98 réponses à ce sujet

[goodbyetonight]

Ashley, Garrus, Miranda, and Tali have to stay alive for me. Everyone else is fair game.

[Phategod1]

I respect all my squaddies But I I dont know how I can get attached to any newbs at this point so I think If I had to sacrifice anyone the newbs would get the shaft.

[Ieldra]

TeenZombie wrote...
Your favorite character sucks and deserves to be nuked from orbit. Repeatedly.

My favorite character is awesome and deserves plot protection, t-shirts, and eighteen DLCs.

So true.

Really, instead of making a "priority death list", it would be more interesting to talk about which choices would be particularly painful to make and why. Everyone could talk about their favorites and no motivation to pile up hate on anyone....

[ToGVita]

Ieldra2 wrote...

Really, instead of making a "priority death list", it would be more interesting to talk about which choices would be particularly painful to make and why. Everyone could talk about their favorites and no motivation to pile up hate on anyone....

I couldn't agree more.    Virmire was only meaningful if you actually cared about both Ashley and Kaidan.  

If I was a BioWare writer wanting to re-do the Virmire scenario, I think I'd choose Wrex vs Mordin.    Make both of them important for later plotlines, so that there is a strategic component to the decision as well as an emotional one.   Of course, Wrex is only available with an ME1 import, so he may not be worth the dev time, but that would be a decision I would sweat over.

[Comsky159]

I could probably discard Samara, Jacob and Liara without much hesitation. Don't hate them, just find them comparably uninteresting,

[Knight of Dane]

Liara
Tali
Garrus
Mordin
Samara
Legion
Grunt
Wrex
Miranda
Thane
Jacob
Kasumi
Kaidan
Ashley
Zaeed
Jack

Jack is the only one i don't care about, but here it is.

[Tyrium]

Garrus and Mordin are my favourites. After them, I especially want Ash, Grunt, Kasumi. I don't want to lose anyone, but Thane's first - he's dying already.

[Anezay]

Liara, Liara, Liara. Something about her being invulnerable in the first two games makes me want her dead. Priority for protection goes to Garrus and Tali, the most loyal of the squaddies.

[flexxdk]

TeenZombie wrote...

Your favorite character sucks and deserves to be nuked from orbit. Repeatedly.

My favorite character is awesome and deserves plot protection, t-shirts, and eighteen DLCs.

I chuckled.

Is that wrong?

Anyway, here's my list...:
1) Tali
2) Jack
3) Samara
4) Thane

After Thane I would do this.

[Aggie Punbot]

Anezay wrote...

Liara, Liara, Liara. Something about her being invulnerable in the first two games makes me want her dead.

THIS. Also, the blatant bias shown towards her by Bioware really irritates me so if there is ever an option for killing her (even if it's avoidable), she'll be the first one to go.

[Bugsie]

CheeseEnchilada wrote...
Zaeed. He's lived a long life, and should go out in a blaze of glory.

I would advocate he do a Logan's Run from your Shepard, cos 40 really isn't that long a life... 

[tomas2377]

Mine is a short list. As soon as I can kill off Liara I will.

She betrayed me to Cerberus and doesn't understand a clear no when it comes to romance. She keeps hitting at my Shep in a very desperate way and I had enough.

Further more the whole Liara favoritism for LI from Bioware is getting on my nerves. As soon as her plot armor comes off and I am given a choice to kill her I will in a heartbeat. No second thought on the subject.

[S.A.K]

Made a poll a few days ago for the exact same thing. Well here it is. You are welcome to vote.
ps.This is the only poll I ever seen Jacob win. Poor dude.

[Aviena]

There there, Liara. It's okay. They only hate you because you're...alive.

The only two squadmates I could give up without too many qualms would be Jack and Thane - and Thane really only because I've been subconciously preparing myself for his death since ME2 shipped. I think I might cry if I lose Garrus, Tali or Kaidan.

[Bolboreta]

S.A.K wrote...

