208 réponses à ce sujet

[jbblue05]

AlphaDormante wrote...

cers001 wrote...

It's cause Ash is a Christian

I'm not trying to start a flame war here, so hear me out. (I also don't know if you're being serious, so I'm pretending you are.)

"Religious" isn't synonymous with "heterosexual", and I always tick an eyebrow when people give this as a reason why Ash couldn't be a bisexual LI. I have several gay/bisexual friends who are perfectly secure in their religious beliefs.

Hell, if Bioware wants to go that route, they can have Ash struggle with her religion vs. her sexual orientation. I can see why they might not want to, though, given the vast amount of media panties that would twist and then fly off into space.

Anyway, my point is that her being Christian shouldn't have anything to do with her being a bisexual LI.

Agreed .

Ash shouldn't be bi in the first place.
She has respect for strong male figures like her dad, grandfather, and Anderson  and wants the approval of men.  Plus she has three sisters and I'm sure they competed with each other for men..
Ash being bi would come out of left field 

If she's bi it wouldn't  ruin the game, it would just annoy me

[skcih-deraj]

Rnegade Femshep + Ashley= best duo ever!

Or at least I enjoy them. Ash comming out of no where and bi wouldn't bother me a bit (only get a "thats new")

[PMC65]

jbblue05 wrote...

AlphaDormante wrote...

cers001 wrote...

It's cause Ash is a Christian

I'm not trying to start a flame war here, so hear me out. (I also don't know if you're being serious, so I'm pretending you are.)

"Religious" isn't synonymous with "heterosexual", and I always tick an eyebrow when people give this as a reason why Ash couldn't be a bisexual LI. I have several gay/bisexual friends who are perfectly secure in their religious beliefs.

Hell, if Bioware wants to go that route, they can have Ash struggle with her religion vs. her sexual orientation. I can see why they might not want to, though, given the vast amount of media panties that would twist and then fly off into space.

Anyway, my point is that her being Christian shouldn't have anything to do with her being a bisexual LI.

Agreed .

Ash shouldn't be bi in the first place.
She has respect for strong male figures like her dad, grandfather, and Anderson  and wants the approval of men.  Plus she has three sisters and I'm sure they competed with each other for men..
Ash being bi would come out of left field 

If she's bi it wouldn't  ruin the game, it would just annoy me

I'm confused ... what point makes her not able to be gay or bi?

Gay women can be a daddy's girl
Gay women have sisters
Gay women go to church
In fact, there are even gay women who wear dresses, make-up and hate sports

For me, Ash would be a great choice if you are playing the Mass Effect trilogy as one complete story.

Act 1 (ME): Shepard & Ash meet. They develop a respect for each other that moves into friendship. My Shepard has feelings but keeps them in check afraid that she will be rejected. She's gutsy on the field but a coward in love.

Act 2 (ME2): Clash on Horizon. A big part of it is due to feelings that both feel but are unable to express. This leads to absolute breakdown in the dialogue ... stupid, stupid Horizon.

Act 3 (ME3): Ash isn't good with expressing her feelings and neither is my Shepard ... coming out with how they feel would be clumsy and raw.

Bringing someone new would be okay ... but for me I would like the relationship to be part of the overall story. I also like stories where the love is kept hidden and/or not embraced until the end.

That is probably why I love "Pride and Prejudice" by Jane Austen.

[Unata]

A Femshep + Ashley romance is dialogued in ME1 (you can romance her if you use the gender switch in the console) So I can see it being a strong possibility in ME3 since it was there to begin with.

[Seboist]

Ash becoming bi would be a complete ass pull. There's no reason why a bisexual character wouldn't be attracted to both genders of Shepard when they're literally the same person(sans plumbing of course).

[Mecha Tengu]

oh you neckbeards

[Eternal Dust]

jbblue05 wrote...

If she's bi it wouldn't  ruin the game, it would just annoy me

YOU don't want her to be bi because it offends YOUR sensibilities. Don't play the game and hit on her with a FemShep then. Problem solved.

[CroGamer002]

Existance of this thread + Moderator noticing this thread = Lockdown of this thread

[Antivenger]

Mesina2 wrote...

Existance of this thread + Moderator noticing this thread = Lockdown of this thread

Yep. Still, handing in my support before that happens.

My Male!Shep can't resist the charms of Ashley Williams. My Fem!Shep has no choice.

The other romances seem bleak.

