Aller au contenu

Photo

Major Kaidan Alenko in ME3: We're going to need a bigger boot.


67443 réponses à ce sujet

#65076
laikabaws

laikabaws
  • Members
  • 1 393 messages
Image IPB

#65077
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

AshTheBrave wrote...

Lol Doodle!

I chose for destruction and was justified by my romance.


Honestly, that BW confession puzzles me cause as a player i just choose whatever i want to choose and i can't see how it is a problem for anybody Image IPB

On my very first PT, I knew that Anderson's path was probably my Shep's.
Before making that choice, i spoiled myself cause i knew vaguely about the breathing part.
It just confirmed my choice. Actually i didn't get the breath anyway Image IPB
I remember people here calling that an epic fail > choosing because of Kaidan but ending up dead anyway. 

#65078
Kunari801

Kunari801
  • Members
  • 3 581 messages
Mimi, I think the "epic fail" people were referring to was on BW's part, not the players. Maybe that is me projecting, even with the EC, "epic fail" is still my feeling.

#65079
Guest_S.T.A.P_*

Guest_S.T.A.P_*
  • Guests
Same for me, this confession has just nothing to do here. I admitt, I chosed Destroy so I would maybe survive and stay with Kaidan - it might had been different without those two heartbreaking scenes (the HQ conversation, then the evac scene). Afterward, I tought about it with my brain - and nothing has changed. Destroy remains the best option for me.

#65080
devSin

devSin
  • Members
  • 8 929 messages

Nrieh wrote...

Not same?? You mean "coup trust" counts separately from "affection"?? Wow, that means extra variables...And Coding God forbids to make extra variables unless really necessary! 8P

I'm charmed by BW logic. Throw out and cut off all sorts of things for sake of simplifying and resource economy, but write multilayered logic for killing (or keeping alive) Kaidan Alenko...

It's not that huge a difference, I don't think (also, the variables lists seem to be huge arrays of different data types, so they're probably free to use as many as they need). One is probably a measure of affection, while the second is more a measure of trust.

I'm assuming the first one is influenced more by buying him gifts and being nice to and supporting him, while the second is more limited (did you import a romance, were you faithful if you did, did you fight him on Mars, did you manage to save the salarian councilor, etc.).

Mimitochan wrote...

The fact that there is a specific event or set of events that determines a boolean value (i.e. referred to as TrueLove here by Laika). Of course, it's easier said than done, but why would the fact that you're actually romancing one character would cause other characters to behave differently towards your Shep?

They simply did not have time.

We can all say how it would have been wonderful to have more nuanced relationships, but the fact is that they were intending to make the game in under two years (and they failed, even with all the time-saving decisions).

Mimitochan wrote...

As you said, the Coup logic seems to be a lot more sophisticated, I just wished the romance logic had been as elaborate.

I wouldn't necessarily say this is true. It's simply that the conversation is far more complex. It has to track all the possibilities for that scene, handle both Ashley and Kaidan, and has a bunch of options for varying levels of trust.

The logic for the relationships doesn't need overly-complex conversations—you either meet the requirement or you don't. (Plus, it plays out over several conversations, some of which don't require a romance but which do increase his affection for you—the coup is a one-time deal.)

#65081
laikabaws

laikabaws
  • Members
  • 1 393 messages
lol...Kaidan you're as oblivious as Shep sometimes :'D
Image IPB
by Theartisticbutts

#65082
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

Kunari801 wrote...

Mimi, I think the "epic fail" people were referring to was on BW's part, not the players. Maybe that is me projecting, even with the EC, "epic fail" is still my feeling.


Oh, forgot to mention, when i said "here", it was on the BSN, not from this thread. Somebody answered this to my post at that time  >




So you murdered the Geth in an attempt to save yourself (ostensibly to make sexy-time with Kaiden) but ended up dying anyway. Fail

I guess some of this is true but I don't really care Image IPB

Modifié par Mimitochan, 14 septembre 2012 - 06:37 .


#65083
Kunari801

Kunari801
  • Members
  • 3 581 messages
 Yeah, take it off Kaidan!  Source

Image IPB 

Modifié par Kunari801, 14 septembre 2012 - 06:37 .


