82210 réponses à ce sujet

[Melra]

It's not Miranda without Yvonne Strahovski, it's as simple as that. No way around it.

[hot_heart]

Rannoch could be nice. Especially if you can avoid Tali.

[Cmdr. Ken Shepard]

MisterJB wrote...

Cmdr. Ken Shepard wrote...
 If I end up living through this second phase of death I should speak to her about building a house on Rannoch and retiring.

Are you sure you're in the right thread?

Yeah, I only like the Quarian homeworld. Not much for Tali (too whiny). I figure a pleasant retirement off the grid with Miranda would be nice.

[Cmdr. Ken Shepard]

Melrache wrote...

It's not Miranda without Yvonne Strahovski, it's as simple as that. No way around it.

Without Yvonne, Miranda wouldn't be the same at all. I'd probably be into Liara instead.

[Caihn]

hot_heart wrote...

Rannoch could be nice. Especially if you can avoid Tali.

Well .. there were only Geths on Rannoch in my playthrough. And I chose the Destroy ending .. so I guess it's a deserted planet now.

[Stalker]

Yannkee wrote...

hot_heart wrote...

Rannoch could be nice. Especially if you can avoid Tali.

Well .. there were only Geths on Rannoch in my playthrough. And I chose the Destroy ending .. so I guess it's a deserted planet now.

I thought the Geth aren't dying...? 
I was interpreting Destroy to be the option that destroys the Reaper-Code, that code that made synthetics aware/alive.

Well, it's hard to say with a living Shepard and Miranda to get a view on what's BioWare's definition of "synthetic"...

Modifié par Mr Massakka, 01 juillet 2012 - 12:05 .

[enayasoul]

MisterJB wrote...

I disagree. Miranda was badly done in ME3 but it was better than not having her in the game at all.
And a change in VA would be much easier for me to accept than changes like the lack of idealism.

Disagree!  No, she wasn't!!!  She just wasn't *your* idea of who you wanted her to be.  I had no problem with the way she was illustrated in the game.  Yes, there could be more content for her and more of her doing bad ass stuff on screen but she wasn't badly done in ME3. Are you sure you're in the right thread? Again, changing Vo would NOT help anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

Modifié par enayasoul, 01 juillet 2012 - 12:08 .

[Melra]

enayasoul wrote...

MisterJB wrote...

I disagree. Miranda was badly done in ME3 but it was better than not having her in the game at all.
And a change in VA would be much easier for me to accept than changes like the lack of idealism.

Disagree!  No, she wasn't!!!  She just wasn't *your* idea of who you wanted her to be.  I had no problem with the way she was illustrated in the game.  Yes, there could be more content for her and more of her doing bad ass stuff on screen but she wasn't badly done in ME3. Are you sure you're in the right thread? Again, changing  Vo would NOT  help or change anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

This so much.

[o Ventus]

Melrache wrote...

It's not Miranda without Yvonne Strahovski, it's as simple as that. No way around it.

This.

What next, replacing Hale and Meer for Shepard?

It just wouldn't be the same.

Modifié par o Ventus, 01 juillet 2012 - 12:11 .

[LanceSolous13]

^This. As much as I laugh sometimes about Meer's VA Performance, It wouldn't be the same.

Yannkee wrote...

hot_heart wrote...

Rannoch could be nice. Especially if you can avoid Tali.

Well .. there were only Geths on Rannoch in my playthrough. And I chose the Destroy ending .. so I guess it's a deserted planet now.

"Beach front property. Its a buyer's market." lol

[MisterJB]

enayasoul wrote...
Disagree!  No, she wasn't!!!  She just wasn't *your* idea of who you wanted her to be.  I had no problem with the way she was illustrated in the game.  Yes, there could be more content for her and more of her doing bad ass stuff on screen but she wasn't badly done in ME3.

Terribly done, really. It was a catastrophe of unimaginable proportions.
Rather than saying my idea of who I wanted her to be, you should see who Miranda was in ME2 and who she is ME3.
She was brilliant, idealistic, ambitious, conflicted. She worked to justify her existence, to help others and simply because she enjoyed it. She was morally ambiguous and capable of understanding when hard decisions had to be made. She had existencial issues due to her birth and upbringing.
None of these characteristics are present in ME3. Her love for ehr sister is the sole motivation behind all of her actions; not the fact Cerberus betrayed everything they used to stand for; and this is boring and an insult to the marvelous characterization of ME2.

 

Are you sure you're in the right thread?

Because you're not a true Miranda fan unless you are satisfied by whatever crap Bioware decides to throw your way and worship the ground beneath Yvonne Strahovsky?
 

Again, changing Vo would NOT help anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

And there is a much greater chance of her being  substantially featured in a future DLC substantially if they replace her VA.

Modifié par MisterJB, 01 juillet 2012 - 12:25 .

[MisterJB]

o Ventus wrote...
It just wouldn't be the same.

For the first five minutes.

[Melra]

It has nothing to do with worshipping Yvonne Strahovski, even saying something like that takes value from anything you say from now on. She was picked as the VA for Miranda at the beginning ,changing the VA would change the whole character. Mordin isn't the Mordin of ME2, he was different, he was somewhat tolerable, but nowhere near the awesumness he was in ME3.

They'd even have to possibly change Miranda's looks if they didn't use Yvonne as a VA, so that would even bigger change.

Just no, no, no, no and again no!

[o Ventus]

MisterJB wrote...

o Ventus wrote...
It just wouldn't be the same.

For the first five minutes.

So do you make it a habit of disagreeing with the popular opinion on everything, or do you find pleasure in trolling people?

[Stalker]

MisterJB wrote...

Again, changing Vo would NOT help anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

And there is a much greater chance of her being substantially featured in a future DLC substantially if they replace her VA.

