Karrie788 wrote...
Aris Ravenstar wrote...
alyxor wrote...
And while I appreciated Kaidan a lot in the first game, it kinda bugged me how he and Ashley turned into pretty much the same person in the third game. Plus, he takes everything so seriously that I can't imagine any Shep of mine ever being interested in him at that point.
I'm not a fan of Kaidan, but I loved Ashley. I think that's a testament to how different the characters were in the first game. ME3 Ashley is just... not Ashley. She's an Ashley stand-in. If you aren't romancing her, it's like she's not even there. It makes me so sad.
I feel the same. I loved Ash in ME1, she was wonderfully written. I created a ManShep just for her. What she became in ME3 truly made me sad. I had her go in a blaze of glory in my newest playthrough on Virmire. I'd rather remember her as this awesome character rather than that piece of furniture in ME3.
Plus I like Kaidan in the last game.
On the other hand, Garrus's character arc was probably one of the best in the trilogy. Along with Wrex, IMO.
I hated Ashley at first in ME1, but my second playthrough I actually grew fond of her. Even my first, completely blind playthrough, I agonized about having to kill either Kaidan or Ashley. My meeting with her on Horizon in 2 went really well, even. So well, that my jerkwad renegade Shepard didn't even hook up with anyone beyond flirting with Kelly, contrary to what I figured I'd do. It also made me really excited for whatever was going to happen between my manshep and Ashley in the final game.
My opinion of Kaidan was rather mild, but I thought that his romance was the most well-written of the first game, and better than most of the romances in the second. (A few of them, especially Jack's and Miranda's, seemed kind of.... cliché.) My run-in with him on Horizon, though, was positively infuriating. I was also taken aback at how he could be less reasonable than Ash was, when I got the perspective of both encounters.
Kaidan actually does a pretty good job of apologizing for sticking his foot in his mouth in the third game, but then resolves to be furniture for most of the rest of the game. (Though his awkward saying-but-not-saying his feelings for Shepard on Earth added an interesting depth to their final conversation). Ashley had a few other interesting things happen (visiting her sister on the Citadel, that time she drank too much on the Normandy), but pretty much does exactly as Kaidan does, even though they're fairly different in the first game.
I, too, was pretty disappointed with what happened with Ashley in me3.