Aller au contenu

Photo

Major Kaidan Alenko in ME3: We're going to need a bigger boot.


67443 réponses à ce sujet

#8126
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

sapphyreelf wrote...

Would it be too much to ask that in our efforts to be respectful of Kaidan fans that we are also respectful that some of us are reading/posting from public and/or work computers, and the nsfw pics and topics inhibit us from being able to participate?

Nobody posts NSFW pics here directly, at worst cropped previews are posted with link to full versions. And if your boss catches you wasting your time on a video game forum, he won't really care if you had shirtless Kaidan or weapon stats pic on.

Modifié par IsaacShep, 20 septembre 2011 - 03:37 .


#8127
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages

IsaacShep wrote...

sapphyreelf wrote...

Would it be too much to ask that in our efforts to be respectful of Kaidan fans that we are also respectful that some of us are reading/posting from public and/or work computers, and the nsfw pics and topics inhibit us from being able to participate?

Nobody posts NSFW pics here directly, at worst cropped previews are posted with link to full versions. And if your boss catches you wasting your time on a video game forum, he won't really care if you had shirtless Kaidan or weapon stats pic on.


Please stop making assumptions about people, their bosses, or their company policies.  OK?

Modifié par Sialater, 20 septembre 2011 - 03:49 .


#8128
sapphyreelf

sapphyreelf
  • Members
  • 2 839 messages
Hmm, well, glad to see such a welcoming reply to what could be a valid for more than just me.

I'll respectfully leave the thread.

#8129
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

sapphyreelf wrote...

Hmm, well, glad to see such a welcoming reply to what could be a valid for more than just me.

Glad to see you started it with your snarky "And here I was hoping that the nsfw work discussions were decreasing".

#8130
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages

IsaacShep wrote...

sapphyreelf wrote...

Hmm, well, glad to see such a welcoming reply to what could be a valid for more than just me.

Glad to see you started it with your snarky "And here I was hoping that the nsfw work discussions were decreasing".


Wait... that was snarky? Considering others have made the same request, how is it snarky?

#8131
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

Sialater wrote...

Wait... that was snarky? Considering others have made the same request, how is it snarky?

Others didn't started with what translated into "ohhhh and just here I was, thinking the gutter's finally gone!".

BTW, are you gonna make a habit of countering every post of mine from now on no matter if I wasn't even responding to you? Because I'm game if you really wanna play.

#8132
syllogi

syllogi
  • Members
  • 7 258 messages

Sialater wrote...

Yeah, OK.  How about the posts that judge everyone with a "cheating" Shepard as a bad Kaidan fan?  How about those who assume it's a fault on the player's part or her morality for playing that way? 

When this can be discussed without judgement on the players, then I'll contribute.  Otherwise, I've defended my "Cheating" Shepard dozens of times over and over and with walls of text and in fic.  But still there exists some judgement on the part of the fans that people like me are fans in name only. 

So, no, until that time comes, I probably won't be contributing more to the "cheating" discussion.  Seeing as every single time I have done so, I personally get flamed for a role-playing decision.


If this is directed to me, I'm really confused, because I thought I was clear in saying that I understand that different people play their games differently.  I just wanted to give a different perspective, since a lot of times it seems like it has to be "cheating" OR "moving on" for everyone, and can't just be defined on a case by case basis for each Shepard.

I was replying to someone who didn't seem interested in continuing the Kaidan romance in ME3.  I'm going to go out on a limb and say that if someone romanced Kaidan in ME1, started a new romance with another character in ME2, and thinks that their character's relationship with Kaidan was over and done with, then they probably did like their ME2 LI better than Kaidan.  I don't see how that's condemning anyone as a "bad" Kaidan fan...there are plenty of people who like Kaidan, but he's not their favorite character in the series.  

