Yeah, I definitely see Liara giving up her Shadow Broker gig. Not immediately, I think it would still be useful for some time after the Reaper war, until the galaxy gets back on track. But after that, I think she'd give it up, quite gladly even. I imagine that while a part of her enjoyed all the shadowy information business, she also finds the job a great burden and realises it would change her if she kept it up. I like to think she mostly stuck with it to help Shepard with the Reapers and once that is finally and truly done, she'd rather return to a more normal life.CrimsonN7 wrote...
On the subject of fanfiction I remember recently reading a few pieces that had Liara and Shep settling down to raise a family, but these authors had Liara giving up her ShadowBroker post for good and handing the reins over to Feron. My question is could you see Liara doing that or do you think she would share the load with Feron more instead of giving up completly?
Liara Fans: keep your love blue and true!
#38276
Guest_frudi_*
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:37
Guest_frudi_*
#38277
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:43
#38278
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:44
Edit - Note that living out a peaceful life doesn't mean she gives up any research or scholarly efforts. There's nothing stopping Liara and Shep from still doing research and archaeology work just because Liara wants to. Just, stuff away from all the war and fighting, doing stuff because they want to, not because they have to.
Modifié par Aristobulus500, 25 mai 2012 - 11:45 .
#38279
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:46
CrimsonN7 wrote...
I agree here, that ending really crushed my spirit and it's only through the forums, fan created fiction, art and videos of the loyal and dedicated fanbase who have poured so much love and effort into their works that has helped ease the pain and subdue the rage and disappointment that I felt after completing what could have been the most defining game of my generation.Thank the goddess for all the talented Mass Effect fans all over the world, you guys/gals to me were the only glimmer of light in the darkness that Bioware left us in:)
On the subject of fanfiction I remember recently reading a few pieces that had Liara and Shep settling down to raise a family, but these authors had Liara giving up her ShadowBroker post for good and handing the reins over to Feron. My question is could you see Liara doing that or do you think she would share the load with Feron more instead of giving up completly?
I have a hard time imagining Liara would simply give up the Shadow Broker role. There's simply too much that can be done with it. Too much that can be learned. Too much that can be influenced. I think that if she tried to give that up she would wind up feeling unfulfilled. That would make for an interesting story, though...
In one of the unpublished stories that I was working on, she stays on as the Shadow Broker in a diminished role, mostly because throughout the course of the Reaper war most of the Broker's networks were compromised or destroyed (not canon, as it turns out), but also so that she could keep her nose clean while she and Alice raised their daughter.
#38280
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:56
TheMarshal wrote...
I have a hard time imagining Liara would simply give up the Shadow Broker role. There's simply too much that can be done with it. Too much that can be learned. Too much that can be influenced. I think that if she tried to give that up she would wind up feeling unfulfilled. That would make for an interesting story, though...
In one of the unpublished stories that I was working on, she stays on as the Shadow Broker in a diminished role, mostly because throughout the course of the Reaper war most of the Broker's networks were compromised or destroyed (not canon, as it turns out), but also so that she could keep her nose clean while she and Alice raised their daughter.
Being the Shadow Broker is really dangerous, though. And all the references to the time she has to spend on it? That’s not a good environment to raise a child in, at all. Shepard going around getting shot at isn’t really a great career in that respect, either.
I’m kind of undecided on this point…it’s not an acute issue in Unity, so I figured I’ll let the characters decide which way they want to go if/when the time comes.
Modifié par lillitheris, 25 mai 2012 - 11:56 .
#38281
Posté 25 mai 2012 - 11:56
#38282
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:01
Modifié par MrStoob, 26 mai 2012 - 12:02 .
#38283
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:02
Personally I think she would either destroyed the network in its entirety (not kill the agents but reassign, etc) or that she would stay the Shadow Broker but in a wastly diminissed role, likely cutting the network drastically down the size.
#38284
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:04
MrStoob wrote...
Unfortunately, the Shadow Broker has become the worst kept secret in the galaxy. It's served its purpose now, probably best just to give it up and concentrate on the life that they have now assured.
This really isn't true. The only people that know Liara is the Shadow Broker, are people close to her and Shepard. Even Barla Von had no idea.
#38285
Guest_frudi_*
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:10
Guest_frudi_*
Sure, she'd be tempted, conflicted... but I can't see her choosing the SB gig over Shepard, which I think is what it would ultimately come down to.
It's certainly a good idea for a fanfic
Modifié par frudi, 26 mai 2012 - 12:11 .
#38286
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:13
Also, assuming there’s some kind of civilization left…can you imagine the number of paparazzi stalking THE SHEPARD’s girl? How you gonna shadowbroker in that? :happy:
Modifié par lillitheris, 26 mai 2012 - 12:15 .
