40 réponses à ce sujet

[JamesX]

According to IGN
http://pc.ign.com/ar.../1011624p5.html 

[Teppil]

OMG star wars tie fighter at #2 lol i played that game SO long ago, so many times.

[Luckyluke03]

That list is silly.

[Kilsot]

That list is not silly. Most of it I agree with. Why C&C is ahead of Starcraft is beyond me though.

[Ashbery]

DeusEx at 21 while **** like Call of Duty and Crysis is higher.Meh.

[Luckyluke03]

OK, some of that list is silly. Like having Command and Conquer on top of Starcraft right after talking about how innovative and genre-changing Starcraft was.

And X-COM at #1? Really?

Modifié par Luckyluke03, 31 octobre 2009 - 01:42 .

[wearyvagrant]

Well the fact that they included System Shock 2 on the list tells me these guys had at least some idea of what they were doing. But I have to agree with Ashbery, Deus Ex down the ladder at 21? What the heck is that about? I really don't have any problems with the list but there's no way Crysis can be higher than Deus Ex...

Modifié par wearyvagrant, 31 octobre 2009 - 01:49 .

[Tiuwaz]

as far as such lists go, this one is actually pretty good

[FalloutBoy]

I sure hope that guy in the X-Com screenshot has some action points left.

[sirkook]

Crysis at #17. Apparently I wasn't playing the same game as these guys, nothing about that game except the graphics deserved to be anywhere near a top 25 list.

[Mistersunshine]

No Planescape: Torment?



IGN, you are dead to me.

[Godzina]

The list is fine, but of all the Lucasfilm Games, it should have been Monkey Island I or II in that Grim Fandango spot.

[Terwox_]

Damnit, now you're making me wanna play Baldur's Gate 2 again. Although, that will probably help easing the wait til the 6th... hmmm.

[soteria]

I thought it was a pretty good list. I don't know if I would have put XCOM at the top of the list, but top 5 I definitely would--it was certainly one of the most engaging PC games I've ever played, and the graphics have actually aged pretty well, especially compared to, say, Starcraft.



I knew one of the Civ games would be there... IMO all of the top 5 deserved the title. I've never played Crysis, but as shooters go, it's certainly highly popular.

[Corbin Netharia]

No Duke Nukem? No Space/Police/Kings Quest? No Oregon Trail?

Lame

[Achromatis]

No Duke Nukem, lame.



I got bord of Crysis after shooting the same korean(thats what they were) in tan safari for 4+ hours.

[GhoXen]

It's an article, not a poll. Those "results" mean nothing.

[Lotion Soronarr]

It's the top 25...not top 100. Kinda hard to include everyone favorite game in just 25 entries.



That said, Sword of the Stars is not there. A travesty. The list needs more love for excellent canadian development studios.Blizzard? HA! Bio and Kerberos blow it out of the water every day of the week (and twice on Sunday).

[Spaghetti_Ninja]

I agree with 3 and 4. The rest... not really.

[Vesoralla]

Where are my Gold Box Games?!? Baldur's Gate doesn't exist without Pool of Radiance.



At least Rome: Total War made it into the top 10. Most complete strategy game I've ever played. You know you've got a complete game when you discover that the Senate hates you so much, they send you on the mission.......to commit suicide.

[knownastherat]

Jagged Alliance 2

Ivan Dolvich: [Speaking Russian; upon finding a weapon he likes] If I keep quiet, I will be able to keep it for myself! - http://www.imdb.com/...t0243339/quotes

[Zilod]

lmao at the list, expecially at x-com as best game of all time, was the guy who made the list a dev of x-com? it was a fun game but nothing exceptional...



tie fighter btw is one of my fav game but dont think i had ranked it 2 (well actually ranked 1st considering X-coml, is ranked 1st. again lol)



same can be said for civ IV (boring) vs original civ (awesome) and a game that kinda started a genere

[Houkka]

Broken Swords, Monkey Islands (1-3), Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis, Commander Keen, Warcraft 2, Age Of Empires... Even Heroes of Might and Magic is missing!



Oh well, I guess this list is still a hell of a lot better than the usual attempts to list the best games ever.

[Lotion Soronarr]

knownastherat wrote...

Jagged Alliance 2

Ivan Dolvich: [Speaking Russian; upon finding a weapon he likes] If I keep quiet, I will be able to keep it for myself! - http://www.imdb.com/...t0243339/quotes

Seconded. Truly an amazing game. Playing it right now (1.13 mod + mah3.5 + Wildfire0.6). FUN!

[frano1]

vampire masquarade redemption is best game of all times its just underated alot..i dont understand...great vampire rpg game...