40 réponses à ce sujet

[Tiskenburdle]

What!?! No Masters of Orion? MOO is an Icon, how can they put X-Com at #1 and then totally forget MOO. That, and Unreal tournament above Doom?

[gotthammer]

Not a bad list. Ultimately, tho', lists like these are still 'biased'/'subjective'. We all have our favourites, after all, no matter how 'objective' we claim to be.



@Tisken: Heh. Yeah. I don't know (nor would I care to) how much time I burned on MOO...or other Microprose games (Sword of the Samurai, Darklands, flight sims, gah...)



I do like how they put Tie Fighter there, tho'. That was one of my all-time favourite space 'flight sims'. IMHO, X-Wing vs Tie Fighter would've been better if it had the campaigns from both its predecessors.

[Korruptted]

I can't take any list seriously that has Crysis and The Sims on it lol

[Valcutio]

That list is ridiculously stupid. BG2 should be #1. Sorry, but these "lists" mean less than nothing.

[gotthammer]

Korruptted wrote...

I can't take any list seriously that has Crysis and The Sims on it lol

Why not? The Sims, I think, introduced PC gaming to a 'different'/broader audience. I mean, there must be a reason why one part of the 'new PC games' section in our local game stores always have Sims titles on them.
(I personally got bored w/ the game quickly...obviously not my cup of tea)

As for Crysis: haven't played it. Tho' I assume that's really mostly for the graphics thingy.

[kevlarcardhouse]

gotthamer has it right. A List always pisses off people because everyone has their own favourites.



Also, you whiners can shove it because Crysis is on par with Half-Life 2 and Deus Ex as far as I'm concerned.

[GhoXen]

kevlarcardhouse wrote...

gotthamer has it right. A List always pisses off people because everyone has their own favourites.

Also, you whiners can shove it because Crysis is on par with Half-Life 2 and Deus Ex as far as I'm concerned.

Half Life 2 would smash both those two games added together.

[Beechwell]

I even think The Sims deserves a place higher in the list. The only shame is that the franchise is now just milked for easy profit.



Quite a few 1st person shooters there. I think they should have discarded one for something different. I am missing some old games like tetris or lemmings.

[Valcutio]

The Sims belongs on that list if for no other reason than it suckered a lot of lonely females into gaming. Crysis doesnt belong on the list at all - what did it do? Set the graphical bar so high that most computers at the time couldn't play it? Whoopty doo. The first half of the game was great but once the aliens started attacking it was just silly.



Sorry, that list is fail.

[kraidy1117]

Baldurs Gate 2 and it's expansion are first in my books, with STAR WARS TIE-FIGHTER BEHIND, that game kicked ass.

[Mordaedil]

Valcutio wrote...

The Sims belongs on that list if for no other reason than it suckered a lot of lonely females into gaming. Crysis doesnt belong on the list at all - what did it do? Set the graphical bar so high that most computers at the time couldn't play it? Whoopty doo. The first half of the game was great but once the aliens started attacking it was just silly.

I stopped playing at that point, but I really enjoyed the first half a lot.

I could play it over and over again and it really does make the game.

[Khumak]

I agree with about half of the list, mostly the older games. They should have broken it out by genre though. A few of the ones on that list I've never played and would never have had any desire to. Some of the others like Xcom and BGII I STILL play.

Actually I just checked the list again and Master of Orion 2 is not on it!  Thumbs up for putting Civ on the list but MOO2 is far more deserving than some of the other titles.  There's some oddball games that don't really squeeze into the standard molds that should be one a list like that too.  Things like Syndicate, Starcon 2, and Master of Magic.

Then there's my all time favorite game to play while drunk, SCORCHED EARTH!!

Modifié par Khumak, 22 décembre 2009 - 02:16 .

[whtnyte-raernst]

Any "list" that would include The Sims <ACK!> and not Diablo II:LOD is whacked from the start!

[IAGTTBleed]

Everyone has a different opinion on lists like this. I reckon the only reason list like this are made is to stir up some debate.



X-COM is still a godly game, definitly one of the best PC games.



(In my opinion)

[Andarthiel_Demigod]

That list is rubbish. BG, DX ,Civ IV and Crysis don't belong there at all.
Where's Bloodlines, KOTOR2 and MGS?

[Xiphias]

Ashbery wrote...

DeusEx at 21 while **** like Call of Duty and Crysis is higher.Meh.

Crysis doesn't belong there, but the original Call of Duty definitely does and I'd even put it slightly higher than Deus Ex. It's just a shame it's been all downhill from there.

It's a very weak list for Strategy Games, RTW and CoH shouldn't be on there at all and it's missing all Paradox games and Men of War.

And no Thief or Independence War game.

Modifié par Xiphias, 22 décembre 2009 - 01:41 .