Morrigan. I never liked Ashley. Ashley is unlikeable to me.
Ashley or Morrigan?
Débuté par
Esternogligen
, nov. 20 2009 06:24
Retour en haut
#52
Guest_Shavon_*
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 03:27
Guest_Shavon_*
Guest_Shavon_*
-
- Guests
Ummm, I am actually going to have to say Ashley 
While I think the romances are so much better in DA, depth, complexity, etc. Ash is a very likeable person, and her romance tugs at the heart strings. Morrigan makes an awesome friend for my Female Wardens, but so far I haven't been the least interested in seeing a romance with her through. Too tragic. It's better to see her end losing a friend-sister than a lover
While I think the romances are so much better in DA, depth, complexity, etc. Ash is a very likeable person, and her romance tugs at the heart strings. Morrigan makes an awesome friend for my Female Wardens, but so far I haven't been the least interested in seeing a romance with her through. Too tragic. It's better to see her end losing a friend-sister than a lover
#53
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 03:58
OH-UP-THIS!
-
- Members
- 2 399 messages
ahh! sorry,but kaiden didn't make it off the surface of the planet............except at nuclear speed.
And in pieces.
And in pieces.
#54
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 04:06
RPGlover732
-
- Members
- 113 messages
Morrigans a ****! like if i new her in real life i would hate her so much more then ashley, but morrigan makes a better video game character shes enjoyable to talk to, even though i want to punch her in her face.
Now Liara or Leliana? Leliana, liara i only liked because she was kinda nice and it was funny when she would say somthing stupid. Leliana is a much more thought out character, shes sweet but comes from a dark past and is all deppressed (unless shes with my PC)
Now Liara or Leliana? Leliana, liara i only liked because she was kinda nice and it was funny when she would say somthing stupid. Leliana is a much more thought out character, shes sweet but comes from a dark past and is all deppressed (unless shes with my PC)
#55
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 04:23
gotthammer
-
- Members
- 1 237 messages
Morrigan, of course. Claudia Black FTW! 
#56
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 04:27
Interitus
-
- Members
- 13 messages
Taleroth wrote...
No to Ashley. GOD NO. She's got a lazy eye and a chip on her shoulder. I can't stand her.
At least Morrigan doesn't try talking to me about her religious beliefs and poetry.
^that
#57
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 04:59
Bann Duncan
-
- Members
- 1 390 messages
andybuiadh wrote...
AgenTBC wrote...
Uh, Claudia Black isn't doing a British accent, she's just talking the same as always. It's an Australian accent, probably altered a bit by her time in New Zealand and the USA.
Incorrect. She has a "Down Under" accent, though it is slightly Anglified, granted.
I lived in Australia during my childhood and I still think Claudia Black sounds more like someone from the Home Counties than Australia. I've read something about her grandmother considering that the proper way to speak and as a result having her speak that way.
#58
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 05:07
Envor44
-
- Members
- 444 messages
I like both even though i prefer Morrigan
#59
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 05:09
F3ralCr
-
- Members
- 104 messages
Morrigan
Ashley was annoying at best.
Ashley was annoying at best.
#60
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 05:15
Keithhy
-
- Members
- 232 messages
Because this is the no spoilers forum I have to be vague, but when Ashley committed a certain act on a certain beach planet on my first playthrough, I began to hate her. On all of my playthroughs from then on, I ignored Ashley completely, and despised her.
On the other hand, Morrigan is a cold, manipulative b****, who shook my sense of right and wrong to its core.
Therefore, I vote Shale. No competition. At all. None.
On the other hand, Morrigan is a cold, manipulative b****, who shook my sense of right and wrong to its core.
Therefore, I vote Shale. No competition. At all. None.
#61
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 05:18
Dave of Canada
-
- Members
- 17 484 messages
Funny how people hate Ashley for her religious beliefs and being slightly wary against aliens (and that can even be changed through a charm option). I don't see how she can even be compared to Morrigan.
#62
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 06:35
mysamuraiFIGHT
-
- Members
- 7 messages
I really don’t get all the Ash hate. Granted, the whole I can do anything as well as a man was pushed a bit hard. In this regard she resembles a hard core feminist. But I think it also ties in to her background. Did any of you actually talk to her? As for what appears to be another big reason for the hate. Her faith. Now I’m nowhere near a religious person, but I find it …odd that this is such a turn off for so many. Not once did she ask if I had accepted Jesus Christ as my lord and savior, nor did I feel she pushed her belief upon me. By far though, the biggest reason for dislike seems to be her “racism”. Which is more correctly xenophobia. However I didn’t get that feeling either. I don’t think she hated aliens, I think she thought Earth/Human interests should be put above all else. But is it such an unreasonable position? The opposing view seems rather naïve to me. But that is another argument altogether. I thought she was a very deep well written character, in spite of her awful poetry.