#65084
Doodle

Doodle
  • Members
  • 4 768 messages
TIM drinks these

Image IPB

Image IPB

#65085
laikabaws

laikabaws
  • Members
  • 1 393 messages
...booty
Image IPB
Image IPB
Image IPB

#65086
Beep Il

Beep Il
  • Members
  • 2 595 messages
Lol, laika.
BroShep doing the FemShep dance... Nonononnonoono. :D

#65087
laikabaws

laikabaws
  • Members
  • 1 393 messages
@Beep haha I just noticed that! Well, at least Sheploo gets to dance with Kaidan this way :'D

More Kaidan for every Shep yey
Image IPB
Image IPB

#65088
Doodle

Doodle
  • Members
  • 4 768 messages
Yay, sig finally updated. took it's sweet time >_>

#65089
lindtchoco

lindtchoco
  • Members
  • 634 messages

laikabaws wrote...

@Beep haha I just noticed that! Well, at least Sheploo gets to dance with Kaidan this way :'D

More Kaidan for every Shep yey
Image IPB
Image IPB


Is it me or does FShep dance better..?

#65090
Kunari801

Kunari801
  • Members
  • 3 581 messages

lindtchoco wrote...
Is it me or does FShep dance better..?


No, mShep is a terrible dancer, it's been the butt of many jokes.  

#65091
AshTheBrave

AshTheBrave
  • Members
  • 821 messages
They're both femShep's dancing. That's a modded broShep from ME1.

#65092
lindtchoco

lindtchoco
  • Members
  • 634 messages

Kunari801 wrote...

lindtchoco wrote...
Is it me or does FShep dance better..?


No, mShep is a terrible dancer, it's been the butt of many jokes.  


Ahh i was wondering why they said Shep was a horrible dancer (i have only played FShep so far...)

#65093
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

devSin wrote...

Mimitochan wrote...

The fact that there is a specific event or set of events that determines a boolean value (i.e. referred to as TrueLove here by Laika). Of course, it's easier said than done, but why would the fact that you're actually romancing one character would cause other characters to behave differently towards your Shep?

They simply did not have time.

We can all say how it would have been wonderful to have more nuanced relationships, but the fact is that they were intending to make the game in under two years (and they failed, even with all the time-saving decisions).

Mimitochan wrote...

As you said, the Coup logic seems to be a lot more sophisticated, I just wished the romance logic had been as elaborate.

I wouldn't necessarily say this is true. It's simply that the conversation is far more complex. It has to track all the possibilities for that scene, handle both Ashley and Kaidan, and has a bunch of options for varying levels of trust.

The logic for the relationships doesn't need overly-complex conversations—you either meet the requirement or you don't. (Plus, it plays out over several conversations, some of which don't require a romance but which do increase his affection for you—the coup is a one-time deal.)


Eh, one can never have too high expectations when it comes to romancing Kaidan Image IPB
What really bothers me is the "lock" feature > i would find it more natural and more immersive to just have an overall romance score all the time that would determine if certain options are available or not to the player; such a during the Coup, rather than having some sort of romance "commitment" (boolean = true) that is irreversible > once Kaidan is locked you can be all Renegade you want with him (not that you have that many opportunities to do so). I would have found it more interesting and realistic that the relationship keeps evolving no matter what, and this would not have needed complex programming or intricate trees.

For instance, what i would have really liked would have been LI to have more memories on events or missions he shared with Shep, or more specific romance banter when paired with another squadmate and so on.
This is not really programming but rather budget wise, for writers and voice actors mainly (which are linked on the overall project, of course).

But i wouldn't want this to become a dating sim either. What they did for Leviathan for instance exceeded a lot of my expectations, so it prooves that i's possible without moving too faraway from the usual developing path.

Modifié par Mimitochan, 14 septembre 2012 - 08:04 .


#65094
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages
Image IPB

 ^An example of very elaborate romantic options :P

Modifié par Mimitochan, 14 septembre 2012 - 08:03 .


#65095
Jackie09

Jackie09
  • Members
  • 326 messages
I love the jokes about Shepard's dance moves they always make me smile.

#65096
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages
Image IPB

http://sweetcandyrain.deviantart.com/

Image IPB

#65097
Guest_S.T.A.P_*

Guest_S.T.A.P_*
  • Guests

Mimitochan wrote...

Image IPB

 ^An example of very elaborate romantic options :P

Where did you find that ? So adorably cute :wub:

#65098
Gtacatalina

Gtacatalina
  • Members
  • 402 messages
Image IPB

Image IPBImage IPB

#65099
Mimitochan

Mimitochan
  • Members
  • 2 489 messages

S.T.A.P wrote...
Where did you find that ? So adorably cute Image IPB


Here >  rabbitzoro.deviantart.com/gallery/24882817

#65100
Doodle

Doodle
  • Members
  • 4 768 messages
Image IPB
peudel caq kut yhouha?

*cough*
i mean.

Biotic sex god anyone?