23 réponses à ce sujet

[Rithmerdui]

If you romanced Leliana but yet killed her, what do she mention?
What would she say, that she had a romance or she explains her death?

[LobselVith8]

Leliana has dialogue where she romanced The Warden, saying (s)he's dear to her heart, but it's the codex that references "her death;" there's dialogue if she remained in Lothering, and she explains that it wasn't her time since she's recognized as a Lothering resident, but there's no explanation for how she came back from The Warden killing her.

[Rithmerdui]

Thanks for the reply

[MistySun]

I could never , ever, kill Leliana. I loved her too much.  <3

[Torax]

I would never kill her. The one time I went to defile the ashes I did kill Wynne but did a quick reload. But I left Leliana in camp for that. It's like killing Merrill. NO! I am forced to kill Merrill in the fade but that is more about teaching her a lesson about demons...

[Fieryeel]

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

[TEWR]

Technically you didn't confirm she was dead. The Warden didn't kneel down and say "Welp, she's dead."


She's a rogue after all, and rogues do know Feign Death. Though that would be a cheap way to explain her survival because what if you didn't teach her that? Are we to assume that she retained some of her bardic ways? Still, it's a talent that fakes death as the name implies.


You could've just left her for dead, and she saw in another vision that the Ashes were her only hope because the Maker had plans for her.


now, I understand the codex updates itself with information regarding the battle, but I choose to see that as the Warden's own personal journal. He may not write "Dear Diary, today I killed Leliana. Or I think I did. I didn't check. The end." but that's how I see it.

[DonutsDealer]

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

Leliana is Andraste v2.0!

[TEWR]

DonutsDealer wrote...

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

Leliana is Andraste v2.0!

Nah that's Flemeth. Flemeth is Andraste who is the Dumat OGB

[Herr Uhl]

DonutsDealer wrote...

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

Leliana is Andraste v2.0!

Andraste never died and came back to life. Unless you believe the mountain dudes.

[Feanor_II]

I wonder why Leliana and Casandra are trying to find The Warden, in y import he died......

[Demx]

Torax wrote...

I would never kill her. The one time I went to defile the ashes I did kill Wynne but did a quick reload. But I left Leliana in camp for that. It's like killing Merrill. NO! I am forced to kill Merrill in the fade but that is more about teaching her a lesson about demons...

I had Wynne, Leliana, and Alistair with me when I defiled the ashes. It was awesome.

[Rifneno]

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

True. But if anyone thinks that explanation is going to be a big shocker, the least bit important to the story, or even make sense... remember the explanation we got for Anders' death at Vigil's Keep. Mages all look alike, and he ran away from the Grey Wardens after framing another mages for his corpse even though he actually runs away later after they made him give away Ser Pounce-a-lot who he might not have even been given. Also, all that happens if you let Rylock have him; he just escapes find another Warden and that Warden does the same stuff as yours would have. Not convoluted at all.

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Nah that's Flemeth. Flemeth is Andraste who is the Dumat OGB

This. All hail Old God Dumat-Andraste-Flemeth, the creator and condemner of blood magic.

Herr Uhl wrote...

Andraste never died and came back to life. Unless you believe the mountain dudes.

Yep. There's no indication of a resurrection in Chantry doctrine. I think it's another case of people assuming because X is true in Christianity, it's true in Andrastism since it's obviously loosely based on it. Made the mistake myself once or twice I'm embarrassed to admit.

Feanor_II wrote...

I wonder why Leliana and Casandra are trying to find The Warden, in y import he died......

If the DAO Warden died, they're looking for the Orlesian Warden-Commander from DAA. I don't know why they're surprised he's disappeared. He's French and there's a war going on.

... Sorry. I had to say it.

Modifié par Rifneno, 22 juin 2011 - 11:34 .

[Hatchetman77]

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

Technically you didn't confirm she was dead. The Warden didn't kneel down and say "Welp, she's dead."

I cut her head clean off though...

[mahony427]

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

I cut her head clean off though...

Me too. You can't feign that

[Rifneno]

mahony427 wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

I cut her head clean off though...

Me too. You can't feign that 

She's a member of the Chantry.  Having a brain is not only optional, it's frowned upon.

[LobselVith8]

MistySun wrote...

I could never , ever, kill Leliana. I loved her too much.  <3

My Surana Warden didn't kill Leliana, but given her attitude towards mages and mage autonomy in Kirkwall, I'm more than willing to rectify that mistake.

Torax wrote...

I would never kill her. The one time I went to defile the ashes I did kill Wynne but did a quick reload. But I left Leliana in camp for that. It's like killing Merrill. NO! I am forced to kill Merrill in the fade but that is more about teaching her a lesson about demons...

Your Warden could defile the Ashes before getting Wynne at the Circle Tower, and then persuade a hardened Leliana or lie to Leliana who was left at camp about the Urn of Sacred Ashes.

Interestingly, it doesn't even seem that the Urn is found "in the canon of DA2" if Brother Genitivi was killed or told to go back to Denerim but never spoken to again despite the DA:O Epilogue slides. I guess this was changed, too.

Rifneno wrote...

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

True. But if anyone thinks that explanation is going to be a big shocker, the least bit important to the story, or even make sense... remember the explanation we got for Anders' death at Vigil's Keep. Mages all look alike, and he ran away from the Grey Wardens after framing another mages for his corpse even though he actually runs away later after they made him give away Ser Pounce-a-lot who he might not have even been given. Also, all that happens if you let Rylock have him; he just escapes find another Warden and that Warden does the same stuff as yours would have. Not convoluted at all.

You forgot about the "not recruited" Anders meeting the "killed at the Dragonbone Wastes" Justice.

[Faust1979]

Never killed Leliana I'm to afraid of killing off my characters then limiting who I have to use for the final battle.

[DaiyoukaiGeisha]

Siradix wrote...

I had Wynne, Leliana, and Alistair with me when I defiled the ashes. It was awesome.

I never had the stones to defile the ashes. OMG, all 3 of them must have went beserk after you did that. LOL!

DA:O Party Disapproves -9001

[TEWR]

mahony427 wrote...

The Ethereal Writer Redux wrote...

I cut her head clean off though...

Me too. You can't feign that

1) Hey I never said that!

2) I don't consider fancy kill animations lore. Because then I'd have to consider goop explosions lore.

Modifié par The Ethereal Writer Redux, 22 juin 2011 - 10:28 .

[Sajuro]

DonutsDealer wrote...

Fieryeel wrote...

David Gaider has said that there is a canon explanation for her return if u "killed" her in DAO, but he won't be revealing it yet.

Leliana is Shepard v2.0!

Fixed that for you

[Tirfan]

It's the magical healing cavern, I knew I should have dragged her body out off that place and fed it to the dragon.

[Torax]

Tirfan wrote...

It's the magical healing cavern, I knew I should have dragged her body out off that place and fed it to the dragon.

Bards are too gamey

[Sajuro]

Torax wrote...

Tirfan wrote...

It's the magical healing cavern, I knew I should have dragged her body out off that place and fed it to the dragon.

Bards are too Spoony

Fixed