Who was the first Bioware writer to work on a romance? And what character was the first romance written for (I'm guessing it was BG2, but I may be wrong)?
At least for the long-term ones in BG2, wouldn't that be Dave? *Points at Page 11 of the topic, the big-ass quote*
I had just started with BioWare, getting my feet wet writing a bunch of the Athkatla plots in Baldur’s Gate II when James Ohlen told me his idea for romance plots… a long chain of interactions over the course of the game specific to someone romancing the character. Seemed… simple enough? Nobody had ever done something quite like that, to my knowledge. At least, not to that extent. There was a romance arc in Final Fantasy 7, sort of, which I’d played. So kind of like that?
Gosh what a nightmare. As was the case with many things in BG2, this kind of ballooned beyond initial plans. At every turn, it was “hey, maybe this could happen here if you’re in a romance” or “hey, maybe we should add this” or “hey, maybe Bodhi kidnaps your romance and turns them into a vampire”. That won’t be hard to do, right? Which was awesome, sure, but the scripting teams were already doing cartwheels to keep on top of all the content. Add to that the plot timers based on real-time mixed with those based on game-time and it was a recipe for bugs. Bugs, bugs, bugs, bugs. This being my first game, it seemed like a bewildering sea of them. There were so many bugs in the Jaheira romance alone James once posted a sign on his door which essentially read “IF YOU’RE COMING TO TALK TO ME ABOUT JAHEIRA BUGS I DON’T WANT TO HEAR IT!” I thought for sure they were all going to get cut. I’m pretty certain they teetered on the edge of it for some time.
But they went in. It just seemed like too much effort to waste, and they were kind of cool even if they were pretty prone to breaking badly. That was just how we rolled in those days. I don’t think we ever imagined it would be popular. Did guy gamers (remember there was only one romance aimed at female players) really want this sort of content? Seemed like a dubious prospect.
And yet… whoa. It became a thing. It took on a life of its own. I suppose the cynical could imagine that we simply liked the positive response and did more of the same to “pander” (there’s that word again) to those poor, deluded fools who couldn’t see how obviously insipid such plots were… but this was a visceral reaction. You don’t ignore that. This was something people hadn’t seen much of, and they wanted to see more. So, yes, I’d say it was something that definitely went right. It was kind of great to be there at the start of it, though I recall being a little chagrined at the time to find myself the only writer who wanted to write the guy-romances. Odd how things change.