I'm also aware of your different playthroughs, and I think it's great, and the way you flesh out each of your characters is the way I like to.  Also as a DA2 Anders fan who had two VERY different outcomes for him with my two "main" Hawkes, and feels unwelcome in the Anders Support Thread most of the time because I'm a Bad Fan, I get it.  

I really don't want you to think I was being snarky towards you, or anyone else who has a ME2 LI playthrough, at all.

IsaacShep wrote...

sapphyreelf wrote...

Would it be too much to ask that in our efforts to be respectful of Kaidan fans that we are also respectful that some of us are reading/posting from public and/or work computers, and the nsfw pics and topics inhibit us from being able to participate?


Nobody posts NSFW pics here directly, at worst cropped previews are posted with link to full versions. And if your boss catches you wasting your time on a video game forum, he won't really care if you had shirtless Kaidan or weapon stats pic on.


Okay...this is a pet peeve of mine.  I'm an adult, working in an environment where my supervisor is fully aware that I use the internet on company time.  I *really* dislike the strawman, when people post NSFW pics, that no one should ever look at the internet while at work.  That's not the point, and most employers in corporate environments would prefer that I was on a video game forum instead of reading a book or knitting, or something else more conspicuous, when the work flow gets light.  In any case, it would just be nice to be more inclusive, and highly suggestive cropped pics are more likely to make people back out of the thread.

#8133
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages
Nah, Teen. I know where you're coming from -- you and I have had this discussion roughly a dozen times by now. (And I, too, have two different outcomes for Anders -- killing him hurt like losing Kaidan on Virmire -- which is why I've never done it -- losing Kaidan on Virmire that is.)

I'm not going to point fingers, that's just going to divide us more. I just see no reason why we can't all be respectful of each other, stop assuming personal things about each other, respect the NSFW restrictions and go back to liking Kaidan and being impatient for news. We can discuss everything pertinent to Kaidan and still be respectful of each other.

I just haven't seen a lot of that around here. And to get jumped on when I point it out is indicative of an unhealthy environment.

#8134
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

Sialater wrote...

I just haven't seen a lot of that around here. And to get jumped on when I point it out is indicative of an unhealthy environment.

But you jump on people yourself LOL.

#8135
Mandalina

Mandalina
  • Members
  • 100 messages
Mommy and Daddy are fighting again...

#8136
SilentK

SilentK
  • Members
  • 2 620 messages

TeenZombie wrote...

* snip*

I was replying to someone who didn't seem interested in continuing the Kaidan romance in ME3.  I'm going to go out on a limb and say that if someone romanced Kaidan in ME1, started a new romance with another character in ME2, and thinks that their character's relationship with Kaidan was over and done with, then they probably did like their ME2 LI better than Kaidan.  I don't see how that's condemning anyone as a "bad" Kaidan fan...there are plenty of people who like Kaidan, but he's not their favorite character in the series. 

*snip*

Hmmm... I would not agree with the statement that playing a FemShep that moves on means that you prefer the ME2 LI. I have FemShep's who are faithful to both Kaidan and Jacob and one who went on from Kaidan to Jacob. Will probably do the same thing with Liara. I tend to play the same FemShep pretty much, paragade with little minor desicions done differently every time. Juggling things on the LI-front between my 3 fav LI:s keeps the differen't FemShep's feeling more different from each other   :)

So I would not say that I like Jacob more than Kaidan, or that I like Liara or Kaidan more than Jacob even if they have a few more FemShep's than Jacob. I simply try to get a feeling for what would suit the current FemShep. I like them all very very much and they keep me coming back for more games. Hmmm.... I would be careful when aussuming how someone else feels about people in the game. They might just have a different game-style    ;)  

I have a pretty good memory for dialouge, the first time I romanced Kaidan my heart was in my throat every time I spoke. Then I started to know all his lines by heart by the 3:rd FemShep, I didn't want to lose that surprised wonderful feeling I got so I changed it up by romancing Liara and discovered that I really like her as well. Hmm... I play this way because it works for me. I get goosebumps when I know I'm starting a Kaidan-FemShep. And I have the same reaction to Liara and Jacob         :D

edit: just making clear that I'm in no way miffed or so, just adding a different point of view. Hope the smileys helps  =)

Modifié par SilentK, 20 septembre 2011 - 04:26 .


