60 réponses à ce sujet

[S.A.K]

Some of you might have noticed these poll I was doing in the last week. I gathered some interesting data about the reaction to various squad mates from the BW community. So here are the results.

Poll No | Character Name          Likes           Dislikes           Total votes
1               Tali                        310(76%)     63(15%)              409
2               Garrus                  257(79%)     39(12%)               322
3               Miranda                250(64%)     92(24%)              390
4               Mordin                  228(92%)     4(2%)                  249
5               Jacob                    111(45%)     67(27%)              247
6               Legion                   217(83%)     6(2%)                  260
7               Ashley                   181(61%)     65(22%)              297
8               Kaidan                   174(54%)     78(24%)              319
9               Samara                  162(70%)     22(10%)              229
10             Thane                    151(58%)     48(18%)              262
11             Grunt                      122(55%)     27(12%)              232
12             Jack                       135(59%)      56(24%)              232
13             Zaeed                     115(60%)      33(17%)             190
14             Kasumi                   157(81%)      10(5%)                195
15             Wrex                       170(89%)     3(2%)                  192
16             Liara                       171(65%)      51(19%)            262
The likes are the total of options 1 and 2. The dislikes are option 4. These show how any of the above characters are accepted by the Bioware community and NOT which character is best. The arrangement is done according to the poll number and NOT the winning order(I don't choose winners here). So don't start troulbe over that. If you want to know what characters are most anticipatd to return in ME3 by fans take a look at this poll.

Notice:
The polls are still running and the names in the table are linked to the polls. You can vote for anyone or all of them and I will update the results when ever I have time. The last polls need more votes anyway. YOU CAN USE THIS FORUM TO DISCUSS ANY OF THE ABOVE CHARACTERS. If you think your favorite is miss understood tell us what you think.

Rules:
These are the main forum rules. No spamming, no bashing, no fighting and absolutely no trolling. People who brake rules will be reported. Arguing is ok to a level. Please respect the rules and respect others.

About the squad mates in general:
I know most of you have a favorite. And you should undestand everyone else do as well. And they also love to see their favorite return in ME3. Every character has flows so no one is perfact just like us. This makes them realistic and intereseting. Most of them got over 50% likes and I think BW did a very good job on creating them.
Thank you. Tell me what you think...

Modifié par S.A.K, 04 juillet 2011 - 08:42 .

[D.Kain]

 What about Morinth? 

[Siansonea]

Those were great polls, S.A.K. And it's nice to see that the character with the highest "like" rating is Mordin. Non LI characters like Mordin and Samara are some of the most interesting characters for me personally, because their lives are their own, and not caught up in Shepard's.

[Ieldra]

As such things go, this is all pretty unrepresentative, even compared with earlier forum polls. Gives good approximation of those who bothered to vote, but those aren't that many, and the forumites here are a group slanted in several directions.

I wish we could see Bioware's statistics of romanced team members and those used on the mission. Perhaps they'll release them after ME3 is out and there's nothing to be gained any more by waging wars about it.

Modifié par Ieldra2, 02 juillet 2011 - 06:09 .

[S.A.K]

OMG I forgot Morinth, but how many used her anyway?

Modifié par S.A.K, 02 juillet 2011 - 06:01 .

[BlaznZero]

Tali and Garrus on the top?


Dear everyone else,


Get some.


(P.S. Disappointed with Liara and Legion's position though, I would think both would be higher)

[S.A.K]

BlaznZero wrote...

Tali and Garrus on the top?


Dear everyone else,


Get some.


(P.S. Disappointed with Liara and Legion's position though, I would think both would be higher)

They are not in winning order. Just the poll number. So Tali and Garrus or anyone else didn't win.

[mineralica]

It was an excellent line of polls. I especially admit you chose a perfect timing - neither spamming nor lifelong series. Congratulations, S.A.K.

[ladyvader]

S.A.K wrote...

OMG I forgot Morinth, but how many used her anyway?

