1. ME1 had the best story and characters, but the worst gameplay. Unfortunately, gameplay is a very important part of a game, so, ironically, even though I enjoy ME1's story and character interaction more, I've probably spent more time playing ME2.
2. ME2 is notable for improving the gameplay of the series, but where I think it really stands out is with fleshing out the universe and making it come even more alive than ME1. I disagree on the characters here being the best, but I think they were okay. I think a failing of ME2 is that not enough time was spent on character conversations and interaction, which could have fleshed the characters out better. The romances were particularly bad, especially with Miranda, where her interest seems to just come out of nowhere after you help her - then she has nothing to say until you sleep together. There's no real buildup. No way to see the relationship developing in game. You have to make it all up in your head.
Nevertheless, I think ME2 is the best over all combination of universe and gameplay in the series, and is probably the strongest in the trilogy, despite sidelining Ash and despite the fact that it does have flaws. I'd also argue that it has the best music, a category in which it just barely defeats ME1.
3. ME3 has the best graphics, combat gameplay (I know some people hate it, but I like it better than ME2, despite admitting it has flaws) and, ironically, some of the best missions in the trilogy (Tuchanka, Rannoch, and I'd add Mars and Grissom Academy, as well). It's the weakest game in the trilogy over all, though, because it represents a major step backwards in our ability to define who our Shepard is, because it eliminates the "find your own side missions" aspect that really fleshed out the ME universe and replaced them with really bland "gun and rush" N7 missions, and because when the main missions don't hit a home run, they tend to be just underwhelming.
The really weird thing for me is that, while I think that ME2 is the "best" over all game and probably the most fun to play in general, I'd say that my top 5 favorite missions are all from ME1 and ME3:
1. Tuchanka missions (ME3)
2. Quarian/geth missions (ME3)
3. Noveria (ME1)
4. Feros (ME1)
5. Bring Down the Sky (ME1)
EDIT: Top Ash!
Modifié par DWH1982, 09 septembre 2012 - 03:01 .





Retour en haut






