21 réponses à ce sujet

[Tall Boss]

Okay so this is driving me crazy. During the mission "A Eye for a Eye" I took the Renegade option to allow Garrus to kill Sidonas. In all honesty I think this is a good example of how renegade is not always evil,Sidonas deserved it. My only worry is how drastically this might change things for Garrus in ME3. You think action could spell his death in ME3 even after he survived the suicide mission? Could this change his personality to a point where Garrus becomes too blood thirsty?

[Shepard Lives]

I don't think it's going to affect him too much, if at all. Garrus is always Garrus, and when he's with Shepard he runs no risk of going nuts.

[TexasToast712]

I didnt like that Garrus was going down the same path I was. I didnt like seeing Garrus like that so I spared Sidonis.

On a side note: Did anyone else find it creepy that when you are talking to Garrus in the taxi his pupils have red in them making him look like he is getting renegade scars like Shep?

[Cutlass Jack]

I doubt it will affect him much. You had a similar bit in ME1 where you could steer him to move forward in a Paragon or Renegade direction, and it didn't change a thing in ME2.

[CrybabyXD]

it will probably only change a line of dialouge or sidionas may show up if hes not dead.

[Tall Boss]

Just as long as Garrus stays a friend and doesn't die im happy. Honestly when it comes to choices killing Sidonas was the most renegade option i've done. That and killing some nobody mercs who thought I took prisoners.

My favorite squad mates are probably:
1.Wrex (my badass)
2.Garrus (my sidekick)
3.Mordin (my OCD hyperactive scientist) XD

[Yeti13]

hmmm Seeing how he never brings up that it was the same situation with Dr. Heart it kinda annoyed me but I went with the Paragon on this one. Garrus is one the character arcs that is superb, he is essentially the definition of Paragon, he is willing to kill to achieve good but does have a conscious about it. How this will affect ME3 is the real interesting thing because he is Shepard's link to Pavalon and the biggest fleet in council species. Garrus might be willing to sacrifice people to save the Galaxy which could come to a head in ME3 if your playing full paragon but maybe if you spared Dr. Heart and Sidionis, he may be a better diplomat between the Turians and Humans

[MACharlie1]

Wasn't there concern over Garrus getting a death scene in ME3? I had a theory that Garrus would die if Sidonis was killed and if he wasn't then he'd take whatever it was that killed Garrus for him.

[Mmw04014]

I really don't think it'll change anything. Despite how you dealt with Dr. Heart, whether telling Garrus to kill him or take him to the authorities, Garrus still ends up in the same situation with the same views as in ME2. I'm hoping if this changes Garrus, he only changes if you take the Paragon path. If you let him kill Sidonis, then he just keeps on being a "take the law into your own hands" guy, but not particularly evil or blood thirsty like you said.

[outmane]

I usually let Garrus kill Sidonis. Hes the perfect example of what a good renegade character should be so i dont feel obligated to go all paragon on his ass for how he handles his personal business. As far as how it will affect him? well if Omega is any example of how well Shep can transform Garrus, id say hes pretty much his own man already.

@MACharlie
Maybe Sidonis will pop out around Pavalen but its a big step from kill Garrus for all the renegade players.

[Tall Boss]

I guess killing Garrus would be a unfairly drastic for that renegade option. Now I'm just hoping that killing Sidonis doesn't screw you over trying to recruit the Turians to fight the Reapers. Which it shouldn't (That would be such bull****),especially since I saved the council and didn't let Cerberus have the Collector base.

[Saberchic]

Garrus getting killed for avenging his squad mates? Nope. Not going to happen. I don't think Garrus is going to get knocked off with a bunk decision like that. That would be a b**** move, and Bioware will definitely treat him better than that.

He has survived a lot of stuff, and darn it, he's going to be with my Shep til the end.

[Power47]

Yeti13 wrote...

Garrus is one the character arcs that is superb, he is essentially the definition of Paragon, he is willing to kill to achieve good but does have a conscious about it.

Wait... what? In ME2 Garrus is the definition of renegade

[Mr.House]

MACharlie1 wrote...

Wasn't there concern over Garrus getting a death scene in ME3? I had a theory that Garrus would die if Sidonis was killed and if he wasn't then he'd take whatever it was that killed Garrus for him.

This will cause so much fan rage I doubt that would happen, even though it would be awesome.

[Sparrow44]

I expect something to go down with Garrus when visiting Palaven seeing as he still has family there.

[danteliveson]

Sidonis runs Garrus over.

[Mims]

I don't think we'll see Sidonis, but we might hear a news report on him. I think the key thing about the incident is that it will weigh heavily on Garrus' paragon/renegade alignment. Ideally in the third game he'll resolve a situation on his own based on that score, and not Shepard.

Modifié par Mims, 17 juin 2011 - 12:58 .

[Raiil]

I don't think it has a huge impact on his story arc after it happens. He either kills the son of a b---h and moves on, or he spares the coward and... moves on. I'm guessing maybe some dialogue changes.

I really like Garrus as an example of how a renegade should be. But I'm not a huge fan of lawful good characters either.

[Rulid]

Garrus never struck me as a mature character.
He's let Shep spin him around with her(his) decisions a bit too much to be considered a solid NPC responding to Shep.
If the devs are aware of how dichotomous his actions could represent adding up ME1 and 2 as a whole picture (were he to spare Dr. Heart then kill Sidonis, or the other way around), he might present as someone who's actually made up his mind on good and evil by ME3.
Otherwise, looking forward to just playing with his mind a bit more.

[Twilight_Princess]

danteliveson wrote...

Sidonis runs Garrus over.

Garrus: Shepard why are we back at the citadel?

Shepard: We are in need of urgent supplies

Garrus: You killed your fish again didn’t you?

Shepard:  I fed them! Ok, 5 missions ago but- *hears an accelerating hover car*

Garrus: Wait...0_-... is that?

Sidonis: YOUSHOULDHAVEKILLEDMEWHENYOUHADTHECHANCEGARRUS!*THUNK*BETYOUDIDN’TSETHATCOMING!PARAGONCONSEQUENCEFTW !*turns corner*

Shepard: what the **** just happened?

Modifié par Hyrule_Gal, 20 juin 2011 - 10:38 .

[Clonedzero]

MACharlie1 wrote...

Wasn't there concern over Garrus getting a death scene in ME3? I had a theory that Garrus would die if Sidonis was killed and if he wasn't then he'd take whatever it was that killed Garrus for him.

nah should be the other way around. garrus hesitates in shooting a guy because he's gone soft thanks to shepard and it gets him killed.

[Fairhammer]

Doesn't Garrus say, if you want to spare Sidnonis and killed Dr. Heart directly without letting him the choice to surrender, "You showed me other" (meaning wise) and shot him never the less?

So your influence isn't gone. He just forgott it in his revange tripp.

Modifié par Fairhammer, 20 juin 2011 - 11:59 .