@JECW - Thank you for commisioning a beautiful piece....and for giving us the name of the artist (I couldn't find it listed on Tumblr). Editted the post to show artist and your Shepard.
@Annie - So very true. Generally speaking, most people are very accepting of choices, if choices were always given from the beginning. I am still completely convinced that if the choice had been available from the start, the majority of people would not hold issue with Thane's POTENTIAL life extension/cure. But, because it was NOT given, there are some that rumble about the idea of an option being added. It's as though they feel they need to justify why they like what was given. Problem is, they don't need to. They can still LIKE what was given.
Look at a polarizing character like Anders in DA2. You can't stop him from blowing the chantry, but how you react to him can be different. The fact is some will always murder/knife him, some never will. And still others will always tell him to GTFO. Then there are those that will try ALL of the options. Why?? Because they can.....because the options exist. Because they like to RP all kinds of PC's. This helps expand replayability. Whether you like DA2 or not, the fact that the options are there for your Hawke to react to, is still generally what many Role Players are looking for. Hell, I can even imagine some Thanemancers and Friends of Thane who would play BOTH options for Thane's fate, had they been available (or if they are ever implemented....hint, hint.).
Bah, I'm not sure I am making any sense right now. Bad nights sleep and not enough coffee.