#38287
Guest_frudi_*
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:20
Guest_frudi_*
#38288
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:36
I will say this it is one of her better ones, there is still something about Liara's face but it is nowhere near the "unrecognisable" as the last one was. So in general I like it, and think it is actually quite good.fluffywalrus wrote...
New Ma-Rin Liara/FemShep work
I really like this one
#38289
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 12:48
Aristobulus500 wrote...
MrStoob wrote...
Unfortunately, the Shadow Broker has become the worst kept secret in the galaxy. It's served its purpose now, probably best just to give it up and concentrate on the life that they have now assured.
This really isn't true. The only people that know Liara is the Shadow Broker, are people close to her and Shepard. Even Barla Von had no idea.
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
P.S. Seen this article? It's Not My Fault
Modifié par Obsidian Gryphon, 26 mai 2012 - 01:05 .
#38290
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 01:15
Obsidian Gryphon wrote...
Aristobulus500 wrote...
MrStoob wrote...
Unfortunately, the Shadow Broker has become the worst kept secret in the galaxy. It's served its purpose now, probably best just to give it up and concentrate on the life that they have now assured.
This really isn't true. The only people that know Liara is the Shadow Broker, are people close to her and Shepard. Even Barla Von had no idea.
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
P.S. Seen this article? It's Not My Fault
Patrick Weekes has been one of the stronger writers for Bioware, and I was aghast when I learned he wasn't going to have a hand in the ending. I truly, truly hope he wasn't reprimanded for that post, and that he's been brought in(along with the rest of the writers) to help do the EC. It's the only way to make it better.
#38291
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 01:24
Also that new Liara/Shep picture at the top...that artist can seriously do everything well except Liara's face. It's really strange. Liara's face ALWAYS looks awkward and off, and doesn't look like her at all.
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
#38292
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 01:39
Aristobulus500 wrote...
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
I wouldn’t trust anyone with that info, to be honest. It’s the kind of info that trustworthiness doesn’t even come to play…one more person in the know means ten more avenues of getting some crucial info even without talking to Hackett himself.
#38293
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 01:58
If we say it was an option would you have Liara keep that information from Shepard as well?lillitheris wrote...
Aristobulus500 wrote...
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
I wouldn’t trust anyone with that info, to be honest. It’s the kind of info that trustworthiness doesn’t even come to play…one more person in the know means ten more avenues of getting some crucial info even without talking to Hackett himself.
#38294
Guest_frudi_*
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 02:19
Guest_frudi_*
I agree, with how SB was portrayed through ME1 and ME2, keeping his identity secret was crucial to ensure his own safety. But at least he also had the benefit of being hidden on that ship above Hagalaz; for Liara, following Shepard all over the galaxy, keeping her SB identity a secret would be of even far greater importance. SB would have a huge number of very dangerous enemies (just look at how the old SB pissed of Liara and what it got him) and every single person that knows her identity would increase the chances of it being revealed, the odds probably increasing even faster than exponentially. It's not even really a matter of trust, information can be and is revealed in any number of accidental ways. On the other hand it is a matter of protecting even those who would know - if someone even suspected Liara might be the SB, her friends would be an obvious target for surveillance, abduction, torture and goddess knows what else.lillitheris wrote...
Aristobulus500 wrote...
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
I wouldn’t trust anyone with that info, to be honest. It’s the kind of info that trustworthiness doesn’t even come to play…one more person in the know means ten more avenues of getting some crucial info even without talking to Hackett himself.
So realistically, I think that's the kind of information that should have been on a strictly need to know basis. And as far as I'm concerned, no-one besides Shepard, Feron and whoever you brought with you in LotSB, needed to know. Not even Hackett - Liara could easily have come up with some cover story to gain access to the Mars archive.
Instead, all the current and even most of the former squad mates know, Cerberus knows, Hackett knows and I'm probably still forgetting others who know. So yeah, I think it can't be denied she's done a poor job hiding her identity. Not her fault, blame the writers <_<
But honestly, I can easily overlook this, especially since it does result in some interesting dialogues in the game. I can even pretend it's one of the reasons Liara quits the job after the war
If player didn't complete LotSB, I think that would actually be a great idea. I suppose Shepard would eventually find out somewhere along the way, would make for a great confrontation between them. It could even be dependant on their romance - she might trust a loyal Shepard and reveal her identity to her immediately (in private of course), but would not trust a cheating or non-romanced Shepard.Akernis wrote...
If we say it was an option would you have Liara keep that information from Shepard as well?
