142 réponses à ce sujet

[madox_ii]

 He would be a good candidate for Spectre in my opinion. Independently he was alredy for the investigating Saren before Sheperd showed up and during the 2 year break he was fighting crime to help ensure galactic security, plus all the stuff he has done with Shepard. Aside from getting his whole team wiped out he seems like an ideal candidate. 

I know it's a bit late but it would be nice to see in ME3.

[ArcticMan94]

No. The Reapers deserve a fair chance.

[SandTrout]

ArcticMan94 wrote...

No. The Reapers deserve a fair chance.

LOL

Besides, Garus would not be able to get the support of the Council behind him. He's like ReneShep, but without Udina and Anderson backing him up.

[Reapinger]

Garrus would be a good candidate and he already seems to prefer to work pretty much alone

[Whatever42]

Renegade Garrus already washed out.

[Destroy Raiden_]

I think Garrus is 1% believable for spector compared to VS 0%. I know he was observed for it for many years but his father kept him out then later he decided not to do it. If Garrus showed up saying he was a spector I his back story aids in his believability and if you para'd him he might've changed his mind. VS however has nothing but convenience and political string pulling to get them into the spectors.

Modifié par Destroy Raiden , 02 juillet 2011 - 01:11 .

[Kusy]

You don't get a spectre status for killing random people in Terminus Systems, blasting citizens of the Citadel and rolling with a terrorist organisation... it would make sense post ME3 tho.

[Chuvvy]

Mr.Kusy wrote...

You don't get a spectre status for killing random people in Terminus Systems, blasting citizens of the Citadel and rolling with a terrorist organisation... it would make sense post ME3 tho.

But you do get Spectre status for being on a ship while someone else took A turian and a Krogan to save the galaxy. And you get Spectre status for yelling at some for stopping Collectors. If they can shoehorn the VS into Spectre status they can make Garrus one, he's a much better fit.

[CSunkyst]

Slidell505 wrote...

But you do get Spectre status for being on a ship while someone else took A turian and a Krogan to save the galaxy. And you get Spectre status for yelling at some for stopping Collectors. If they can shoehorn the VS into Spectre status they can make Garrus one, he's a much better fit.

Oh please, this isn't more of that insecure "WAH WAH, The VS had their own opinion and didn't suck up to me because I'm so insecure I need every character in the game to worship me and agree with everything I say or else they're stupid-pants" BS, is it???  

YES, Ashley is very capable of being a Spectre, if anything her pre-Spectre resume is MORE impressive than Shep's (Especially if in your game she led a group of Salarian spies into a warzone for a SUICIDE mission and somehow SURVIVED) 

Garrus spent two games whining about authority, and then he got his entire team killed.  Garrus isn't a serious Spectre candidate because he isn't so likely to be a good Spectre as much as he's likely to be a ROGUE Spectre.  He's talented, but giving him that kind of authority would be a very poor choice.   

[Spectre_907]

I agree. Garrus would make a better Spectre candidate than the VS. Garrus was already targeted as a Spectre candidate and he's the character that has been influenced the most by Shepard. There was already a mentor/student relationship between Garrus and Shepard in ME that continued in ME2 and Garrus lead a team that destablized major mercenary elements in the Terminus systems, which would benefit the Citadel races, on his own. Something the VS did not do. He seems like the more logical choice than the VS.

Modifié par Spectre_907, 02 juillet 2011 - 01:46 .

[Guitar-Hero]

Better spectre candidate than VS, i guess we will see,

[Chuvvy]

CSunkyst wrote...

Slidell505 wrote...

But you do get Spectre status for being on a ship while someone else took A turian and a Krogan to save the galaxy. And you get Spectre status for yelling at some for stopping Collectors. If they can shoehorn the VS into Spectre status they can make Garrus one, he's a much better fit.

Oh please, this isn't more of that insecure "WAH WAH, The VS had their own opinion and didn't suck up to me because I'm so insecure I need every character in the game to worship me and agree with everything I say or else they're stupid-pants" BS, is it???  

YES, Ashley is very capable of being a Spectre, if anything her pre-Spectre resume is MORE impressive than Shep's (Especially if in your game she led a group of Salarian spies into a warzone for a SUICIDE mission and somehow SURVIVED) 

Garrus spent two games whining about authority, and then he got his entire team killed.  Garrus isn't a serious Spectre candidate because he isn't so likely to be a good Spectre as much as he's likely to be a ROGUE Spectre.  He's talented, but giving him that kind of authority would be a very poor choice.   

I'm fine with people disagreeing with me, I mentioned it in passing and the post as a whole was more of a joke than anything.

[REgentleman]

@CSunky Fair enough, but don't get ahead of yourself, Shepard was special forces and waaaaaay higher rank than Ashley. Not to mention whatever prebuilt history Shep had would've put em up there. It was implied people were looking for whatever reason they could to give Shepard recognition at the beginning of ME1.

Modifié par REgentleman, 02 juillet 2011 - 01:48 .

[The C Trayne]

Slidell505 wrote...

