fongiel24 wrote...
But why go to all that trouble when you can just... change your name? You wouldn't need countermeasures against information brokers, space stations in the middle of nowhere, or reconstructive surgery if you don't even show up on the enemy's radar in the first place. Hiding your true identity from the enemy gives you an advantage and it's basically free. There's no reason not to do it even if you feel you think you're powerful and resourceful enough that no one can make you pay for not taking that precaution. Why is TIM only known by a moniker? Because keeping his identity and past a secret makes him harder to decipher and gives him a psychological edge.
As for Cerberus being able to afford the loss of one individual, I'm not sure that's the case. Highly capable individuals with a natural talent for the intelligence business are rare. Individuals like that who are both human and willing to work for an organization like Cerberus are even more rare. Miranda isn't irreplacable but it wouldn't be easy to find someone to just step right into her shoes immediately. Furthermore, what if instead of being killed she's captured? Based on what we learned in ME3 from the Codex and Liara's intelligence terminal, Cerberus is paranoid about any information leaks. Their agents are fitted with ocular flashbang implants and all their gear self-destructs as soon as the operative using it is terminated. Why would an organization that's willing to go to such lengths to protect is secrecy not take the simple step of having Miranda change her name?
I wouldn't say Miranda's father is that strong of an argument. Despite his wealth and supposed influence he still has to hire a bunch of two-bit Eclipse mercenaries to recover Oriana. What this tells me is that he doesn't have people working for him capable of conducting such an operation and he doesn't have the influence to "borrow" someone like Kai Leng who could do it with more finesse and sublety. More importantly for his debate, there's no evidence that Miranda's father is even trying to reclaim her. In ME2 Miranda's father doesn't want to tangle with Cerberus and in ME3 it's Miranda who's chasing him.
You really think a name is the only way to track someone? TIM has eluded everyone all these years not just because some call him TIM (hah reference!) but because he almost never leaves his station and very few people even know what he looks like. That's actually a plot point in Retribution. And again we're talking about one person among billions in a huge ass galaxy. I would go so far as to say it's
impossible to track one being by name alone. Any information broker, or enemy intelligence officer would also look at appearance, associates, patterns, known haunts (I'm thinking of the Shield from the Avengers now- if there's a satelite or camera, we can see it). So many different and more reliable ways of tracking Miranda regardless of what she calls herself. That being said I do believe all that hiding on a space station stuff is standard proceedure for all high ranking operatives anyway, given the threat of other agencies like the Shadow Broker being on their tail.
As an operative Miranda runs the same risk of capture/being killed as any other and this risk is not diminshed one iota by a name change. If she is captured are you assuming she'd buckle under torture? Because in that case she'd reveal her real name anyway.
I don't see Lawson hiring Eclipse mercs as a weakness. First off he's a businessman not a warlord so I don't think he keeps much of a standing private army. Second while we as the godlike Shepard mow down Eclipse left and right, they are supposed to be one of the most feared gangs in the galaxy and not simply two bit alley pukes. And third I don't think Miranda was supposed to find out. I believe Lawson was going for subtlety here hiring a local merc band whose movements wouldn't raise too many eyebrows. They were only there in case there were problems anyway. If Miranda hadn't interfered Niket would've probably just sweetalked Oriana on a cab back to daddy. And it's not that Lawson
doesn't want to tangle with Cerberus, there is no evidence for that. Instead we are simply told he withdrew his support. And of course he'd still want Miranda if he could get her. He still got further with her than with all his other "children". Even Oriana would be harder to "retrain" since she grew up away from his influence. If he got Miranda back I imagine he'd be hard at work reconditioning her for his original purposes. Whether he'd succeed or not wouldn't cross his mind and is another debate altogether.