#8137
jeweledleah

jeweledleah
  • Members
  • 4 043 messages
oh look. its Isaac getting personal with people who dare to disagree with his vision of what this thread should be.

on cheating issue. the letter is very ambiguous. you can interpret it in a variety of ways, but one way that I cannot possibly see is thinking that Kaidan assumes that their relationship is totally back on. he shows interest, he shows he still care, but I cannot see him getting angry if Shepard moves on. sad, yes. but I feel like the reason he's telling Shepard about the doctor, one of them anyways, is to give himself a way out and give Shepard a way out.

unless bioware decides to "character develop" him into a different person.

about NSFW pictures.  I check out this thread from home and some of those images still catch me off guard.  there's a NSFW thread in the group for just that purpose.  There's a lot of SFW fanart for Kaidan including m/m if you are so inclined, why not make the thread more welcoming for more people by sticking to it?

Modifié par jeweledleah, 20 septembre 2011 - 04:30 .


#8138
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages

jeweledleah wrote...
unless bioware decides to "character develop" him into a different person.


It's all a set-up for the Great ME3 LI Slapfest, Leah.  Didn't you know?

#8139
syllogi

syllogi
  • Members
  • 7 258 messages

SilentK wrote...

TeenZombie wrote...

* snip*

I was replying to someone who didn't seem interested in continuing the Kaidan romance in ME3.  I'm going to go out on a limb and say that if someone romanced Kaidan in ME1, started a new romance with another character in ME2, and thinks that their character's relationship with Kaidan was over and done with, then they probably did like their ME2 LI better than Kaidan.  I don't see how that's condemning anyone as a "bad" Kaidan fan...there are plenty of people who like Kaidan, but he's not their favorite character in the series. 

*snip*

Hmmm... I would not agree with the statement that playing a FemShep that moves on means that you prefer the ME2 LI. I have FemShep's who are faithful to both Kaidan and Jacob and one who went on from Kaidan to Jacob. Will probably do the same thing with Liara. I tend to play the same FemShep pretty much, paragade with little minor desicions done differently every time. Juggling things on the LI-front between my 3 fav LI:s keeps the differen't FemShep's feeling more different from each other   :)

So I would not say that I like Jacob more than Kaidan, or that I like Liara or Kaidan more than Jacob even if they have a few more FemShep's than Jacob. I simply try to get a feeling for what would suit the current FemShep. I like them all very very much and they keep me coming back for more games. Hmmm.... I would be careful when aussuming how someone else feels about people in the game. They might just have a different game-style    ;)  

I have a pretty good memory for dialouge, the first time I romanced Kaidan my heart was in my throat every time I spoke. Then I started to know all his lines by heart by the 3:rd FemShep, I didn't want to lose that surprised wonderful feeling I got so I changed it up by romancing Liara and discovered that I really like her as well. Hmm... I play this way because it works for me. I get goosebumps when I know I'm starting a Kaidan-FemShep. And I have the same reaction to Liara and Jacob         :D

edit: just making clear that I'm in no way miffed or so, just adding a different point of view. Hope the smileys helps  =)


I agree with what you say, and I was trying to say the same about play styles.  My point in the portion you quoted, though, was that I don't think it's the end of the world if someone does say they prefer the ME2 romances.  They can still like Kaidan as a character, and move on with a new LI, even when they don't have a separate playthrough dedicated to him.  Just like I can do something that makes me very, very depressed for the rest of the day, in DA2, and still be an Anders fan (I'm trying not to be spoilery, apologies if even this is too much).

