fiendishchicken wrote...
You missed mentioning the option of rogue cells. Teltin Facility was rogue, and they were actively hiding it from TIM. It's stated by researchers in the facility that TIM is in the dark about what they are really doing. And these are his own employee's. If you trust them enough to do ethically and morally questionable research for you, you tend to have a little faith that they're doing the right thing. Of course, Teltin wasn't, and TIM eventually learned about what was really going on there. He ordered the remains of the facility shut down, and its remaining staff to be forcibly "retired". I'm sure this was a case where he resolved to keep a closer eye on his projects, seeing as to what could happen if he didn't keep his eye on cells.
And no one in the alliance ever heard about Teltin. At least, not until years after the projects demise.
If you're going to be running an extremist covert op group, allowing "rogue cells" is simply not an option. To adapt the Citadel Gunnery Chief's speech: If you start perforing brutal experiments to gain admittedly useful information, you are ruining someone else's day, somewhere, sometime. That is why you maintain checks and balances at all times, that is why you monitor every aspect and every stage of the operation, that is why you do not simply "trust" or "have faith" that everything will be hunky-dory.
The bottom line is TIM didn't find the type of researchers willing to be that brutal at the local Y or the Good Shepard. If you hire monsters or those with monstrous tendencies and do not guard against said tendencies getting out of hand, you are either a monster yourself, or a moron. Pick one.
As for Akuze going public, the only person who knew it was really Cerberus was Corporal Toombs. I don't know about you, but my Shepard is a Sole Survivor, having lost his entire unit at Akuze. He, and everyone else, had no idea that Cerberus was behind the whole incident. Toombs, who was captured and experimented on by them, was the only person who knew about what was going on.That became public because Toombs escaped and started a killing spree on scientists involved with the project. When Shepard found him, Toombs had the last scientist in his gunsights. When Shepard learned about what was going on, he convinced Toombs to go public with his knowledge. The scientist, Dr. Wayne testified for his own immunity, that he did work for an organization known as Cerberus.
Ignoring again the questionable risk vs reward of the whole operation (I'd very much love to know exactly what Cerberus got out of watching people get torn new ****s by thresher maws), where was the response team to deal with Toombs? If it was so well kept under wraps why was one disgruntled marine allowed to cause so much damage, both in PR and in loss of personnel (amoral scientists don't just grow on trees you know)?
In ME2 Shepard gets spammed with all sorts of inane requests from Cerberus. "Hey, if you're not busy taking on the entire Collector race with your ONE ship, you know, while our army just sits this one out (and don't try and tell me ALL of Cerberus' war machine in ME3 didn't exist before the war), why don't you go and find out what happend to this random operative who ran into a gang?" Or how about: "Shepard! Our prototype hovercraft crashed, can you get our ride back? kthnx."
They've got cleaners to take out an Alliance Admiral but they can't make one crazy marine disappear? Again, incompetent at best.
As for the Hades Dogs scenario, Admiral Kohoku had knowledge of the name Cerberus, but little else other than they were a "covert alliance black ops and research group that had gone rogue". Yes, people know they exist, but it's like the DEVGRU, or the 1st SFOD-D, or any other JSOC unit today. No one knows what they're doing really.
Kahoku, an alliance Admiral, had to get information from the Shadow Broker about Cerberus. The SB provided a source for locations, but requested that any data recovered be handed over to the Shadow Broker. Even the SB didn't have much information on them in the first game.
Organizations don't get called "terrorists" on a whim. You can call it Citadel/Alliance propaganda all you want but the point is, if Cerberus is visible enough for the authorities to make that claim, it's already failed.
I'm saying in essence that a lot of the screw-ups aren't TIM's fault really. And everyone is going to screw up at some point, sometimes repeatedly. As of ME3 he needed to be replaced, but that was because his beliefs concerning the Reapers have become irreconcilable with the reality of them, due to indoctrination.
They
are TIMs fault. I recognize the necessity of some of Cerberus' actions. But the fact that some of their operations go too far and/or go public is a direct result of his failing. Because he's in charge, he set all this up, he thought up how it was going to work. If someone under his commander ****ed up, that's on him as well, for failing to prevent the ****up or to deal with it appropriately. It's all on him. And while I don't expect him or anyone else to be infallible, he started making
too many mistakes. That's been my point all along.
