AndreasShepard wrote...
Just a question to fellow Kaidanites, would you be ok with the ending if Kaidan had gone up the beam with Shepard and they had both confronted the catalyst together? Obviously resulting in them both being sacrificed for the greater good but at least they would have each other at the end. Not sure if this discussion has been had before since I'm still relatively new to this thread but it's something I've been thinking about the past couple of days.
I don't believe it would have really been all that much better (better, yes, but not by much).
If Kaidan had followed you up but you were able to send him back before the explosion, or if he didn't come up but you had some other way to ensure that he was spared, or if he followed you up and saved you and you both lived, then I think it would have been quite a bit better (obviously, that last one would have been perfect).
I think the real issue is that Kaidan would still be fighting, even if he didn't make it to the beam. He would not abandon the fight, Earth, or you (none of them would have). There was just no reason for them to be flying away and to crash for no reason on some remote jungle planet, never to be seen or heard from again. Kaidan should have been on Earth, and when the smoke cleared, he should have been able to mourn Shepard's death and help out in the immediate aftermath of the war. (If Shepard survived, of course, then they needed to be reunited, to face the future together.)
AndreasShepard wrote...
I just finished again too! It's been weeks since I played it but for some reason I just got the urge to finish one of my newer playthroughs tonight. Man it is still depressing, had to watch the romance scene with Kaidan afterwards just to try and feel a little better.
I did this when the patch came out.
For some reason, I was playing from a save near the end, and I decided to just go through it again. I felt just as bad as I had the first time I witnessed it.
I laugh when reading that they wanted the ending to ME3 to be something you'd never forget, because I truly will never forget how bad the ending made me feel. There is not a single form of entertainment I've ever experienced that has ever made me feel like this. I really can't explain it, and I won't ever forget it.