... Who ever said that her VA is a problem at any development? It isn't.
Why should it be a problem to bring a B-actress to voice-work, while they managed to get many other, far more successful people in the business?
It has already been proven that even acting jobs do not interfere with voice-work...

Yvonne Strahovski does not stand in the way for Miranda DLC.

[MisterJB]

o Ventus wrote...
So do you make it a habit of disagreeing with the popular opinion on everything, or do you find pleasure in trolling people?

No, it's something much more exceptional.
I have an opinion that differ from yours.
Shocking, I know.

[Cmdr. Ken Shepard]

Mr Massakka wrote...

MisterJB wrote...

Again, changing Vo would NOT help anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

And there is a much greater chance of her being substantially featured in a future DLC substantially if they replace her VA.

... Who ever said that her VA is a problem at any development? It isn't.
Why should it be a problem to bring a B-actress to voice-work, while they managed to get many other, far more successful people in the business?
It has already been proven that even acting jobs do not interfere with voice-work...

Yvonne Strahovski does not stand in the way for Miranda DLC.

Is there even actual proof she (or her agent) have stated or made it clear she has no interest in doing more as Miranda? Without proof it is all heresay. She doesn't seem like the type to spit on her fans, especially since many of her chuck fans came from Mass Effect, and vice versa. Its mutually beneficial for her.

[MisterJB]

Melrache wrote...

It has nothing to do with worshipping Yvonne Strahovski, even saying something like that takes value from anything you say from now on. She was picked as the VA for Miranda at the beginning ,changing the VA would change the whole character. Mordin isn't the Mordin of ME2, he was different, he was somewhat tolerable, but nowhere near the awesumness he was in ME3.

They'd even have to possibly change Miranda's looks if they didn't use Yvonne as a VA, so that would even bigger change.

Just no, no, no, no and again no!

Mordin's role was awesome and touching in ME3. His new voice actor detracted nothing from it and if that is what it would take to have Miranda featured heavily in a Cerberus DLC, it is a price I would gladly pay.

But, like you said, chances are it won't happen because of Miranda's model.

[o Ventus]

Cmdr. Ken Shepard wrote...

Mr Massakka wrote...

MisterJB wrote...

Again, changing Vo would NOT help anything! I'm keeping what we have... Things can be added to her role and contributions in future dlc's..

And there is a much greater chance of her being substantially featured in a future DLC substantially if they replace her VA.

... Who ever said that her VA is a problem at any development? It isn't.
Why should it be a problem to bring a B-actress to voice-work, while they managed to get many other, far more successful people in the business?
It has already been proven that even acting jobs do not interfere with voice-work...

Yvonne Strahovski does not stand in the way for Miranda DLC.

Is there even actual proof she (or her agent) have stated or made it clear she has no interest in doing more as Miranda? Without proof it is all heresay. She doesn't seem like the type to spit on her fans, especially since many of her chuck fans came from Mass Effect, and vice versa. Its mutually beneficial for her.

No, there isn't.

Not even remotely.

[o Ventus]

MisterJB wrote...

o Ventus wrote...
So do you make it a habit of disagreeing with the popular opinion on everything, or do you find pleasure in trolling people?

No, it's something much more exceptional.
I have an opinion that differ from yours.
Shocking, I know.

Saying that there would be a higher chance for Miranda DLC if Yvonne was replaced is not an opinion.

But, y'know, minor details like that aren't important.

[MisterJB]

Mr Massakka wrote...
Who ever said that her VA is a problem at any development? It isn't.
Why should it be a problem to bring a B-actress to voice-work, while they managed to get many other, far more successful people in the business?
It has already been proven that even acting jobs do not interfere with voice-work...

Yvonne Strahovski does not stand in the way for Miranda DLC.

Getting Yvonne Strahovsky is harder and more expensive than simply using a regular VA at Bioware that appear in most of their games.
Ultimately, it's a collection of factors such as these that will determine wheter or not Miranda will be featured in DLC. Arranging for a new VA for Miranda would, undoubtedly, help the case for her return.

[MisterJB]

o Ventus wrote...
Saying that there would be a higher chance for Miranda DLC if Yvonne was replaced is not an opinion.
But, y'know, minor details like that aren't important.

True, that's actually a fact.

[Melra]

MisterJB wrote...

Mr Massakka wrote...
Who ever said that her VA is a problem at any development? It isn't.
Why should it be a problem to bring a B-actress to voice-work, while they managed to get many other, far more successful people in the business?
It has already been proven that even acting jobs do not interfere with voice-work...

Yvonne Strahovski does not stand in the way for Miranda DLC.

Getting Yvonne Strahovsky is harder and more expensive than simply using a regular VA at Bioware that appear in most of their games.
Ultimately, it's a collection of factors such as these that will determine wheter or not Miranda will be featured in DLC. Arranging for a new VA for Miranda would, undoubtedly, help the case for her return.

No it wouldn't since it wouldn't be Miranda for most of her fans. I am quite sure of this. Why bring back a character, if it wasn't even the character that people were looking forward to seeing again? Pure stupidity.

[o Ventus]

MisterJB wrote...

o Ventus wrote...
Saying that there would be a higher chance for Miranda DLC if Yvonne was replaced is not an opinion.
But, y'know, minor details like that aren't important.

True, that's actually a fact.

Give me evidence of this "fact".

And by "evidence", I mean articles or other pieces of information coming from Yvonne herself or Bioware affirming your point, not just a statement that bother making.

[MisterJB]

Melrache wrote...
No it wouldn't since it wouldn't be Miranda for most of her fans. I am quite sure of this. Why bring back a character, if it wasn't even the character that people were looking forward to seeing again? Pure stupidity.

That is the way some of us feel about ME3.
Her voice doesn't make or break her character for me, her words do.