20 playthroughs, used her once and that Shepard didn't make it through the SM.  So no crazy asari in any of my imports.

[Welsh Inferno]

Who the hell doesn't like mordin!? Numbers in the polls have changed alot by the way, update it!

[Big_Stupid_Jelly]

Welsh Inferno wrote...

Who the hell doesn't like mordin!? Numbers in the polls have changed alot by the way, update it!

He was a decent character, but i was fairly annoyed at him when he slagged Kirahee off.

[CroGamer002]

Put Morinth too.

[CroGamer002]

For those who cares, current order by precentage in like vs dislike:

• Mordin- 170( 94%)- 3( 2%)- 182
• Wrex- 109( 89%)- 3( 2%)- 122
• Legion- 168( 85%)- 6( 3%)- 198
• Kasumi- 105( 84%)- 5( 4%)- 125
• Garrus- 185( 81%)- 20( 9%)- 228
• Tali- 215( 76%)- 40( 14%)- 283
• Liara- 110( 74%)- 16( 11%)- 148
• Samara- 115( 71%)- 14( 9%)- 162
• Miranda- 201( 69%)- 54( 18%)- 292
• Ashley- 138( 65%)- 41( 19%)- 213
• Zaeed- 80( 63%)- 22( 17%)- 126
• Thane- 106( 61%)- 22( 13%)- 173
• Kadan- 131( 58%)- 48( 21%)- 227
• Jack- 87( 58%)- 37( 25%)- 150
• Grunt- 92( 55%)- 15( 9%)- 167
• Jacob- 89( 48%)- 45( 24%)- 186

I'm very suprised with this order.        

[Welsh Inferno]

Those who have lots of fans usually have lots of haters. I think we already knew that everyone around here(most) love Mordin, Wrex and Legion. Squaddies like Grunt and Thane have a lots of neutral votes which aren't taken into account of that poll also. I'm a little suprised to see Kasumi so high and Thane & Jack so low but otherwise expected.

[Asari_Party]

Mesina2 wrote...

I'm very suprised with this order.        

Romanceable characters are always controversial, I am not surprised.

[HTTP 404]

Zaeed has one bullet for all of those that dislike him.

yes you heard right: one bullet.

[XX55XX]

I used to do these character surveys a while back... Perhaps it's time for another one? It has been nine months.

Anyways, it's itneresting to see how binary you have made the choices. I offered respondents a chance to "score" the character. Perhaps, for the next poll, might you consider three options instead: "Like," "Dislike," and "Neutral?" There are many characters I am rather neutral towards.

[Well]

The order is surprising.

[VegasVance]

Not surprised by Jacob being almost forgotten, wait what was I talking about again?

[xSTONEYx187x]

I don't dislike any of the characters, although I do find Jacob and Kaidan to be a bit boring. Hopefully Kaidan isn't to "by the book" in Mass Effect 3.

(Even though he's only alive in 2 of my multiple playthroughs)

[Zephyrre]

I rather think that if Morinth were in the mix, she would work out about the same as Samara. They're both in the same part of the insane spectrum, just different shades of that particular color. Shame about Jack, though. A twisted bucket-load of crazy hate. What's not to love Jack's why I never go with Morinth. I have a rage-o-meter, and 'twixt Jack and Grunt, it's pretty much full. It's bad enough having two crew-members that started out wanting to kill me, I don't need a third who actually went for it.

[S.A.K]

Welsh Inferno wrote...

Those who have lots of fans usually have lots of haters. I think we already knew that everyone around here(most) love Mordin, Wrex and Legion. Squaddies like Grunt and Thane have a lots of neutral votes which aren't taken into account of that poll also. I'm a little suprised to see Kasumi so high and Thane & Jack so low but otherwise expected.

That makes sense. I kinda expected Mordin to get most likes. Even if we get more votes I don't think this will change.

[Chancer15]

What WHAT why is my boy thane so like not loved DONT DIE from your sickness