#8140
shepskisaac

shepskisaac
  • Members
  • 16 374 messages

jeweledleah wrote...

oh look. its Isaac getting personal with people who dare to disagree with his vision of what this thread should be.

Ohh look. It's jeweledleah pressed about me again.

#8141
Criz

Criz
  • Members
  • 1 026 messages

Chylise wrote...

Criz-Zone wrote...

well, ... there isn't that much we can discuss, that hasn't been talked over and over and over and over before after ME1 and the only new thing that ME2 added was pretty much Horizon and perhaps the email and who that doctor is and what femSheps everywhere are going to do to her etc.


Shall we try to guess what color Kaidan's underclothes are again instead? ;)

Or maybe his extranet fetish site addiction?

...Dammit, is it March yet? *wanders off to go get her Harvest Moon preorder*


you know, ever since ME2 and EDI's remark about Joker's extranet sites, I keep thinking that Kaidan knows about asari in pinstripe suit like fetish sites because of Joker.
Even under the 'silent waters run deep' I couldn't wrap my head around Kaidan intentionally googling such sites :huh:

#8142
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages

Criz-Zone wrote...

Chylise wrote...

Criz-Zone wrote...

well, ... there isn't that much we can discuss, that hasn't been talked over and over and over and over before after ME1 and the only new thing that ME2 added was pretty much Horizon and perhaps the email and who that doctor is and what femSheps everywhere are going to do to her etc.


Shall we try to guess what color Kaidan's underclothes are again instead? ;)

Or maybe his extranet fetish site addiction?

...Dammit, is it March yet? *wanders off to go get her Harvest Moon preorder*


you know, ever since ME2 and EDI's remark about Joker's extranet sites, I keep thinking that Kaidan knows about asari in pinstripe suit like fetish sites because of Joker.
Even under the 'silent waters run deep' I couldn't wrap my head around Kaidan intentionally googling such sites :huh:


Well... everyone needs a hobby.  :lol:

BUT.... if it was because of Joker, wouldn't he say that? Instead of the defensive, "What?" and shrug?

#8143
SilentK

SilentK
  • Members
  • 2 620 messages
@ TeenZombie =) great. Then I get what you mean.

Well yes, I have FemShep's who would wait forever for him and one who loved him very very much and was heartbroken when she realized that he had moved on. Luckily she found love again with Jacob, we'll see how it turns out for her in ME3. She doesn't know that Kaidan was removed in order to be safe from the SM so she really thought that the love of her life left her. Jupp... I love playing all my different FemSheps =)

Modifié par SilentK, 20 septembre 2011 - 04:44 .


#8144
Ellyria

Ellyria
  • Members
  • 905 messages

Criz-Zone wrote...

Chylise wrote...

Criz-Zone wrote...

well, ... there isn't that much we can discuss, that hasn't been talked over and over and over and over before after ME1 and the only new thing that ME2 added was pretty much Horizon and perhaps the email and who that doctor is and what femSheps everywhere are going to do to her etc.


Shall we try to guess what color Kaidan's underclothes are again instead? ;)

Or maybe his extranet fetish site addiction?

...Dammit, is it March yet? *wanders off to go get her Harvest Moon preorder*


you know, ever since ME2 and EDI's remark about Joker's extranet sites, I keep thinking that Kaidan knows about asari in pinstripe suit like fetish sites because of Joker.
Even under the 'silent waters run deep' I couldn't wrap my head around Kaidan intentionally googling such sites :huh:


I now have this image of Joker saying "Hey Kaidan, check this out!" and Kaidan runs to see every time only to find out Joker is showing him something smutty... again. Poor guy never learns. :lol:

Edit: Or maybe Kaidan just googled something he thought was innocent and it produced too many "special sites". :D

I had a professor in college who wouldn't let her seven year old use Google for an assignment because it was about beavers.

Modifié par Chylise, 20 septembre 2011 - 04:54 .