[Liliandra Nadiar]

Ash isn't necessarily 'gay or bi', it may just simply be she's attracted just to FemShep. Even without it, ME1 (Paragon route anyways) makes it quite believable that Ash has a great deal of respect and admiration for Shepard. I don't see it as totally 'left field' that she might consider a more physical relationship but only with (Fem)Shep. I see the same thing with DA2's Merrill, if you treat her nice, but non-romantic, it's still pretty obvious she's in love with Lady Hawke.

[Yana Montana]

Hellz yeah!!!!!

[Terminatort800]

I would say it like this: "FemShepard + Ashley + Miranda + Liara + Samara= Victory" ...lol

[Eternal Dust]

FemShep + Ashley = World Domination

[RainyDayLover]

I saved Ashley on Virmire in my canon femshep playthrough  and they both have immense respect for each other (in fact, she was my femshep's "goto" person for missions)...but I don't think my femshep looks at her that way. Though I might consider it if she is romanceable in ME3...

Modifié par RainyDayLover, 15 juin 2011 - 01:41 .

[shinobi602]

That would kind of ruin the character for me, if she was bi from the beginning...then ok. But now it would feel shoehorned in, to me.

I doubt it will happen anyway.

Modifié par shinobi602, 15 juin 2011 - 01:59 .

[darkchaz]

I like this idea ^^

[Agamo45]

Wouldn't make any goddamn sense. Why would she suddenly turn ****** in the third game, when there is no inkling of it in the first two games? Plus she's a Christian.

[SennenScale]

I would love a firey, strong woman for Femshep.

Support!

[Raanz]

shinobi602 wrote...

That would kind of ruin the character for me, if she was bi from the beginning...then ok. But now it would feel shoehorned in, to me.

I have to agree with this.  I don't know if it would ruin it for me....but it would be a disappointment.

Modifié par Raanz, 15 juin 2011 - 03:35 .

[shepskisaac]

Raanz wrote...

shinobi602 wrote...

That would kind of ruin the character for me, if she was bi from the beginning...then ok. But now it would feel shoehorned in, to me.

I have to agree with this.  I don't know if it would ruin it for me....but it would be a disappointment.

As your sig says, support ALL the ladies of ME, including the closeted bisexual ones too

Modifié par IsaacShep, 15 juin 2011 - 03:43 .

[ADLegend21]

Liliandra Nadiar wrote...

Ash isn't necessarily 'gay or bi', it may just simply be she's attracted just to FemShep. Even without it, ME1 (Paragon route anyways) makes it quite believable that Ash has a great deal of respect and admiration for Shepard. I don't see it as totally 'left field' that she might consider a more physical relationship but only with (Fem)Shep. I see the same thing with DA2's Merrill, if you treat her nice, but non-romantic, it's still pretty obvious she's in love with Lady Hawke.

This. I'm fine with femshep being the only girl Ash wants to be with. That how I have it in my game, other than Shepard he likes guy, it's like experimenting in college I guess.

[Maugrim]

ADLegend21 wrote...

Liliandra Nadiar wrote...

Ash isn't necessarily 'gay or bi', it may just simply be she's attracted just to FemShep. Even without it, ME1 (Paragon route anyways) makes it quite believable that Ash has a great deal of respect and admiration for Shepard. I don't see it as totally 'left field' that she might consider a more physical relationship but only with (Fem)Shep. I see the same thing with DA2's Merrill, if you treat her nice, but non-romantic, it's still pretty obvious she's in love with Lady Hawke.

This. I'm fine with femshep being the only girl Ash wants to be with. That how I have it in my game, other than Shepard he likes guy, it's like experimenting in college I guess.

You might even say that If It's You It's Ok

I definately think Ash could and should be a case of this.

*evil laugh for all the people who will click on the link and waste the rest of their day. *

Modifié par makenzieshepard, 15 juin 2011 - 04:02 .

[jbblue05]

octoberfire wrote...

jbblue05 wrote...

If she's bi it wouldn't  ruin the game, it would just annoy me

YOU don't want her to be bi because it offends YOUR sensibilities. Don't play the game and hit on her with a FemShep then. Problem solved.

Not really I'm an Ash fan, not just because she's romanceable, Ash all of a sudden being bi seems forced and doesn't give the Ash I knew in ME1 justice.

[JeffZero]

I can get with this.

[Eternal Dust]

jbblue05 wrote...

octoberfire wrote...

jbblue05 wrote...

If she's bi it wouldn't  ruin the game, it would just annoy me

YOU don't want her to be bi because it offends YOUR sensibilities. Don't play the game and hit on her with a FemShep then. Problem solved.

Not really I'm an Ash fan, not just because she's romanceable, Ash all of a sudden being bi seems forced and doesn't give the Ash I knew in ME1 justice.

It'll only seem forced if it's written horribly.