Morrigan was also a very well written character. She is a cynical, self serving, and power hungry. She despises weakness, she is mistrusting, and very isolated. She is a very broken woman. Who throughout the story can come to care deeply for the warden. Something that challenges her world view, and frightens her.
Maybe I am reading a bit much into it, I don’t know. Bioware just seems to have a knack for developing great characters, Sten, Aton, Liara, Leiliana, HK47. Really to many to list. As for Ash or Morrigan. I think both are a credit to Biowares ability to create believable characters. If I had to choose I guess its Ash.
Morrigan was also a very well written character. She is a cynical, self serving, and power hungry. She despises weakness, she is mistrusting, and very isolated. She is a very broken woman. Who throughout the story can come to care deeply for the warden. Something that challenges her world view, and frightens her.
Maybe I am reading a bit much into it, I don’t know. Bioware just seems to have a knack for developing great characters, Sten, Aton, Liara, Leiliana, HK47. Really to many to list. As for Ash or Morrigan. I think both are a credit to Biowares ability to create believable characters. If I had to choose I guess its Ash.
#64
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 06:48
nmal015
-
- Members
- 64 messages
Morrigan. Nutty religious talk just bores me to tears.
Leliana as well, how irritating can a character be.
Come to think of it I wish there was an option to romance a normal person, not a sneaky witch thief, and not a nut job who has seemingly dedicated her life to invisible tyrants hiding in the clouds.
Normal person.
Leliana as well, how irritating can a character be.
Come to think of it I wish there was an option to romance a normal person, not a sneaky witch thief, and not a nut job who has seemingly dedicated her life to invisible tyrants hiding in the clouds.
Normal person.
Modifié par nmal015, 19 janvier 2010 - 06:48 .
#66
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 06:55
Leather_Rebel90
-
- Members
- 206 messages
Claudia Black has an annoying voice... Would have loved Morrigan's character if they had chosen a different VO.
I did like Liara, just because I'm a sucker for innocent/shy girls.
Didn't care for Ashley 'cuz I don't like girls who act tough like men.
I like Leliana as well because she was girly.
I did like Liara, just because I'm a sucker for innocent/shy girls.
Didn't care for Ashley 'cuz I don't like girls who act tough like men.
I like Leliana as well because she was girly.
#67
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 06:56
Leather_Rebel90
-
- Members
- 206 messages
TheDrunkenPanda wrote...
....I vote for Viconia.
^This! Absolutely adored Viconia's character.
#68
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 06:58
Leather_Rebel90
-
- Members
- 206 messages
Keithhy wrote...
Because this is the no spoilers forum I have to be vague, but when Ashley committed a certain act on a certain beach planet on my first playthrough, I began to hate her. On all of my playthroughs from then on, I ignored Ashley completely, and despised her.
.
PM me what you mean, I'm not exactly sure what you're talking about... If you're talking about something other than what I'm think about, then damnit I have to play ME again! Must... Do... Everything...
#69
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 07:22
stefan9
-
- Members
- 236 messages
Liked both but liked morrigan way more.
#72
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 09:22
MarginalBeast
-
- Members
- 664 messages
Ashley is a good person with a mouth on her. Morrigan is a sociopath.
I'd say that Morrigan is a better character, but Ashley is a better person.
If you liked him so much you should have gotten his armor for him like a true bro.
I'd say that Morrigan is a better character, but Ashley is a better person.
Keithhy wrote...
Because this is the no spoilers forum I have to be vague, but when Ashley committed a certain act on a certain beach planet on my first playthrough, I began to hate her. On all of my playthroughs from then on, I ignored Ashley completely, and despised her.
If you liked him so much you should have gotten his armor for him like a true bro.