Another missed opportunity I guess...
Modifié par frudi, 26 mai 2012 - 02:23 .
#38295
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 02:25
Aristobulus500 wrote...
Hudson and Casey seriously need to be fired and Weekes needs to take their positions. They aren't even good enough to empty his trash cans. And Weekes is amazing and completely on board with what fans want to see in the games.
Also that new Liara/Shep picture at the top...that artist can seriously do everything well except Liara's face. It's really strange. Liara's face ALWAYS looks awkward and off, and doesn't look like her at all.Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
Hehe, I think you mean Casey Hudson and Mac Walters.
And I completely agree about Weekes. Which is why I made this a few days ago.
Modifié par Makrys, 26 mai 2012 - 02:26 .
#38296
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 02:35
Akernis wrote...
If we say it was an option would you have Liara keep that information from Shepard as well?lillitheris wrote...
Aristobulus500 wrote...
Admiral Hackett isn't that close to them (other than the fact he seems to have their implicit trust but if anyone would trust him that much, it would be Shepard. And lest it be said that bondmates share memories / feelings so Liara would follow accordingly / trust Shepard's opinion, I don't think it's that cut and dried as that would make her like a "automaton" ) so I'm wondering why she would tell him. I doubt Shepard would. Unless ... her sources gave her that 100% confirmation that Hackett is ironclad trustworthy. But still, it still seems risky.
There's no way Shepard doesn't trust Hackett with that kind of info - and since Shepard trusts him, Liara would too. And besides, she probably has tabs on Hackett too so she could double check and know he's trustworthy.
I wouldn’t trust anyone with that info, to be honest. It’s the kind of info that trustworthiness doesn’t even come to play…one more person in the know means ten more avenues of getting some crucial info even without talking to Hackett himself.
Whether she’d be able to, I’m not certain. Leaving aside the question of melds, which I think would make it impossible, she’d have an awful lot of little white lies to make up, what with the mysterious ship in Hagalaz to start with.
I think she would consider it, certainly. She was already an information broker, so theoretically she could, for example, play it off as having decided to join forces with Feron who had been running a rival network, giving some plausibility to her improved intel gathering?
#38297
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 02:52
Akernis wrote...
I will say this it is one of her better ones, there is still something about Liara's face but it is nowhere near the "unrecognisable" as the last one was. So in general I like it, and think it is actually quite good.fluffywalrus wrote...
*snip*
New Ma-Rin Liara/FemShep work
I really like this one
Pretty sure the big problem is the nose. Looks nothing like Liara's and really makes the character in the picture take on a whole different look. The eyes and mouth are also too small. Definitely does not resemble Liara. Still a good picture though!
Modifié par Makrys, 26 mai 2012 - 02:53 .
#38298
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 03:26
fluffywalrus wrote...
New Ma-Rin Liara/FemShep work
I really like this one
OMG Top
This is very nice, but when I saw Jane, I thought of Kenshin. It is very nice though.
Regarding: The Witcher 2.
I have it played it, but the swearing is off putting. I really think people exaggerate how good it is ( Origins was much better, and didn't require f this & f that.) The gameplay is less mind numbing though, and is not watered down.
Is anyone else annoyed with the surge of Liara/Javi, and also Liara/Fshep/Traynor?
#38299
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 03:27
#38300
Posté 26 mai 2012 - 03:28
And personally, if I were the lead director on the franchise I would have done everything in my power to provide that type of ending and closure. Sure the ending (after the beam) may be 10 to 15 minutes of cutscenes (though it wouldn't have to be, there could be some dialogue in there), but at least it would have sent off the trilogy the way it deserved to be. And frankly I think the fans deserve an ending like that. So if I were lead director, I would have said (given we had enough time) to the team, "Look guys, we've got some extra time, let's craft a lovely epilogue to send Shepard and the crew out with". Boom, craft something like this for every LI, and I don't think anyone would very many people would be complaining about the ending.
Don't tell me, "That would be impossible to do"! I refuse to believe that. If Bioware truly wanted to give us closure and sort a salute to the fans, they would spend the time and money to end the trilogy like that. Cuz it sure as hell deserves it. Shepard deserves it. So why not? I would have done it. Or at least pushed the team as hard as they could to do anything close to it. It would have been so worth it.
*sigh* But I'm not the lead director. And I'm not saying that would be the only ending. It would be one of many. But I don't know why we couldn't have gotten an ending with that kind of depth. It should have happened, and it would have been amazing. A Return of the King style ending. Mass Effect deserves it.
Modifié par Makrys, 26 mai 2012 - 03:42 .





Retour en haut