Mr.Kusy wrote...

You don't get a spectre status for killing random people in Terminus Systems, blasting citizens of the Citadel and rolling with a terrorist organisation... it would make sense post ME3 tho.

But you do get Spectre status for being on a ship while someone else took A turian and a Krogan to save the galaxy. And you get Spectre status for yelling at some for stopping Collectors. If they can shoehorn the VS into Spectre status they can make Garrus one, he's a much better fit.

ok i don't want to sound like an idiot but i'm new to the forum and was just curious as to who or what the "VS" is??

also i think Garrus would be a decent spectre canidate. he has the skills and training and he didn't "get" his team killed like so many people are saying. he was set up by someone he trusted. anyone could fall for that even shepard or any other spectre.

and lastly, based on who survives on virmire kaidan or ashley, they do become a spectre just read about it on the mass effect wiki page. they get promoted after a time of working for them or something i'll have to find the page again and link it

[HogarthHughes 3]

The C Trayne wrote...

ok i don't want to sound like an idiot but i'm new to the forum and was just curious as to who or what the "VS" is??

also i think Garrus would be a decent spectre canidate. he has the skills and training and he didn't "get" his team killed like so many people are saying. he was set up by someone he trusted. anyone could fall for that even shepard or any other spectre.

and lastly, based on who survives on virmire kaidan or ashley, they do become a spectre just read about it on the mass effect wiki page. they get promoted after a time of working for them or something i'll have to find the page again and link it

You answered your own question, VS = Virmire Survivor

Anyways I don't think Garrus would have time to become a Spectre pre-ME3 as even if he is "renegaded" things don't go well in-between ME1 & 2.  I could definitely see it happening post ME3 though.

Modifié par HogarthHughes 3, 02 juillet 2011 - 01:56 .

[ThePwener]

Garrus is too rebellious and brash. He would make a horrible Spectre since he can't make choices by himself and always screws up here and there.

Don't pretend he doesn't! You know he does! He even admits it in the Femshep romance.

[CSunkyst]

Of course Shep was a higher rank, though the only reason Ash is so low on the totem pole is supposedly only because her family name is tarnished. I'm just looking at acomplishments.

Ash (and Kaiden) helped save the Citadel from a Geth attack (saved the whole damn galaxy really, but the council doesn't want to recognize that) she was the sole survivor of her unit on Eden prime, and her scores have always been above average. I say that at least rivals anything Shep did pre-Spectre. Especially sole survivor (sorry sole survivor fans) I was always under the impression that sole survivor Shep survived more so because he was lucky rather than skilled.

Unlike renegade Shepard, Garrus is reckless, not ruthless, which I think works against him when it comes to being concidered for Spectre status.

[rft]

In ME1 he did say he was liable for being a spectre. He would probably be the best person to be a spectre on your squad.

[SSJ5]

While Garrus has the necessary qualities to become a Specter I think that he will overgrow it over the course of Mass Effect 3. He might have been a Specter in ME2, but now its too late for that IMO.

[Repearized Miranda]

Garrus should be considered and while Ashley (or Kaidan) are, it really makes no difference to me. I just wonder if Ashley will be nicer to Garrus. haha

Modifié par Repearized Miranda, 02 juillet 2011 - 02:02 .

[SandTrout]

Ok, there seems to be a lot of people very vehement about the VS being a specter, one way or the other. I personally don't think that is unreasonable for the VS to be a specter, but that's really besides the point.

The question I really want to ask, is why some people seem to think that the VS has been confirmed as being a specter in ME3? I must have missed that press release.

[Mims]

I really hope they just let the VS be a specter and leave it at that. Making Garrus a specter would be pointless, since he already was selected for one and rejected it. Twice, if renegade. He's much better doing his own thing, or supporting Shepard. It's not like you have to be a specter to be a awesome. The VS are better candidates for being a specter because they're more even tempered. Ashley might be hot tempered, but she doesn't fight the system. Garrus wouldn't be happy there anymore then c-sec.

[ThePwener]

It was confirmed... I think. Well... someone had to have said something! Right....

[ThePwener]

Mims wrote...

I really hope they just let the VS be a specter and leave it at that. Making Garrus a specter would be pointless, since he already was selected for one and rejected it. Twice, if renegade. He's much better doing his own thing, or supporting Shepard. It's not like you have to be a specter to be a awesome. The VS are better candidates for being a specter because they're more even tempered. Ashley might be hot tempered, but she doesn't fight the system. Garrus wouldn't be happy there anymore then c-sec.

Exactly. I didn't need no stinking Spectre tag to save Humanity and do wathever I wanted. Spectres are overrated and whyen the VS tries to shove "I r Spector! Yu arnt" I'll SHEPARD PUNCH!!!!

[syllogi]

Ashley or Kaidan's new job is probably a plot point in ME3. Shepard can turn down the position in ME2, so if the plot demands having a Human Spectre around, having the VS fill that role makes sense.

The story doesn't *need* Garrus to be a Spectre.