I get what the blogger was saying, and yes, I found Miranda's ass shots to be annoying after a certain point (and mostly random once I got the alternate pack DLC- random metal bottom in my face, why?) but I do take issue with how the writer tries to frame her argument and how she perceives the characters, which is through a very specific lens- one that I feel went looking for problems.
My biggest annoyance is that there seems to be a complete lack of regard to the fact that the women in question- and honestly, all the female squaddies-totally own their sexuality and themselves. Yes, Miranda uses hers for an edge and yes, I have some questions about the functionality of Samara's epic cleavage (although I imagine they have distracted one than one baddie). Do I believe part of this was fanservice? Yes, absolutely, in the same way Thane's outfit was as well, along with Jacob's, which emphasises a 'good' male body, at least by human standards.
Miranda, Jack, and Samara make no apologies for who they are. They are three women shaped by extraordinary circumstances who didn't assume the position and take everything life was throwing at them. One rescued her sister from a emotionally unstable homelife, one disavowed mortal luxuries and endured great hardship to track down the daughter she loves and kill her, and one went from tragedy to tragedy and came out damaged pretty badly.
For the individual characters: I didn't particularly care to see Miranda's jumpsuit eat her ass every time we had a conversation, but that outfit fits her personality. Functional, attractive, it gets the job done. Yes, it's figure emphasising. Yes, Miranda knows that. And yes, Miranda uses that to her advantage. Yeah, I like her alternate outfit better but to each their own- there are plenty of strong women out there who like to flaunt their assets, whether for compliments or as a form of control. As a woman who buys all her clothing baggy and dark so I never have to worry about colour clash (aka you wouldn't find me dead in that sort of get-up), I'm cool with that and I don't care. If some dude wants to drool over her in the meantime, have fun with that. The IRL Miranda's will eat you up and spit you out.
For Samara: Part of the outfit I saw as justicars needing something extremely iconic- something you can spot from a distance that says 'I will f--k your **** up' in bright, bold letters. That outfit does the trick. Additionally, justicars operate in asari space, where boobs are the standard since everyone already has them. That outfit might not be particularly sexual where they come from. Again, yes, there probably was fanservice involved, and as a straight girl myself, her breasts aren't particularly alluring to me. That doesn't stop her from being a freight train of awesome. Sexy outfit =/= automatic weakness.
As for Jack... poor Jack, she's less a woman and more an example of what happens when a society (in this case, the mini ecosystem of Cerberus) fosters pragmatism over morality. She's broken as well, and she doesn't mind letting you know. Her outfit is less 'look at me, I've got ******' and more 'I'm powerful, I'm scary, I'm not like you and I'm letting you know that
right now.'. She lives to be abrasive, rude, and frightening to the average layman. Her outfit is meant to offend. It makes perfect sense for her character. Although I admit, they should have made an alternate outfit for some jaunts. That has to get chilly after a while.
There are still roads to be crossed when it comes to gender equality in video games- hell, in society in general- but I find these articles to be problematic mostly because a lot of it is less 'this is what's wrong with the world!' and more 'These don't fit my views of a STRONG WOMAN and therefore it is WRONG.' Strength means so many different things to different people, and by such emphasis, at least towards the ends, on the physical, the actual social aspect of the article is lost in a wave of 'boobs everywhere, I don't like it CATER TO MY PERSONAL OPINION OF WHAT A WOMAN SHOULD BE.' I have always believed that feminism is nothing more than a demand for the right to prove myself- and for all women to do so- and that we are capable of excelling in whatever field we choose as well as any man could. I hate when it becomes something about how we dress or carry ourselves. We're all women, and we should embrace the many nuances that make us strong.
Modifié par Valentia X, 13 juin 2011 - 03:51 .