#8145
Eccentrica Gallumbits

Eccentrica Gallumbits
  • Members
  • 172 messages

Bekkael wrote...

TeenZombie wrote...

Eh, for all we know, Mass Effect is going the way of Dragon Age with the GRIMDARK endings, anyway. So no matter who we romance Kaidan with, bad things might happen anyway. I already made my prediction:

*snip deeply disturbing pic*


I have been scarred for life. Cannot unsee... :pinched:

On another note, my third son turned thirteen years old today. Please tell me I still look good for my age, I'm feeling a little weathered and worn. :? Possibly, I need chocolate.


LOL My son is 13 too. 14 soon.  Having teens does that to you. Posted Image

#8146
JaerWolfe

JaerWolfe
  • Members
  • 418 messages
On the nothing new to discuss front...actually, there kind of is, based on probabilities in plot. The Vega comic takes place days after Arrival and Shep is in the brig of the Normandy being taken presumably to earth.
That leaves two possible reunion scenes with Kaidan...the most likely being that Shepard will be behind bars. The second being during the trial itself. Perhaps the VS is called as a witness?
Hmm, I suppose there is a third, too. We see Ashley on the Normandy picking Shep up in the demo so that is a placeholder for the VS and could be the first meeting between them since Horizon.
Which do you think is preferable?
I like the behind bars scenario myself, simply for the drama of it.

#8147
Criz

Criz
  • Members
  • 1 026 messages

Sialater wrote...

*snipping to avoid quote pyramid*

Well... everyone needs a hobby.  :lol:

BUT.... if it was because of Joker, wouldn't he say that? Instead of the defensive, "What?" and shrug?


maybe he took a moment to realize that because he brought it up, people would think he's the one who's looking at those sites for fun.
if you phrase it as extranet FETISH site you probably know it's not for the common taste :lol:

#8148
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages
How on earth or above is Shepard in the brig of her own ship?

I kinda like the behind bars scenario myself...

#8149
Ellyria

Ellyria
  • Members
  • 905 messages

Sialater wrote...

How on earth or above is Shepard in the brig of her own ship?

I kinda like the behind bars scenario myself...


*scratches head* Yeah, that's just odd.

Miranda/Jacob/whoever: Okay Shepard, you blew up a bunch of Batarians and now you need to stand trail on Earth. So get in the brig. No, you're not allowed to stay in your quarters until we get there, that would make sense!

Shepard: Lolwut.

Modifié par Chylise, 20 septembre 2011 - 05:02 .


#8150
Fault Girl

Fault Girl
  • Members
  • 2 153 messages

JaerWolfe wrote...

On the nothing new to discuss front...actually, there kind of is, based on probabilities in plot. The Vega comic takes place days after Arrival and Shep is in the brig of the Normandy being taken presumably to earth.
That leaves two possible reunion scenes with Kaidan...the most likely being that Shepard will be behind bars. The second being during the trial itself. Perhaps the VS is called as a witness?
Hmm, I suppose there is a third, too. We see Ashley on the Normandy picking Shep up in the demo so that is a placeholder for the VS and could be the first meeting between them since Horizon.
Which do you think is preferable?
I like the behind bars scenario myself, simply for the drama of it.


My feeling is you first meet the VS when they rescue you. I would love to meet them before hand. But if Vega is guarding Shepard, that means you would meet him before the trail. There are alot of possiblities. In the demo, I think Anderson speaks to VS before the Normandy comes so they are on the ship in advance or in the vicinity. So Kaidan could be at the trail watching but maybe not been able to talk to Shepard.

So many possiblities. That it why I probably will leave the thread a month before release, I dont want to ruin it for myself! :P

Even though My Shepard gave herself in willingly, I suppose they have to restrain her/place her in a temp proson such as the brig incase she changes her mind or for the Batarians to make it look like they are being serious?

Modifié par ZombieGeisha, 20 septembre 2011 - 05:04 .