190 réponses à ce sujet

[Homey C-Dawg]

Garrus.

Although Shepards still the only one who could keep everyone alive too.

[Shep-ley]

Garrus has some issues but the most capable of it. After him, i choose Ashley. A krogan commanding multi-raced team is kinda risky.

[taffy_17]

Zaeed! He's like Shepard but take cheques!

[Dangerfoot]

I really haven't seen anything to show me why Shepard is such an amazing leader, the game just keeps telling me that and people keep listening to me no matter what I do.

[RelentlessEcho]

Miranda, with Garrus as second.

After most of his squad getting killed, I highly doubt he could ever lead another squad.

[Silentblaze]

Garrus: He's lead a vigilante team on Omega for months and 1 turncoat was how they were brought down.  The Shadow Broker Dossier says that leadership potential is overshadowed and unlikely to develop while under Shepard.  So if Shepard wasn't around Garrus should step up.

[alihou]

Justicar Samara...She's lived a long time and has so much experience... She'll demand respect and I believe she has the ability to lead... Garrus is on top of the list as well...

[Tamahome560]

snowfox522 wrote...

Tali could do it

WTF are you smoking dude? No seriously did Freedom's Progress and Haestrom get wiped from your memory? Try having Tali lead the Fire Team during SM, good luck!

Anyway, Garrus or Miranda would be able to pull things through for a while but they couldn't match Shepard.

[Homebound]

brokarian ftw.

[Guitar-Hero]

Garrus is my Shepards protegé so obviously he would be first choice... Otherwise.. i don't know.. Joker? for kicks, He would do a ****** poor job but atleast the team would go to their deaths laughing.

[King Gigglez]

I think it would be Garrus as my first choice... then a tag team, Legion for smarts and either Wrex and Grunt for brute force (and I think they would command respect)... but Garrus is definitely my first choice.

[Niulus Kriyk]

taffy_17 wrote...

Zaeed! He's like Shepard but take cheques!

And the only one that walks out alive!

[Shifty Assassin]

Garrus
Miranda
Wrex
VS

[Ianamus]

I don't know. My first thought was Garrus, but with such little squad interaction it's hard to tell what the others think about him. In ME1 he spends half the elevator convo's offending people and in ME2 his only interaction is mentioning said elevator conversations and results in Tali threatening him with a shotgun. Not a good sign.

Thinking about it more, probably Ashley. If she can overcome her prejudices and learns to fully trust the alien teammembers of the squad then she would be the most likely to keep everyone together and keep morale high. She also has a lot of combat experiance and is a spectre in ME3.

[Finis Valorum]

Well that depends on what the mission actually is doesn't it?
If Shepard where incapacitated during me1 or 2 where it is essentially a tactical mission to defeat a single target in time then it would definitely be Garrus or possibly Anderson.
However Me3 is most likely about building a grand coalition to face the Reapers themselves and I fear Garrus just doesn't display the tact and diplomacy necessary to get the politicians on his side so in ME3 I'd have to go with either Miranda, Kaidan, Anderson, or possibly Liara, now that she's the shadow broker. All of these would have a chance I think at forging the sort of coalition necessary to stand a chance against the reapers (and be a replacement protagonist for me3) if Shepard were to be unavailable for whatever reason.

[danteliveson]

Jack for the LOLZ.

[Threeparts]

Mordin for strategy, Garrus for tactics. I don't trust Miranda as far as I can throw her, and Jacob never proved himself to my Shepard. Neither Ashley nor Kaidan struck me as strong leaders, even if they're perfectly capable while following orders or going solo.

[100k]

Garrus.

Ashley, Miranda, and Jacob would all likely bicker about who should lead in Shepard's wake, but my Shepard at least would make sure that Garrus gets the role.

[Homey C-Dawg]

RelentlessEcho wrote...

Miranda, with Garrus as second.

After most of his squad getting killed, I highly doubt he could ever lead another squad.

If you recall however, Miranda also lost her team to an inside betrayer, just like Garrus.

[Repearized Miranda]

C9316 wrote...

Garrus, Miranda, and Ashley.

Miranda
Garrus
Ashley

(in that order)

[Team Value]

I think some people are confusing the fact that they like Garrus to mean that he would be a great leader. He isn't. He is too unsure of himself.

Kaiden is the most calm and level-headed and would probably be the best choice overall, but I think he would need Wrex as his second in command to make absolutely sure things got done no matter what.

[Repearized Miranda]

Team Value wrote...

I think some people are confusing the fact that they like Garrus to mean that he would be a great leader. He isn't. He is too unsure of himself.

Kaiden is the most calm and level-headed and would probably be the best choice overall, but I think he would need Wrex as his second in command to make absolutely sure things got done no matter what.

Uncertainty brings out the best in people - unlike the someone's who's too sure thenselves as it tends to make them overlook things and often times end up disappointed due to the oversight.

But let me ask you this. Why should Garrus not be considering based on being unsuccessful? Shepard been unsuccessful lots of tme, but people still see him or her as the end all, be all for humanity. Shepard should be uncertain as hell with all that pressure put on him/her and I bet this is so despite hiding it well.

[Wintermist]

I'd go with Garrus.