Dasher1010 wrote...
Seriosuly? Who attacks the geth when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you get your homeworld back only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Guest_Calinstel_*
Modifié par Calinstel, 23 juin 2011 - 01:10 .
It's about timing. They have waited more than a hundred years. To decide now is the time to invade is stupid. Heck if they waited another couple of years the Reapers might have even done their job for them. Alternatively if the Citadel races don't manage to defeat the Reapers and the Quarians wanted to run off and hide somewhere, they would do so in the migrant fleet anyway without a massive waste of resources.Someone With Mass wrote...
Dasher1010 wrote...
Seriosuly? Who attacks the geth when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you get your homeworld back only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
As stupid as the other races that tries to reclaim their homeworlds? Like... the human race?
Guest_Saphra Deden_*
Malanek999 wrote...
It's about timing. They have waited more than a hundred years. To decide now is the time to invade is stupid. Heck if they waited another couple of years the Reapers might have even done their job for them. Alternatively if the Citadel races don't manage to defeat the Reapers and the Quarians wanted to run off and hide somewhere, they would do so in the migrant fleet anyway without a massive waste of resources.
Malanek999 wrote...
You talk to them and they acknowledge the Reapers in ME2. They know they are coming.
It's not a plan as such its just accounting for a possibility. The Reapers are going to go around planets wiping out life. That includes Geth. If the Reapers wiped out the Geth on the Quarian homeworld and were then defeated, the Quarians could just move back in without having to fire a shot. How is that stupid?Someone With Mass wrote...
Malanek999 wrote...
It's about timing. They have waited more than a hundred years. To decide now is the time to invade is stupid. Heck if they waited another couple of years the Reapers might have even done their job for them. Alternatively if the Citadel races don't manage to defeat the Reapers and the Quarians wanted to run off and hide somewhere, they would do so in the migrant fleet anyway without a massive waste of resources.
That plan is also very stupid.
And this is what we are saying is stupid. Non-combatants are going to be much safer in a mobile ship than a planet which is on the Reapers hit list. And attacking the Geth is likely to be extremely costly even if successful.Someone With Mass wrote...
Malanek999 wrote...
You talk to them and they acknowledge the Reapers in ME2. They know they are coming.
You know what they also said? That they need a safe place to put their non-combatants on before going to war.
Malanek999 wrote...
It's not a plan as such its just accounting for a possibility. The Reapers are going to go around planets wiping out life. That includes Geth. If the Reapers wiped out the Geth on the Quarian homeworld and were then defeated, the Quarians could just move back in without having to fire a shot. How is that stupid?
They will go after the Quarians as well but it is much harder to go after a target that can move and you don't know where it is.Someone With Mass wrote...
Malanek999 wrote...
It's not a plan as such its just accounting for a possibility. The Reapers are going to go around planets wiping out life. That includes Geth. If the Reapers wiped out the Geth on the Quarian homeworld and were then defeated, the Quarians could just move back in without having to fire a shot. How is that stupid?
Because there's also a very good possibility that the Reapers might go after the quarians too.
Someone With Mass wrote...
Malanek999 wrote...
You talk to them and they acknowledge the Reapers in ME2. They know they are coming.
You know what they also said? That they need a safe place to put their non-combatants on before going to war.
TexasNationalist wrote...
A two-front war against two separate synthetic species (one of which is hyper-advanced) with such a small population prone to disease is unwise.
Modifié par Praetor Shepard, 23 juin 2011 - 01:34 .
Okayshnizzler93 wrote...
Krogan are stupid. Seriously? Who is involved in a civil war when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you can be united only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Salarians are stupid. Seriously? Who is debating the merits of the genophage when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you all agree it was bad only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Humans are stupid. Seriously? Who is holding Shepard on trial when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you bring him/her to justice only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
/thread
Modifié par Serpenttt92, 23 juin 2011 - 05:07 .
shnizzler93 wrote...
Dasher1010 wrote...
Seriosuly? Who attacks the geth when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you get your homeworld back only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Krogan are stupid. Seriously? Who is involved in a civil war when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you can be united only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Salarians are stupid. Seriously? Who is debating the merits of the genophage when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you all agree it was bad only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
Humans are stupid. Seriously? Who is holding Shepard on trial when they're about to be wiped out by the reapers. Yeah, you bring him/her to justice only to be melted down into goo to build a reaper a few days later. How dumb can you be?
/thread
JimiShep wrote...
It would be terrible if that Captain on Virmire was already indoctrinated before you meet him and he goes back to the STG a new agent of Harbinger!!! I would hate that!!!
You're missing the point. Every single ship larger than a shuttle in the Migrant Fleet is filled to the gills with non-combatants. They can't go to war with their warships cram full of refugees. Besides, we don't even know if they are at war wit the Geth.Malanek999 wrote...
And this is what we are saying is stupid. Non-combatants are going to be much safer in a mobile ship than a planet which is on the Reapers hit list. And attacking the Geth is likely to be extremely costly even if successful.Someone With Mass wrote...
Malanek999 wrote...
You talk to them and they acknowledge the Reapers in ME2. They know they are coming.
You know what they also said? That they need a safe place to put their non-combatants on before going to war.
If that was the case how do they intend to retake their homeworld? However it isn't isn't true. They have a small navy, research ships, scout ships, manufacturing ships, liveships etc etc. I'm not suggesting they should engage the reapers with their fleet. But launching an attack on the Geth now is not a strategically good move.Lord Aesir wrote...
You're missing the point. Every single ship larger than a shuttle in the Migrant Fleet is filled to the gills with non-combatants. They can't go to war with their warships cram full of refugees. Besides, we don't even know if they are at war wit the Geth.
It is true, the majority of their ships are filled with noncombatants. Smaller scouting vessels are the exception. Again, who says they are at war with the Geth.Malanek999 wrote...
If that was the case how do they intend to retake their homeworld? However it isn't isn't true. They have a small navy, research ships, scout ships, manufacturing ships, liveships etc etc. I'm not suggesting they should engage the reapers with their fleet. But launching an attack on the Geth now is not a strategically good move.Lord Aesir wrote...
You're missing the point. Every single ship larger than a shuttle in the Migrant Fleet is filled to the gills with non-combatants. They can't go to war with their warships cram full of refugees. Besides, we don't even know if they are at war wit the Geth.
The migrant fleet is 50,000 ships. Even with the majority stacked with civilians that is still a lot of ships. And they do have a combat wing. We don't actually know they have attempted to retake their home planet although it was strongly hinted they were about to in ME2 and is rumoured for ME3. This thread is taking that as an assumptionLord Aesir wrote...
It is true, the majority of their ships are filled with noncombatants. Smaller scouting vessels are the exception. Again, who says they are at war with the Geth.
Retour en haut
