iAmLegion2183 wrote...
Hows this for a twist...
The Alliance has always known about the Reapers. Evidence of the Reapers was discovered when scientists excavated Mars and found the Prothean ruins and the technology cache, but this knownledge was kept from the civilian population. Xenophobic Alliance brass decided not to tell the citadel council after the First Contact War with the Turians. The Alliance decided that they were going to put a sustainable human population into hiding. After the galactic purge is completed and the Reapers have left the galaxy these humans would go onto repopulate the galaxy. The next 50,000 years would allow the human race to rival the technology of the Reapers, and dominate the galaxy. The Alliance orders Cerberus to retrieve and resurrect Commander Shepard because he is the only person capable of removing the Collector threat. The Alliance can't afford loss of colonies, these will be be required to repopulate the galaxy. The Alliance can't stop the Collectors head on using a fleet of ships against the Collectors because it would cause tension with the Batarians. The Alliance can't afford an all out war with massive losses of human lives.
Cerberus is then ordered to terminate Shepard because he has the potential to actually stop the Reapers at this cycle. The Alliance and Cerberus don't want a diverse galactic population of aliens, and Shepard is too resourceful.
I am completely on this.
This is completely brilliant. The Alliance ultimately being every bit as genophobic and selfish as Cerberus would be an excellent twist!
I'm gonna guess that, by the end of ME3, the Alliance, Cerberus, and the Council will be the three major players. Paragon players would be torn with three options as to whom to side with, with the unobvious paragon option to be the Council, and the deceptive option to be the Alliance (Cerberus being quite clearly renegade).
On top of that, having Shepard wiping out the Collectors now makes perfect sense. With the galaxy empty of sentient space faring life for several thousand years, the Alliance wouldn't be able to emerge from hiding with the Collectors and a in-galaxy Reaper probing the stars for potential space faring races. At the first sight of an Alliance ship or radio communication, they'd either abduct expanding human colonies without taking a hit, or send in a few Reapers to wipe out humanities last pockets.
All the protheans had to do to adequately warn humanity of the Reapers would be to make a simple and very clear cut message to humans on Mars, trusting earth to eventually reach that destination. The Alliance grabs that information first, realizes the futility of their actions, and plans a massive expansion in wake of a galactic river of blood.
The only thing that doesn't make sense is the last part. Cerberus wouldn't be "ordered" to do anything. It seems more likely that the Alliance initially used Cerberus for their own goals, but with TIM having taken over, Cerberus is out of their control. They wouldn't need to order Cerberus to take down Shepard if their communication and over all goals were no longer aligned. They could just pull Shepard into a side room full of Alliance N7 Marines and gun him down, or shoot him in his sleep. Shepard expects an attack from Cerberus, but from the Alliance?
It seems more likely that the two factions (alliance and cerberus) work together periodically and unintentionally get the same results. But in the end, they have to similar, if not equally startling goals:
Cerberus plans on utilizing Reaper technology and Geth technology to stop the Reapers, and essentially rule over the other races. Obviously resistance will be swift, but Cerberus will put down anyone who stops them.
The Alliance plans on using the other races as a shield, stealthily escaping a sea of bloodshed, to emerge a few thousand years later onto a quiet and utterly human exclusive galaxy. Their human dominance is utterly assured.
The one flaw with the Alliance's plan is that it counts on at least a few thousand years in which humanity will remain "veiled" from the Reapers. That's a long time, and an even longer maintaining of power and control. Its a great plan for long term goals, but Cerberus seems more open to just winning quickly.
Damn...this is probably the best speculation I've ever read!
Modifié par 100k, 17 juin 2011 - 06:40 .