Aller au contenu

Photo

So Cerberus is Indoctrinated? How cliche/anti-climatic....


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
271 réponses à ce sujet

#201
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages

littlezack wrote...

I really don't get why this bothers people so much. Cerberus has a long history of screwing with crap that comes back to bite them in the ass. On top of that, because of the way the organization works, all it would really take was the Illusive Man getting indoctrinated - from there, the Reapers could poison the whole system.

I don't call it lazy. I call it an inevitable conclusion.


It's lazy because it's uninteresting, not because Cerberus don't morally "deserve" it. At the moment Cerberus have been built up quite nicely as interesting, morally grey, villians, capable of fueling many ethical discussions. Now if it turns out they are indoctrinated, they are basically functioning against their will and little better than husks. The storyline in ME3 can be much more interesting if they are against Shepard for their own devious reason.

Even against the evidence we have seen, I still believe there is a lot more to it than Cerberus being largely, or completely, indoctrinated.

#202
Cirno

Cirno
  • Members
  • 37 messages
Wasn't Cerberus created in response to the Illusive Man's discovery of the Reaper threat?

#203
Guest_laecraft_*

Guest_laecraft_*
  • Guests

Getorex wrote...

Ahglock wrote...

Saphra Deden wrote...

Getorex wrote...

Ugh.  So here we have one of those "torture apologists" who likely was A-OK with Bush's (and now Obama's) torture system.


Damn right. People like you really need to wake up and smell the reality.


The reality that real life politics and game boards don't mix is what you meant right?  


Buddy, I've had all the 'reality' I need to make my judgements.  I'm a vet.  I've been to Iraq, have you?  Hell, I've been in the military for YEARS and I don't buy into that CRAP.  It's cowardly, it's unethical, it's unAmerican, it's against the friggin law (laws WE wrote for hell's sake - Reagan himself signed off on the Conventions Against Torture, Abuse, and Inhumane Treatment).  Some people hide under their beds, wet their pants, and scream and cry for mommy to torture the bad brown man (women and children too) so they don't have to look at brown people.  I wont have any of that crap.  Not in reality, not in games.  

Cowards drop their principles and their ethics at the first gunshot.  I wont tolerate that sh*t from anyone, superior or subordinate, civilian or miltiary.  Makes me wanna puke and beat the sh*t out of them at the same time.


Let us not confuse the human countries' politics with the situation we're facing at Mass Effect universe. Fighting for the survival and advancement of your species is the most ethical thing to do in this universe. You're backed up by the evolution itself, here. No goal is more noble than striving for continuing your genetic legacy, for it took millions of years for the organic life to get us where we are now, and if we're gone, this genetic munation might never happen again, and all the potential will be wasted, lost forever. I know that no humans of our real world ever experienced the situation where their very species has been endangered, but we can use our imagination.

In the end, it comes to this: will our genetic branch survive or be destroyed? Many species have perished into oblivion because they were not strong enough. Several yet are close to extinction. The Council will not fight for the survival of humanity. Several times already they showed that they don't care if humans are destroyed. The Alliance will not fight for the survival of humanity. They betrayed their own kind, abandaning them to their fate at the hands of the Collectors, for the sake of territory and politics. If the humans, too, give up on survival of humanity, then humanity is doomed. The species that doesn't care about its own kind will not survive - nor does it deserve to survive.

We have to fight for the Earth and for humanity's surivival. No price is too high for that. The torture of a few chosen individuals might seem to high, but only if you forget that if we don't find a way to defeat the Reapers, billions will suffer much worse torture at the hands of the Reapers, being liquified into a genetic goo, and no human will survive. The cycle will continue, everyone will be wiped out, and the next organic life will suffer the same fate as we do. Keep the stakes in mind. They're much higher than anything we could've experienced on Earth.

Again, please do not confuse the political goals of the real world with the situation in ME. The survival of our species is not some kind of an artificial territorial agenda invented by the politicians and meant to enrich some while dividing our own species. It's a real threat to all of humanity. And if humanity goes, the rest of the galaxy is going to hell, too.

#204
RoboticWater

RoboticWater
  • Members
  • 2 358 messages
I think that the only people indoctrinated are the cerberus troops not the Illusive man. If I was a cerberus trooper i joined cerberus to advance humanity, not join the reapers and destroy it. I'm also sure the Illusive man has some interesting reason for joining the reapers.

#205
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

Cirno wrote...

Wasn't Cerberus created in response to the Illusive Man's discovery of the Reaper threat?


Yeah, that's what the Evolution comics say.

#206
Rob Roy

Rob Roy
  • Members
  • 72 messages
I'm more interested to hear what the fate of the Illusive Man is. Somehow I don't think BW is just going to write him off as one of the indoctrinated. An indoctrinated IM would just kill anything and everything that was interesting about the character.

#207
I99I Dragoon

I99I Dragoon
  • Members
  • 121 messages
I like how this one Shepard line caused this......from a game none of us have played through yet.....

#208
Praetor Knight

Praetor Knight
  • Members
  • 5 772 messages

I99I Dragoon wrote...

I like how this one Shepard line caused this......from a game none of us have played through yet.....


True, and Shep has said some really funny and silly stuff in both games so far ^_^

#209
I99I Dragoon

I99I Dragoon
  • Members
  • 121 messages
I'm excited for the assumptions that are made from the next Shepard line...

