21 réponses à ce sujet

[Proto-Man]

At 0:25 he says the geth are working for the reapers. The base seems to be Cerberus occupied though and Legion is assisting you so.... discuss.

[Thompson family]

Looks that way. The question is, can they be turned? Or is this a Heretic remnant?

[Mr.House]

*grumbles*

[Blze001]

Could be that the default import assumes you didn't help Legion?

[J. Finley]

Here's hoping they're Heretics. I don't want that rewriting decision to be for nothing.

[Mr.House]

Thompson family wrote...

Looks that way. The question is, can they be turned? Or is this a Heretic remnant?

Nah, it's Bioware not making our choices matter.

[baryonic member]

Thompson family wrote...

Or is this a Heretic remnant?

I hope this is it, otherwise BioWare will feel my fury.

[Kreid]

Probably has an explanation, might be a remnant cluster of heretics, or maybe Cerberus got a hold of some Geth throught the Overlord research data, let's not assume anything rashly.

[Proto-Man]

Creid-X wrote...

Probably has an explanation, might be a remnant cluster of heretics, or maybe Cerberus got a hold of some Geth throught the Overlord research data, let's not assume anything rashly.

Yeah I hope It's Overlord related. That will make It matter more than just getting an email or something.

[Paulinius]

This is odd. I'm assuming it's Cerberus created/controlled Geth.

If there were remaining Heretics, they would have eventually received the rewrite code the next time they linked in with the now former Heretics, assuming you rewrote them.

If the Reapers unleashed a new virus to rewrite the Geth, then Legion would have turned as well. Plus, the Geth are on the opposite side of the galaxy from where the Reapers entered Batarian space.

And if the Geth willingly decided to join the Reapers, Legion should have turned against you. Plus why would Legion be on the Quarian ship (I assume he's there to broker a peace between the Quarians and Geth) if the Geth have joined the Reapers and would then want to destroy all organic life?

[Aloren]

Well, this probably depends on the choice you made in the previous games; this is just like saying "Mordin is not dead ?"

[diskoh]

I think they probably tried to show stuff in the demos that is the least spoilery as possible. As such, I bet they used a playthrough where the geth were not reprogrammed.

[CrybabyXD]

maybe shepard handed over legion to cerbus in this instanc.

[Proto-Man]

Aloren wrote...

Well, this probably depends on the choice you made in the previous games; this is just like saying "Mordin is not dead ?"

This is a bit bigger than just some "other salarian scientist" being there instead of mordin
. This is a huge ****ing reaper on Rannoch.

If choices would have such an impact I'll be seriously impressed.

[Paulinius]

diskoh wrote...

I think they probably tried to show stuff in the demos that is the least spoilery as possible. As such, I bet they used a playthrough where the geth were not reprogrammed.

Good point. Bioware has access to player decisions, so they can see what percentage of players rewrote the Geth or not; activated Legion or not; or gave David (was that his name?) to Cerberus or not in Overload. Like you said, they may have picked a scenario that the least amount of players chose for that particular demo.

But that would mean there would be completely different missions based on your choices. That would be awesome and make for extra replayability, but would they really spend that time to make different missions for different choices? I hope so, but it will probably would just be something cheesy like they just change a few lines of dialouge or even worse-you decision didn't matter.

[Cosmar]

The explanation will have to be damned impressive to prevent me from becoming enraged. Whatever your choice was in Legion's loyalty mission, it was supposed to have taken care of the heretic problem. Geth working for the reapers sounds way too ME1. Please don't rehash old plot lines, Bioware.

I really hope the demo segment really was just when Legion's loyalty quest wasn't completed...

Modifié par Cosmar, 09 juin 2011 - 12:52 .

[Envor44]

It might be default choice's consequences that assuming Shepard didn't help Legion at Heretic Station or only Geth at Heretic Station received the rewrite code, and remaining Heretics Geth still work for the Reapers.

[Zaxares]

I thought this was a fairly easily explained situation:

1. If you chose to turn Legion over to Cerberus, then the Heretics went ahead with their plan to rewrite the Geth, and all the Geth are now assisting the Reapers.

2. If you helped Legion with his loyalty mission and destroyed the Heretics, some small clusters of Heretics who didn't link back up with Heretic Station might have survived. (Perhaps in too small numbers to be intelligent enough to know to link back.) These pockets are then found by the Reapers, and assimilated into the Reaper's invasion force.

3. If you helped Legion with his loyalty mission and re-wrote the Heretics, most of the Heretics do rejoin the Geth, but a portion of the Heretics still come back to the same conclusion that worshipping the Reapers is the best course of action (particularly since they're now HERE), and so join up with the Reapers anyway.

[WizenSlinky0]

Could be a lot of things.

Even if you used the virus on the geth, Legion mentioned that the changes would occur overtime as the geth units networked, not immediately. If you destroyed it I'm sure there's still other instances of heretics in the geth.

The fact legion is still helping you indicates more of a split in the Geth than the entirety of the geth assisting the reapers.

There's also the possibility this comes after choosing to support the Quarians, as their fleet is in orbit. Thereby relinquishing the possibility of utilizing the Geth as an ally.

[JamieCOTC]

It sounds like two of the biggest decisions in the game canceling each other out, i. e. keeping the Collector Base (renegade) and rewriting the Geth (paragon). In other words, both Paragons and Renegades can be equally screwed.