Made a poll a few days ago for the exact same thing. Well here it is. You are welcome to vote.
ps.This is the only poll I ever seen Jacob win. Poor dude.

Well, Jacob appears twice, so he's obviously winning 

[xSTONEYx187x]

My space hamster deserves to go out in a blaze of glory.

[Vilio1]

I really hope Liara keeps her plot armor, just to ****** off all the haters.

[Labrev]

I'll figure in both Ashley and Kaidan, since I have two serious careers and effectively, both are alive. Morinth too.

Priority list would be subject to change based on squad make-up. But as an overall:


1.) Jacob: pretty much the exact same skill-set as Jack, and I prefer her as a squadmate (pull-bot, more effective with bonuses); drifter, so this loss won't really break anyone up too much either.

2.) Thane: among least-used squdmate, overall redundant skills; dying man; no value outside combat.

3.) Tali: tech expertise useful in story-line
situation (see: tech specialist, Suicide Mission); average-at-best combat skills; some quarian influence but
realistically, probably not much.

4.) Samara: biotic mastery useful in story-line situation; otherwise, redundant skill-set, least used teammate; offers no value outside combat either.

5.) Morinth: same page as her mother; but Dominate is wonderfully useful, so she goes a peg up.

6.) Zaeed: strong in combat; but no outside uses.

7.) Grunt: strong in combat; potential bargaining-chip with krogan, but minimal overall outside use.

8.) Mordin: decent combat; some "science" uses; limited overall by old age.

9a.) Kasumi: decent combat; tech skills useful, no outside use (that we know of, anyway).

9b.) Jack: decent combat; biotic skills useful, no outside use. Romance to one Shepard and a personal favorite, so this loss will hurt a bit.

11.) Garrus: strong in combat; leadership value; no outside uses.

12.) Wrex: strong combat (in ME1 anyway); considerable Krogan influence; age is a question-mark.

13.) Miranda: useful in combat; possibly useful Ceberus ties; leadership value.

14.) Kaidan/Ashley: both very solid in combat; Spectre/high-ranking Alliance officials.

16.) Legion: good combat, useful tech skills, key in rallying geth support.

17.) Liara: biotic skills, single most powerful teammate as Shadow Broker.


Kinda funny how a robot takes priority to all but one person on my list.

[dahoughtonuk]

Well Jack and Thane are two I could leave behind without feeling too guilty. Both have degenerative conditions and want to go out fighting. Still there is Kolyat to consider.

Miranda, but it's not necessarily going to be guilt free. Oriana will likely be used against her.

After that it'll depend on decision a Shepard made in game.

[S.A.K]

Bolboreta wrote...

S.A.K wrote...

Made a poll a few days ago for the exact same thing. Well here it is. You are welcome to vote.
ps.This is the only poll I ever seen Jacob win. Poor dude.

Well, Jacob appears twice, so he's obviously winning 

I put his name twice by mistake, that means we have to add the 2 to get his number of votes. You can only vote once you know.

[Degenerate Rakia Time]

Everyone i wanted dead already is, but if i had to make a list
Legion
Garrus
Samara
Tali

[Berkilak]

Valentia X wrote...

 an enormous soft spot for Grunt, unless we find out that he can have children,

As far as I know, the sterility targetted the women, not the males. Although some krogan males believe they can make themselves more potent, it really isn't their issue. I could be wrong, however...

[S.A.K]

goodbyetonight wrote...

Ashley, Garrus, Miranda, and Tali have to stay alive for me. Everyone else is fair game.

^this and add Legion and Liara to that too

[Nerevar-as]

Only situation I´d want someone dead is if the Quarians attempt to genocide the geth again and Tali approves. Otherwise ... I wouldn´t cry for Jacob or Zaeed, but don´t actively want them dead either.

[gunswordfist]

My hit list, AKA MFers that I WILL kill in order of who will die first to last:
1. VS
2. Jacob
3. Liara
4. Miranda
5. Morinth
Vega isn't on because WE HAVEN'T GOT TO KNOW HIM YET. He might go if I ever have to sacrifice more than 4 or 5.