#210
Destroy Raiden_

Destroy Raiden_
  • Members
  • 3 408 messages
It's not cliche I'm glad they're the bad guys again I'm looking forward to shooting every last one of them.

#211
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages

Destroy Raiden wrote...

It's not cliche I'm glad they're the bad guys again I'm looking forward to shooting every last one of them.

They can be bad without being indoctrinated. In fact if they are indoctrinated they are not evil because they are not taking their actions willfully.

#212
littlezack

littlezack
  • Members
  • 1 532 messages
I just don't think it's a surprise or a cliche - we've been told from the beginning that this is how Reapers operate. Earth is going to be hit hard as hell - it's the first place the Reapers' strike. Given that Cerberus is responsible - more or less - for stopping the Reapers in the last game, it makes sense that the Reapers would put top priority on getting them under control.

#213
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages

littlezack wrote...

I just don't think it's a surprise or a cliche - we've been told from the beginning that this is how Reapers operate. Earth is going to be hit hard as hell - it's the first place the Reapers' strike. Given that Cerberus is responsible - more or less - for stopping the Reapers in the last game, it makes sense that the Reapers would put top priority on getting them under control.

I agree with this. It's not a surprise at all. When we heard Cerberus was after Shepard it was the obvious answer. I just think, if that is the reason, they have missed a trick with the plot.

#214
littlezack

littlezack
  • Members
  • 1 532 messages
Not everything has to be a giant plot twist.

#215
HTTP 404

HTTP 404
  • Members
  • 4 631 messages
omg, a hero in a video game? so cliche....

#216
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages
Being indoctrinated is something of a plot twist. The actions they took in ME2 did not fit at all with that theory, although there was always the danger of it. Cerberus just being evil machivalian barstewards would not be a plot twist, they have been that way since the start.

Modifié par Malanek999, 04 juillet 2011 - 05:10 .


#217
littlezack

littlezack
  • Members
  • 1 532 messages
I honestly expect a LOT of humans to turn up indoctrinated - Cerberus will probably be the ones used most by the Reapers since they fit their needs, but, as near as I can tell, the Reapers are going to decimate Earth, then move on to the rest of the galaxy.

#218
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Malanek999 wrote...

Cerberus just being evil machivalian barstewards would not be a plot twist, they have been that way since the start.


Uh, no they haven't. They have certain goals and all of their actions should in some way serve those goals. Aiding the Reapers does not serve Cerberus' goals.

Bad writing. Bad twist.

I suspect it is just the outside world leaking into the game.

#219
HTTP 404

HTTP 404
  • Members
  • 4 631 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

Malanek999 wrote...

Cerberus just being evil machivalian barstewards would not be a plot twist, they have been that way since the start.


Uh, no they haven't. They have certain goals and all of their actions should in some way serve those goals. Aiding the Reapers does not serve Cerberus' goals.

Bad writing. Bad twist.

I suspect it is just the outside world leaking into the game.


have you not played Me1?  they killed Kohuku! damn them to heck!  Image IPB

#220
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

PiR8 Rob wrote...

I'm more interested to hear what the fate of the Illusive Man is. Somehow I don't think BW is just going to write him off as one of the indoctrinated. An indoctrinated IM would just kill anything and everything that was interesting about the character.


He's hands down my favorite character in the franchise and if it ends up being a case of "im indoctrinated lulz" I'll be disapointed to say the least.

#221
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

Malanek999 wrote...

Cerberus just being evil machivalian barstewards would not be a plot twist, they have been that way since the start.


Uh, no they haven't. They have certain goals and all of their actions should in some way serve those goals. Aiding the Reapers does not serve Cerberus' goals.

Bad writing. Bad twist.

I suspect it is just the outside world leaking into the game.

Their methods are extreme and immoral. They do have a purpose though and the philosophical question of whether their end justifies their means is what makes them interesting. If they are indoctrinated all the moral shades of grey go. They can be out to get shepard without working for the reapers.

#222
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

HTTP 404 wrote...
have you not played Me1?  they killed Kohuku! damn them to heck!  Image IPB


Kohuku was a traitor! He got what he deserved!

#223
Guest_Saphra Deden_*

Guest_Saphra Deden_*
  • Guests

Malanek999 wrote...

Their methods are extreme and immoral.


So is the Council. So is the Alliance. So is the entire galaxy.

Cerberus has noble goals and that's what matters to me.

#224
Malanek

Malanek
  • Members
  • 7 838 messages

Saphra Deden wrote...

Malanek999 wrote...

Their methods are extreme and immoral.


So is the Council. So is the Alliance. So is the entire galaxy.

Absolutely for the first two. Politicians are definately not bastions of morality. However Cerberus does violate a significantly higher number of our ethical viewpoints than the council or the alliance.

#225
Seboist

Seboist
  • Members
  • 11 989 messages

HTTP 404 wrote...

Saphra Deden wrote...

Malanek999 wrote...

Cerberus just being evil machivalian barstewards would not be a plot twist, they have been that way since the start.


Uh, no they haven't. They have certain goals and all of their actions should in some way serve those goals. Aiding the Reapers does not serve Cerberus' goals.

Bad writing. Bad twist.

I suspect it is just the outside world leaking into the game.


have you not played Me1?  they killed Kohuku! damn them to heck!  Image IPB


The only thing wrong about the Kahoku killing is that Cerberus didn't hire my Shepard to kill that son of a ****.