Ieldra2 wrote...
@wright:
The problem is that I could accept her resignation as in-character if it was based on "I know too much about TIM and what he'd do with it. That's going to be more risk than benefit to humanity." But it isn't. If you consider her betrayal line, It is a moral judgment made in a moral domain that isn't even based on actual harm but on notions of the sacred, against a strategic reasoning that suggests that unless new facts materialize, it would be highly useful to keep the base. That's so totally not Miranda that I can't see any defense of it as valid.
(At least you can get her resignation without the "betrayal" line. That's at least bearable. The downside is now that you've got *no* explanation for her radical change of allegiance)
Yeah i agree betrayal line is silly. It is part of the wider problem that Shepherd isn't allowed to choose his own reason for destroying base. I would love there to be i don't trust TIM with the base option. However without that i just have to use my own head canon at this point and therefore getting Miranda's resignation line without the betrayal is a major boon to me.





Retour en haut