#73
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 09:27
Xanfyrst
-
- Members
- 76 messages
Ashley was well-written. I'm an atheist, but I didn't mind her religious beliefs as she didn't threw it in my face... and she actually didn't talk much about her faith, so don't know why people think she's a religious zealot, or for that matter - a christian. (christianity isn't the only monotheistic faith, ya know)
She's suspecious and cautious towards aliens. So is most of humanity. You guys forget that humanity has only been a member of the galactic society for a few decades. Humans don't trust aliens, aliens don't trust humans. Her reactions and views is normal for one who doesn't know the unknown (people fear/hate/distrust things they don't know). In my opinion she always gets along quite well with the other aliens on the Normandy. Ashley is very loyal and is the reason why she does what she MAY do on Virmire (her job is to protect the interest of Earth Alliance, ergo protecting Shepard).
Morrigan is also a well-written character. Actually I think she has more depth than Ashley. Claudia Black is awesome. She's been brought up by a woman who has given her 'tough love' and it reflects on her actions and views shown throughout the game. She's a cynical individual that hates authority or people telling her what she can and can't do (unless you're bedding her... ;P )
T'Soni... I never really liked. Besides being less physically attractive than Ashley (who isn't my type either) she was also very dull personality-wise. The writers should've done a better with a love interest, especially one who seems to be more important for the overall story plot of the trilology than the other two. Hopefully we'll see an improvement in both ME2 and ME3.
Lelianna. Well, she's cute though she's also very deceptive. She didn't get the same amount of depth as Morrigan but still more than Ashley. I romanced her in my first playthrough and she came off as a likeable person... though her almost zealous obsession with her faith was undesireable for my tastes.
Tali is the enigma here. We don't know much about her, though what we know of her makes her likeable (unless you're a Geth-lover). She's a bit naive, yet not as much as T'Soni and seem to be far more sociable than her as well (Well, guess all quarians are, considering they don't have any private life on the Flotilla)
Miranda is the cold, calculating perfectionist. She dislikes recklessness, inefficiency and incompetence. I sense she has a more charismatic side, but we'll find out when we get the game.
Subject Zero AKA Jack is the ultra-violent punk of the ME universe. Unpredictable, reckless and highly unstable. It's hinted at that there's a little fragile girl hidden behind all that anger. Will be interesting to see who she really is.
She's suspecious and cautious towards aliens. So is most of humanity. You guys forget that humanity has only been a member of the galactic society for a few decades. Humans don't trust aliens, aliens don't trust humans. Her reactions and views is normal for one who doesn't know the unknown (people fear/hate/distrust things they don't know). In my opinion she always gets along quite well with the other aliens on the Normandy. Ashley is very loyal and is the reason why she does what she MAY do on Virmire (her job is to protect the interest of Earth Alliance, ergo protecting Shepard).
Morrigan is also a well-written character. Actually I think she has more depth than Ashley. Claudia Black is awesome. She's been brought up by a woman who has given her 'tough love' and it reflects on her actions and views shown throughout the game. She's a cynical individual that hates authority or people telling her what she can and can't do (unless you're bedding her... ;P )
T'Soni... I never really liked. Besides being less physically attractive than Ashley (who isn't my type either) she was also very dull personality-wise. The writers should've done a better with a love interest, especially one who seems to be more important for the overall story plot of the trilology than the other two. Hopefully we'll see an improvement in both ME2 and ME3.
Lelianna. Well, she's cute though she's also very deceptive. She didn't get the same amount of depth as Morrigan but still more than Ashley. I romanced her in my first playthrough and she came off as a likeable person... though her almost zealous obsession with her faith was undesireable for my tastes.
Tali is the enigma here. We don't know much about her, though what we know of her makes her likeable (unless you're a Geth-lover). She's a bit naive, yet not as much as T'Soni and seem to be far more sociable than her as well (Well, guess all quarians are, considering they don't have any private life on the Flotilla)
Miranda is the cold, calculating perfectionist. She dislikes recklessness, inefficiency and incompetence. I sense she has a more charismatic side, but we'll find out when we get the game.
Subject Zero AKA Jack is the ultra-violent punk of the ME universe. Unpredictable, reckless and highly unstable. It's hinted at that there's a little fragile girl hidden behind all that anger. Will be interesting to see who she really is.
Modifié par Xanfyrst, 19 janvier 2010 - 10:12 .
#74
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 09:27
StephenCharles
-
- Members
- 158 messages
i found ashley very annoying. morrigan all the way
#75
Posté 19 janvier 2010 - 09:32
TGore001
-
- Members
- 4 messages
Seeing as ME came out about what 2 years ago roughly...it will be even more enteresting to see who in ME2 (next week when it comes out) of the ladies match up with DA:O girls. Sense both titles would have come out closer so hopefully just as good dialog to say the least.
