Visii wrote...
Maybe it shouldn't be past tense?
Want Thane, Won't Settle for Kaidan?
Good idea!
yamainu1984 wrote...
And I lost hope again. Right now and at the moment anything feel senseless.

by masterluckyxiii on tumblr: http://masterluckyxi...-to-be-a-really
They won't see it because it wasn't the plan for him. And the hammer crushes down on me.
And your reaction was exactly why I didn't want to post this here. But I guess I couldn't really stop it from getting around posting it on tumblr. Oh well.
Looking at Weekes comments makes me feel so frustrated. He's one of my favorites and I can see his side of things, but he's missing the point. In my opinion, they have every right to not cure him, however, they instead only focused on making him die which is just sick and twisted when you really think about it. As my little picture above indicates and what I've said a thousand times, his existence should been more than a death scene. Yeah I've said in the past if he had to die, I wanted to see him go out saving someone's life. But I also said I didn't want to see him in the hospital first thing, never putting up a fight at all. I didn't expect to have one conversation and next time I see him I watch him die. It wasn't bittersweet, it was just bitter and bad story telling.
If you created a character only for killing them off, you've made a worthless NPC, a plot tool. You don't build them up for family, friends, potentially a romance, and involment with the major plot. You don't do that to red shirts. In ME2 they created a wonderful little plot around him, his loyalty mission didn't even need a lot of fighting and people loved him for the story. If they wanted him in a hospital so bad, why not just have a lot of story side stuff involving him? Why does his son suddenly change? Just accepts everything. What made him want to submit himself to a hospital when he seemed so stubborn about it before? What the crap is going on his in life besides dying? We already knew that!
He has no god damn story in ME3 at all. The only reason they brought him back is for shock value, to emotionally engage the player. Like so many other things in the story, there is little real logic behind it. They just wanted to have everyone watch someone die.