added more to it with the Organization's time in the limelight.

It also beckons the question of why Xehanort needed to throw his heart away in first place.


IIRC, he didn't NEED to. He was just curious to see if a person could banish their heart from their body and retain their sense of self. Additionally, I believe it was to also give them better control over the darkness to create their vessels. People lost to the darkness and strong of will were suitable vessel material, because he could then put MX's heart in them.

Xemnas wasn't necessarily lying when he said they'd get hearts again. They would just have been Nort'd instead of getting their original hearts back. By having them believe they were always without a heart, he had them distance themselves from genuine connections which would've allowed them to grow a heart through emotions, and thus were always empty (save for Axel, Roxas, and Xion).

While it's possible to corrupt a heart into being suitable (like was done with Xigbar, due to his scarring from MX and his final moments as Braig), this method was easier. It allowed him to just insert -nort into them like a CD in a disc drive.

Modifié par The Ethereal Writer Redux, 21 novembre 2013 - 01:47 .


#546
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages
Bah, nevermind - My post became a contrived mess now. I'll add my follow up statements later on.

Modifié par TheChris92, 21 novembre 2013 - 03:48 .


#547
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages
Fighting the Dark Lord of the Sith, Xemnas - This battle is quite fun.

#548
Guest_Catch This Fade_*

Guest_Catch This Fade_*
  • Guests

TheChris92 wrote...

Fighting the Dark Lord of the Sith, Xemnas - This battle is quite fun.

His lightsabers are blue in the Final Mix right?

#549
TheChris92

TheChris92
  • Members
  • 10 639 messages
Nah, they are red - The best part is that he starts off the battle by shooting lightning at Sora, which he deflects with his keyblade, like it was a lightsaber, almost as if Sora was Yoda and Xemnas being the Emperor from Star Wars, lol.

Modifié par TheChris92, 22 novembre 2013 - 12:14 .


#550
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

J. Reezy wrote...

TheChris92 wrote...

Fighting the Dark Lord of the Sith, Xemnas - This battle is quite fun.

His lightsabers are blue in the Final Mix right?


Why would they make them blue?