And I will get "self-righteous" with him backing Shepard and fighting the Reapers. In an entire galaxy with dozens of species and massive militaries and everything, TIM is the only one to acknowledge and work against the Reapers besides Shepard.
The alliance disowns him (while using his image to promote recruiting), the council labels him a traitor and an unstable nutjob, and many others don't do anything at all. I never said TIM or Aria deserved a medal, but they understand what the real threat is, and that something must be done to stop it. They all have their own motivations: TIM wants to preserve, and if possible, ascend humanity. Aria wants to keep Omega and her organization as a Pirate and Gang leader intact. Shepard, by the end of ME3 for me, just wants to keep Miranda safe and live to see her again.
That's no credit to TIM, but merely a black mark for everyone else. Like I said, apart from a few individuals, everyone else is infected with Stupid. Nearly fatally so. At least as far as the Reapers go.
But now turn your attention back to Shepard. Why does the Council (and parts of the Alliance) call him a traitor, why does the VS keep ****ing about it? Because he joined Cerberus. Cerberus who as far as they`re concerned is the SS and Al Queda rolled in one. And why, pray tell is that? Because of Cerberus' utter inability to stop being the Highly Visible Secret Agency of Baby Killers. Thus you add more to TIM's failure. Not only does he not have as much control over the jerkasses who work for him as he should, but he also can't keep away from the public eye
and to top it all of, the stuff that does make it to the public is all the crap.
He fails at being an effective administrator, he fails at the "covert" part of "covert ops" and now, he's failing at PR.
If Cerberus is so damn beneficial why is the only person who sees it already dismissed as an "unstable nutjob"? ME2 is supposed to be all "oh, look at the
good side of Cerberus"- well ****, don't just show me, I'm supposed to be dead! Show the rest of the galaxy. Or at least the Alliance. Because as stupid as you may believe them to be having them on your side at least provides a distraction.
We say Cerberus should be "humanity's STG" right? Well I guarantee you, if Mordin was the hero here and he got the STG to back him up, he wouldn't get a tenth of the flack Shepard gets with Cerberus. Why? Is it because the STG is so much more clean and friendly and never does anything bad? **** no. They just about sterilized an entire goddamn race. But see, they don't come across as mad scientists with serial-killer levels of bodycounts. They just have better management.
And yes, I agree with the Empire reference btw. Palpatine knew what was coming and knew that it had to be stopped, but that wasn't his only motivation. Don't make it sound like it was. He was the biggest megalomaniac in the history of the SW galaxy, minus maybe the Sith Emperor.
And you think TIM's motivation was only "stopping the Reapers"? Please. TIM may not be the monster Palpatine is but don't kid yourself. The pattern is there.
And TIM *was* right about control. He wasn't shooting in the dark. He had evidence to back his theory up. He had Miranda's father running his experiments on Sanctuary. He had research done to figure out how indoctrination worked. That information was gained from the husk experiments. He had a method to control them. Granted, it was on a shorter scale than the actual Reapers, but he had the information on a baseline method to control them that actually worked.
Then their was the Leviathans. Doubtless, TIM learned about them, even though nothing was done on Cerberus' part about them. I'm willing to bet he had information on their nature, through his sources in the alliance, the Reapers, or his own.
So TIM did have knowledge that the Reapers could be controlled. It wasn't a total stab in the dark. As for the Crucible, I will say it was a bit of an educated guess, but he was right in the end. Even if he couldn't control the Reapers himself, the Reapers could be controlled by the Crucible.
Ah but now you're shooting in the dark. First off, TIM had leanings of control as early as ME2 with the Collector base. That may seem like just seizing enemy tech but when the enemy's a race of machines, that distinction gets quite a bit blurry.
Second of all Sanctuary in no way proves Reapers can be controlled. That's like saying you manage to lure an attack dog away from mauling you with a steak and throwing that steak at someone else makes it attack them, and from this you conclude you can make its master your puppet with steak. Please. Don't be too proud of that concentration camp he was running. The ability to have an army of husks is insignificant next to the power of the Reapers.
Bottom line is control is impossible without the Crucible and there is no evidence that even that is a possibility until the holokid flat out tells you. If I believe I can fly and I launch myself off the roof in a shopping cart and later someone gives me a plane, I was not "right" that I could fly. Events merely coincided.
Modifié par CrutchCricket, 25 septembre 2012 - 07:26 .